Re: Engine Oil Change : Paid Service vs Buying Oil yourself vs Full DIY Hi, new to the car scene in India, but here's what I've been doing in several European countries and the USA.
In essence I will try and do every maintenance and or repair job myself. I've never bought a car new myself, so warranty is something that never comes into play. Having said that, I've had lots of company cars back in Europe. In all cases we leased them and the lease company demanded you stick to the maintenance schedule religiously and take the car to main stream dealers only. So I did. Never touched the company cars myself.
There's several reasons I carry out all my maintenance. Firstly, I enjoy doing it. Secondly, I think I do a better job at it then most official and unofficial garages/dealers. I'm definitely not as quick as they are. But then again, as it is my hobby, my time is my own. I can take all the time I want. I can research all I want, I can ask my petrol head friends and come and help me out.
Most importantly, whilst working on my cars, it gives me a far better understanding on what needs doing, I'll be able to pick up things before they go wrong etc.
As this is my hobby, I'll gladly invest in special tools, even if I need them only once. Or make them up myself, or see if any of my friends have anything I could use.
Back in the Netherlands and in the US I had a good relationship with a few garages I trusted. If I got stuck, they would help me out, lend me tools, or let me watch and help along. You need to make it worthwhile for them, so I did let them carry out various jobs now and then as well, supply tires and or parts.
In the USA getting rid of your oil and other waste is no problem at all. All the car parts shops such as Autozone, O'Reilly will take that back from you as part of their service. They also rent out a host of different tools at very reasonable prices.
On the NEW Company cars:They were mostly BMWs, Audi's, Mercedes, Volvo's and the odd Ford and Volkswagen. As long as there was nothing wrong with them, their dealers are marginally ok at best.
I had a big bust up with Volkswagen years ago. I got the impression that they were not carrying out the required prescribed maintenance, but were still charging for it, admittedly through the leasing company, but still. So, for it's next service I marked each and every part multiple ways.
When I came back in the evening to pick up the car, I told them I wanted it on the lift/ramp so I could verify every item as I had marked them all. Big, BiG consternation. Within minutes I was ushered into the MD's office and he offered me his Audi A8 as a loaner for all of next week, whilst he would "double check" that the maintenance on my vehicle was carried out properly. So he was very much aware of what was going on.
I had issues with the Jaguar dealer in Kansas City as well. The one thing I won't /can't do myself is wheel alignment. I had a problem with the alignment of my XJR. Now, they take a bit of special treatment. Most quick fitters won't / can't do the job. So left my car with Jaguar and when I came back got a bull **** story why they couldn't fix it from the service manager. Told them to bring the measurements, the mechanic and let him explain to me what he'd done. He came, brought the measurements explained what he'd be doing.
I told him what he should have done. They were adamant that it could not be fixed. So I agreed with them, I would get it fixed, I would show them the new corrected measurement and they would have to re-imburse me. Took me a while to find a shop that really understood alignments and understood what was wrong with my car and fixed it all in under two hours. Humble pie time for Jaguar.
I believe one of the problems is that most dealers work by standard rates. So on a wheel alignment they have a fixed price, and they can't afford to work any longer on it, then the standard allows them. If they can't fix it in the allocated time, they call it "not-fixable", which is just rubbish.
Audi was the most and utter pathetic dealer I ever had the misfortune to have to deal with. Nothing big, just endless list of little niggles. Started by putting wrong registration plates on my car, which got me into a lot of trouble with various law enforcement agencies. Damaged the interior by swapping out a faulty radio unit. Replaced the cruise control 8 times in the space of two and a half year. Blew all its head light bulbs every 6 weeks etc. etc.
So my experience with high end cars and their dealers and their respective maintenance is sub standard at best. Not sure how it works here in India. But in the US/Europe Audi, Mercedes, Jaguar etc. will give you a complementary loaner as long as your car is in maintenance, they have very nice reception areas, with great free coffee.
As long as you have just standard maintenance and don't poke around what they're actually doing, and you don't mind footing a whopping great bill, you'll be fine.
Anything out of the ordinary, and you can run into problems pretty quick, especially if you start poking around and demanding to know exactly what they are doing, why they are doing it, why aren't they doing it differently etc/.
So I just don't trust them. They have to much staff that hoovers around you, pours you coffee, shows the next sales brochure, filling out form after form, washing your car, pester you with customer satisfaction surveys etc.
I'd rather be dealing with the mechanics myself. So I prefer small repair shops where the owner is very much present and in charge and who employs some real top notch mechanics.
I'd much rather get charged by the hour by somebody who really understands what he's doing, then to pay a fixed rate and hope it gets fixed permanently for that fixed price.
With modern cars electronics plays a more crucial part. You show me a workshop and I will tell you if they are capable of really trouble shooting and fixing electronic issues. If they have the latest and greatest diagnostics tool and not much else, run a mile! Because they won't have a clue. They can follow the steps the diagnostic tool gives them, but if that doesn't solve it, it's again "not fixable" or it becomes a question of hit or miss replacement.
Just read the other day, that Jaguar in the UK had came nr 1 in the JD Powell survey when it comes to customer services. Good for them! But I remain skeptical.....Maybe in a few years I should move to the UK and experience it first hand.
Jeroen |