News
BHPian Hayek recently shared this with other enthusiasts.
TLDR Summary
Let me start by saying Please Read This Fully. But so far, after 40 days and 2350 km, I could not be more happy with the car.
Like
Things that Could Be Improved
We need a Third Car
As many of you may be aware, my primary car is a BMW X3 20d (F25), which I purchased in January 2017. Even though the car is now getting to nearly 7 years old and 56,000 km, I am quite happy with the car, and content to let it continue as my daily driver for the next few years.
My employer has a car scheme that lets me buy a new car every 4 years on very attractive terms, and when the X3 completed 4 years in 2021, I bought a VW Tiguan Allspace as a replacement for my wife's VW Vento. The Allspace has turned out to be a great buy as well - and is currently running up the miles at a faster clip than any car we have owned in the last two decades. We bought Allspace in March 2021, and thanks to the second wave of COVID-19, it took nearly three months to cross the 1000 km mark. But thanks to a combination of usage (largely chauffeur driven) by my wife, my in-laws (who came to live with us during the lockdowns and often go to visit friends and relatives in the suburbs where they lived prior to Covid), and my son (who has an increasing number of classes), it crossed 11,000 km by March 2022, 23500 km by March 2023, and is now at nearly 33,000 km. Not excessive usage for a car - but with three claimants who often need the car at the same time, we quickly realized that we probably need a third car - or at the very least, a second driver who car ferry my X3 around for when others in the family need it.
The option of making the X3 available for the rest of the family was quickly ruled out - even though I am now no longer finicky about letting a driver handle the car, I often need to head for meetings at short notice, and I was clear that I would need a car available for my use at all times. This was amply demonstrated when our Tiguan unfortunately had its windscreen chipped by a stone sent flying from Bombay's lousy monsoon roads and I found managing without the X3 while the Tiguan went for repairs quite inconvenient. Net result, we decided we needed to buy a third car. This would of course have to be bought without the benefit of my company car scheme - and the thought immediately turned to which car we should buy.
What Car?
I must admit that we have often been confused about which car we want to buy, especially when it comes to cars for the family. Back in 2010, when I bought my Superb, it was a fairly straightforward decision. Luxury cars were ruled out, I wanted an automatic, and hence the only serious contenders were the Honda Accord and the Skoda Superb. Our decision in 2012 was more complex. We started off with a consideration set of the Vento and the City, but because the Vento trim we wanted (Petrol Highline 1.6 AT) was not available, ended up scouring the entire market ranging from the Jazz to the 520D, before going a full circle and picking up our first choice. In late 2016, I was clear that the Superb replacement would be a luxury car, and it ended up as a two-horse race between the Mercedes GLC and the BMW X3 before the mouthwatering discounts that BMW gave in the post-demonetization phase swung the decision in its favor. Our Vento replacement was a more complex process - we started off loving the Kia Seltos DCT, but the long wait periods and the poor crash rating moved it down our selection list. We then test-drove the MG Hector DCT (very comfortable but terrible to drive), and the Innova Crysta 2.8 AT (as a substitute for the Innova Crysta 2.7 AT and the Innova Crysta 2.4 AT both of which were not available to be tested), before settling on the Tiguan Allspace which we once again got at a mouthwatering discount.
And this time round, we already had 2 very similar-sized SUVs which we were going to retain - one with a BS4 diesel power train, and the other a BS6 petrol. And consequently, we started our decision-making process with only one criteria that had more or less been set - that we could not add one more smoke-belching ICE card to Bombay roads. We were clear we wanted to pick up an EV.
Why an EV?
Continue reading BHPian Hayek report for more insights and information.