HOW IT ALL STARTED? June 2016 – We were on a lookout for a hatchback for my elder sister who was just starting to drive. My father was inclined towards Swift/Baleno. Further discussions in the family and we decided to go the Pre-owned Route. The reason was simple – less running, new driver (sister).
August 2016 – We bought home the Hyundai i20 Asta Petrol (2010 Model).
April 2017 - I turned 18 and started my driving classes. My sister, well she got scared of driving after having 2 minor bumps. This implied that the car was officially mine.
i20 is a very good car, no doubt about that but our car was not what we would call a “Well Maintained Car”. After a year or so, it started to reveal its true colors. My father and I were literally spending at least two Sundays a month in getting the car repaired. This included basic niggles as well as some major repairs.
Fast forward to June 2019 – i20 was yet again causing troubles. The car required new brakes, a new set of tyres, some small niggles that required attention.
This time my father insisted that we buy a new car instead of investing our time and money in this car. Initially, my mother was against this, but later we convinced her.
The Requirement- A petrol car – low running.
- Hatchback – Lack of parking space.
- A budget of 6.5 Lacs onroad.
- Should be comfortable for 4 + 1 occasional passenger.
- Decent Fuel Efficiency.
- Good Legroom (Me and my father are 6’2)
- Rear Defogger & Washer
Nice to Have Features-- Automatic Climate Control
- Alloy Wheels
- Push Start
- Touchscreen System
- Reversing Camera
My father asked me to go and check out the cars with mom and get quotes. This way we could get her opinion as well.
The Contenders
For me, I was looking for a car that could at least do what the i20 or provide a better experience. So I will be comparing various aspects of each car with the i20.
Cars from Maruti Suzuki and Hyundai were considered as my father didn’t want to go with any other brand.
1. Maruti Swift-
Before buying the i20, this was our choice as a brand-new car. Vxi variant was falling in our budget but it simply didn’t excite in the first look.
In terms of features, the swift Vxi was left behind by our i20.
Space at the back was also a bit tight. The interior felt a bit dull and the all-black look (although very sporty) made the cabin a bit cramped.
The test drive was good and coming from the i20 the steering felt a bit heavy.
Swift Vxi (P) came at around 6.9 Lacs On-Road.
2. Maruti Baleno-
This car was a bit of a stretch to the budget but was considered as the Delta variant offered pretty much everything that we wanted. It came around 7.25 Lacs On-Road for the Delta Variant.
Get in the back and there is oodles of space. I close relative owns Baleno diesel, so I was pretty much familiar with the car. The recent facelift added some good featured to the delta variant which made it appealing. It was also available in BS6.
But I had one problem with the car, Build quality of panels- The panels were prone to dents and dimples. I observed the same in my relatives’ car. The Interiors did not feel “Premium” to me. Our i20’s interior was better built.
3. Hyundai Grand i10-
I knew this car was good, but never really got a chance to observe in closely or have a proper drive. The car was good to drive, had enough space for our requirements, feature-loaded for the price point, quality interiors.
The car had ongoing discounts of Rs 90,000. This made the deal sweeter.
But wait, Grand i10 was due for an update in the upcoming months and would have a BS6 engine.
Selling the i20
The main concern of my father was getting the Car transferred as we faced a lot of problems in that aspect while selling our M800 to Cars24. Talked to various second-hand car dealers and they were quoting prices as low as Rs 1Lac and there was no certainty of when will they get a buyer.
So, we showed the car to the Showroom guys when checking the above cars and here is the best price offered among various dealers-
Maruti – 1,15,000 + 10,000 (exchange)
Hyundai – 1,45,000 + 30,000 (exchange)
The Final Decision
Taking into consideration all the factors, Grand i10 was coming out as a winner as it ticked all the right boxes and satisfied most of our needs and wants.
Regarding the upcoming update, I applied simple math-
The new model will be dearer by Rs 30,000 – Rs 40,000 (approx.). Add to that, the ongoing discount of Rs 1Lac. This comes around 1.4 lacs approximately.
If we look at the possible additions-
Engine- Same 1.2L, albeit with BS6.
Wireless Charging – Maybe, but I don’t need that.
Sunroof, Cruise Control – No chance, even the I20 doesn’t get that.
Looks – Well they are subjective.
So, it was clear that we will be going for the current generation car.
Variant & Colour Decision
This was a very easy decision for me. Sportz was the choice as it offered great value and features over and above the Magna variant at just 40,000. My father asked me to go for the Asta variant at one point in time but the 80,000 price difference just didn’t seem to justify the value addition.
I really wanted the Rear Wiper and the Alloy Wheels but the other features – Push start, ACC, Boot Light, Adjustable Rear Headrests, Chrome Door Handles, Auto Folding ORVMs was not that necessary.
My father was very fond of Hyundai’s Stardust (Grey) color. I liked it too. Probably the easiest decision of the whole buying experience.
Final Price
Ex-showroom Price: 5,99,990
Registration Charges: 30,573
Insurance (Zero Dep): 29,500
Handling Charges: 3,000
Fastag: 600
Extended Warranty: 7,399
Discount: (90,000)
Total: 5,81,062
Old Car Value: (1,45,000)
Final Payable Price: 4,36,062
Freebies included- Mats, Mud Flaps, Perfume, Tissue Box, Car Body Cover.
The D-DAY
We completed all the formalities and gave them the i20 by 5th June 2019. The car was in Stock and was April manufactured. The D-Day was set to be 9th June (Sunday) so that all four of us can take the car. But due to some problem the date had to be postponed. My sister could not get a holiday before Thursday, so we settled on 13th June, around 1 pm.
Thursday morning, I get a call from the SA that there is a problem from their end and they have to postpone the delivery to 6 pm.
We Reached the showroom at 6 pm and the car was getting ready. We go upstairs and complete the rest of the formalities. This is followed by a key handover, photo, and cake cutting. I checked the car again all around, checked the Odometer which was around 45km. By 6:30 pm we were out with the car. Overall, the dealership experience was good.
A QUESTION THAT MANY PEOPLE ASKED “Why would you buy an i10 after owning i20? / Why have you degraded?”
As mentioned above, the prime reason for buying a new car was the i20 being troublesome and we were in no intention of buying a new car before 2021. So the thought process was to buy a car that at least provides us what the i20 did and some things more. In simple words, to buy a car that we NEEDED and not that we WANTED.
So where have I “degraded”?
Just for a reminder, the cars in question are 2010 i20 Asta and 2019 Grand i10 Sportz.
In terms of features, Grand i10 loses on- Auto AC, Alloy Wheels, Rear wiper, 60:40 Split Seats, Boot light, Height adjustable driver seat, Telescopic steering, Variable speed for intermittent wiper, adjustable headrests.
What the Grand i10 has more than the i20- Touchscreen Infotainment System, Rear camera and sensors, Rear AC vents, DRLs.
Even though the Grand i10 has smaller dimensions on paper, I feel it has been packaged better. The thin seats liberate more room at the back. The less width is evident which means 3 people at the back will not be comfortable on long journeys. In terms of Back Seat experience, Grand i10 is definitely a step up.
Other differences will be covered as I move on with my review.