Want to replace my BMW 520d with a new Z4 roadster: Does it make sense

When I bought the 520d - I was more keen on buying a daily ride as it was my first luxury car.

BHPian tictactoe recently shared this with other enthusiasts.

Hi Friends,

I'm planning to change my current 520d to something more fun. I have been eyeing the Z4 since possibly 10 years. First it was beyond my reach. When I bought the 520d - I was more keen on buying a daily ride as it was my first luxury car. But now I'm really thinking of a roadster. I saw that BMW has refreshed its Z4. My heart still goes out to it. I want to know is that still a good choice in 2023 / 24 (its been around for sometime) and if it's practical on Indian highways (I even had trouble with speed bumps near Hampi in a 5 series). Anything else I should be aware of? I live in Mumbai if that matters.

Here's what GTO had to say on the matter:

If you love the Z4 since 10 years, go for it . Quick, fun, usable, backed by BMW's reliability & service network. Also consider the Audi RS5 which is fast & more practical.

Personally, if I'm spending so much money, I prefer pre-worshipped cars as most of them suffer rapid depreciation. Something like a used M3 or M4, Boxster / Cayman, 911 etc.

Here's what BHPian mgastor2022grey had to say on the matter:

Hi @tictactoe, The Z4 is a beast of a machine, yet very impractical. Are you a family of 2? Yes, go for it. Are you a family of 3/4? Retain the 520D and buy the Z4 (if pocket is not torn). Do you want something sexy but practical? Take the BMW M340i.

I'd actually say, used car market is on fire now, check in regularly and you will get some beastly deals. Follow TeamBHP's used car checklist and you are good to go.

If you just want to spruce up your 520D, try tuning it or adding a custom exhaust, something like that. You can even do a lateral upgrade as specified by GTO.

Here's what BHPian NazgulLOTR had to say on the matter:

Getting that itch for a new car again are we... awesome feeling that is.. You will have to give a few more details to be able to help on this conundrum.

Will you be letting go of the 520D? What else is there in your garage?

What will this car be primarily used for and how often? How many passengers and what luggage capacity?

Are you aware of the low GC and it's implications - can you live with it?

And there are a few ownership threads of the Z4 on the forum, go through them to understand the livability factor with something that exotic.. happy hunting..

Check out BHPian comments for more insights and information.