Re: Mahindra Scorpio : Issues & Solutions I own a Scorpio (Crde, 2005 December) and the odo reads 85k. Fortunately, I never had to venture into this thread till now, however, lately for the past 3 months or so, there's a strange and erratic, overheating problem and I am here to seek expert advise...will try to explain the problem in detail...
My friend wanted to take my car for 10 day Kerala trip. On the day before trip, I gave the car for general service/checkup at Ignite Garage in Chennai. Car was delivered in the evening and it was fine. After driving it around 3km or so, in a stop-go traffic, I suddenly found the temperature gauge needle in extreme right position and the light started to blink. I immediately pulled over and stopped the car. After sometime, I cautiously opened the radiator to check coolant level and it was fine, but it was boiling hot. Called Raghav (Ignite) to seek his advice, he asked me not to drive any further. So I parked the car immediately (at a Hotel nearby) and next day I took it back to the garage. On my way back there was no overheating problem.
Mechanic at the garage did all preliminary checks and found that radiator water was boiling (he said its sign of overheating), and coolant level was down, but temperature never shot up. And when radiator was filled with water again, it drained off in short time(perhaps because of evaporation).
After the initial diagnosis, took him along for drive to re-create the problem and rode hard & fast for nearly 45 minutes and finally needle went above the half-way mark (exactly at toll booth, when I stopped to pay the fees), but it was ephemeral. Subsequently however fast/hard I drove, temperature didn't shoot up at all.
Since the problem was erratic, they came to a conclusion that overheating could be mainly because of the following reasons
thermostat not working properly
radiator leaking
crack in engine head
viscous fan not working
but they found that thermostat was working properly (did a test) and changed the radiator (felt old one was in a bad shape).
They didn't want to check the head and asked to report when the problem reappears. They couldn't find out whether viscous fan was working or not as they were not able re-create the problem at all...
After that I drove it for a month or so, there was no overheating problem. Second month problem reappeared, but it was less frequent ( may be twice in a month), again needle will go up to the right extreme, light will glow and immediately comeback to normal position. In the last few days frequency has gone up and in all the instances following was the pattern
Drove the car for 15 to 20 minutes
Got stuck in stop-go, bumper to bumper traffic
At such slow speeds temperature goes up almost to the extreme and comes back to normal position immediately
When I think about the previous situations when this happened, it seems to be the same.
After observing the problem I have arrived at the following conclusion, but one seem to contradict other.
a. Problem is not with actual over heating, but because of faulty gauge/sensor. Reason being, temperature comes back to normal in no time and this is not possible if there's is real overheating.
b. Mechanics at garage found water to be boiling and it is corroborated by the fact that water/coolant level reduction in radiator
This is where it stands and am looking desperately for help to sort out the issue... |