Brezza ZXi CNG or the Baleno Zeta CNG

Kartikaygaur · 16th September 2023, 14:20

Hello everyone,

I am currently grappling with a decision between two options: the Brezza ZXI CNG and the Baleno Zeta CNG.

Here's a bit of context regarding my current vehicles:

1. Innova Crysta 2.4 VX
2. Maruti Alto LXI CNG

The new car I'm considering will replace the Alto LXI, which has primarily served as a city car and has performed adequately thus far. However, it has become a bit too cramped for our needs, prompting us to consider an upgrade.

We've narrowed down our choices to the Brezza ZXI CNG and the Baleno Zeta CNG for the following reasons:

1. We trust Maruti Suzuki's reliability.
2. Both options are affordable with CNG.
3. We're looking for smooth engines that don't need to be overly fancy – just reliable and refined.
4. Good mileage is a top priority, which is why we're opting for a CNG car in the first place. We're not considering the Tata CNG options because their mileage appears to be on the lower side.

Now, here's the dilemma:

The Baleno is significantly cheaper by 3 lakhs on the road. It has an attractive appearance, excellent mileage, a rich set of features, and ample space.
However, the Baleno falls short primarily in terms of safety and its form factor. Despite having 6 airbags, I believe the Brezza would be the overall safer choice. Please correct me if I'm mistaken. Should we spend the extra 3L and get the brezza or save that money and get the baleno?

Kindly let me know your thoughts and suggestions.

Ry_der · 18th September 2023, 16:19

If the vehicle is to be used on highways, go for Brezza otherwise go for Baleno.

The build quality of Baleno is inarguably on the weaker side but it will compensate with the fuel economy.

bijims · 20th September 2023, 13:10

If mileage is the top priority, along with some safety features like 6 airbags, ESP, and Hill Hold, along with telematics, auto headlamps, driver armrest, etc. it's the Baleno CNG that wins it, it is both cheaper as well as more frugal than the Brezza CNG.

If crashworthiness (GNCAP 4 stars), power, SUV looks, a sunroof, etc. are the priority, then it's the Brezza that's the car to go for.

Assuming, your usage is primarily going to be in the City, and you can live with the hatchback form factor, I would advise you to save the 3 lakhs and go for the more well-rounded Baleno CNG.

Shreyans_Jain · 20th September 2023, 13:18

Brezza has a far superior suspension, resulting in significantly better comfort and handling. Steering feels more natural with a little bit of self centering action (Baleno has none). Visibility is better. Seating position is more natural. Then there is the bigger engine that provides a more relaxed driving experience.

All this without even talking about the build quality, the superior platform and crash safety. Budget permitting, Brezza is the one to go for.

Kartikaygaur · 24th September 2023, 09:43

Thankyou everyone for your valuable inputs. We have decided to buy the Brezza ZXI CNG. Test drove both cars and the brezza felt superior.

16th September 2023, 14:20	#1
Kartikaygaur BHPian Join Date: Mar 2020 Location: FARIDABAD Posts: 43 Thanked: 67 Times	Brezza ZXi CNG or the Baleno Zeta CNG Hello everyone, I am currently grappling with a decision between two options: the Brezza ZXI CNG and the Baleno Zeta CNG. Here's a bit of context regarding my current vehicles: 1. Innova Crysta 2.4 VX 2. Maruti Alto LXI CNG The new car I'm considering will replace the Alto LXI, which has primarily served as a city car and has performed adequately thus far. However, it has become a bit too cramped for our needs, prompting us to consider an upgrade. We've narrowed down our choices to the Brezza ZXI CNG and the Baleno Zeta CNG for the following reasons: 1. We trust Maruti Suzuki's reliability. 2. Both options are affordable with CNG. 3. We're looking for smooth engines that don't need to be overly fancy – just reliable and refined. 4. Good mileage is a top priority, which is why we're opting for a CNG car in the first place. We're not considering the Tata CNG options because their mileage appears to be on the lower side. Now, here's the dilemma: The Baleno is significantly cheaper by 3 lakhs on the road. It has an attractive appearance, excellent mileage, a rich set of features, and ample space. However, the Baleno falls short primarily in terms of safety and its form factor. Despite having 6 airbags, I believe the Brezza would be the overall safer choice. Please correct me if I'm mistaken. Should we spend the extra 3L and get the brezza or save that money and get the baleno? Kindly let me know your thoughts and suggestions.
	(1) Thanks

18th September 2023, 16:19	#2
Ry_der BHPian Join Date: Mar 2017 Location: Earth Posts: 156 Thanked: 335 Times	Re: Brezza ZXi CNG or the Baleno Zeta CNG If the vehicle is to be used on highways, go for Brezza otherwise go for Baleno. The build quality of Baleno is inarguably on the weaker side but it will compensate with the fuel economy.
	(1) Thanks

20th September 2023, 13:10	#3
bijims BANNED Join Date: Aug 2022 Location: Muscat Posts: 1,168 Thanked: 3,685 Times Infractions: 0/2 (19)	Re: Brezza ZXi CNG or the Baleno Zeta CNG If mileage is the top priority, along with some safety features like 6 airbags, ESP, and Hill Hold, along with telematics, auto headlamps, driver armrest, etc. it's the Baleno CNG that wins it, it is both cheaper as well as more frugal than the Brezza CNG. If crashworthiness (GNCAP 4 stars), power, SUV looks, a sunroof, etc. are the priority, then it's the Brezza that's the car to go for. Assuming, your usage is primarily going to be in the City, and you can live with the hatchback form factor, I would advise you to save the 3 lakhs and go for the more well-rounded Baleno CNG.
	(3) Thanks

20th September 2023, 13:18	#4
Shreyans_Jain Distinguished - BHPian Join Date: Nov 2013 Location: HR51/HR29/HR26 Posts: 2,981 Thanked: 23,828 Times	Re: Brezza ZXi CNG or the Baleno Zeta CNG Brezza has a far superior suspension, resulting in significantly better comfort and handling. Steering feels more natural with a little bit of self centering action (Baleno has none). Visibility is better. Seating position is more natural. Then there is the bigger engine that provides a more relaxed driving experience. All this without even talking about the build quality, the superior platform and crash safety. Budget permitting, Brezza is the one to go for.
	(2) Thanks

24th September 2023, 09:43	#5
Kartikaygaur BHPian Join Date: Mar 2020 Location: FARIDABAD Posts: 43 Thanked: 67 Times	Re: Brezza ZXi CNG or the Baleno Zeta CNG Thankyou everyone for your valuable inputs. We have decided to buy the Brezza ZXI CNG. Test drove both cars and the brezza felt superior.
	(1) Thanks