Quote:
Originally Posted by pramods Haroon would be able to provide more input and may be able to give a better comparative view.
-Pramod |
Quote:
Originally Posted by mobike008 +1. That would be an interesting comparison Haroon, iam sure you rode both GS1200 and Tiger 1200 extensively in your global rides.
May we request you for a " What I like" & " What I don't" for both these bikes  |
Friends, while I have spent lots of saddle time on a variety of BMW bikes, I have to admit I am severely limited on Triumph. By coincidence few months back when I was returning the rented bmw bike after our Adriatic trip to the rental company, I had the chance to take their Explorer 1200XC on a short ride around their part of town in a corner of Ljubljana, Slovenia. So I can only share so much information based on that small ride on the XC. Also, I am yet to ride the redesigned 2014 Liquid Cooled(LC) 1200GS although I rode for the trip its sport-touring sibling- the 2014 R1200RT LC, so my experience is based on the previous air/oil cooled 1200GS.
On a good sunny day, I am about 6ft tall and weigh close to 88kgs.
Ergonomics
In general the 1200XC and 1200GS are almost on par for my frame. The reach to the ground on the 1200XC probably a tiny bit longer but not significant as I can almost flat foot on both bikes. It may not necessarily just be the height of the bike but probably the seat width/angle also could have made the difference on the XC. The reach to the handlebars on both bikes are similar. The foot pegs are also almost identical but may be the 1200XC footpegs were a wee bit higher. Sitting posture very very comfortable & identical on both bikes with handlebar width also almost identical. Personally for me the stock seat of the GS sucks. So I have a custom seat on my bike. The stock seat of the XC felt a bit better, but I cant give a verdict unless I spend atleast 2-3 hours on the saddle. The wind protection are almost identical on both bikes and the windshield can be adjusted manually with 2 knobs on both bikes with the bike stopped. On the 2014 GS the windshield can be adjusted on the move with a single knob.
Slow-speed handling
The 1200GS felt better, probably due to the lower Center of Gravity of the boxer engine, whereas the 1200XC felt a little top heavy to me and generally it felt a tad bit heavier to move the bike on foot. I felt the turning radius on the GS was better than the XC. As far as High speed handling/braking etc- Sorry no experience on the XC, so I cant make a comparison. At stand still when you twist the throttle on the GS, you can feel the bike wanting to tilt to the right (that’s the jacking effect from the pistons of opposed twin engine conveyed to the drive shaft), no such special effects on the XC!
Engine
People new to BMW boxer engines will initially feel the vibrations like a stone crusher machine and the sound like a sewing machine, but once you get used to it, its torque is simply enjoyable esp in twisty mountain roads (BTW, the new 2014 liquid cooled BMW boxer engines are a tad more smoother, powerful & have a deep throaty sound). The 1200XC engine on the other hand was butter smooth and I really really loved the engine note. Its music to the ears. And a sudden twist of throttle on the XC can really catapult you into orbit.
Suspension
No contest on the front end. The BMW tele-lever on the front is way superior esp on rough patches & uneven surfaces, road humps etc you just don’t feel the fork dive. The rear suspension on both felt almost similar. Ofcourse, I did not have the time to play around with the Triumph suspension as it was more of a goodwill ride...The BMW has the electronic suspension adjustment, but I prefer the old fashioned manual setting type (less things to go wrong).
Price
While the GS is an iconic bike that is generally known for its reliability, appreciated for its technology/riding performance by having amply proved its capabilities all around the globe (but coming with a premium price tag in India!), the Triumph XC although a new kid on the block, I still feel it is also a tough built bike oozing with high quality fit & finish and is good value for money (in relative terms). Added to that the dealer support from Triumph I gather at present is among the best in the Indian market. Approx OTR Price for 2014 1200XC 20 lacs and the 2014 1200GS Adv 35 lacs…
While the GS & XC may be classified as ‘Adventure Touring’ bikes, these are supremely capable & comfortable touring bikes. So its not necessary that you always have to chase the sahara desert or Leh/Ladakh to really enjoy their potential. They are perfectly at home on good tarmac roads as well all across the country. And as a bonus when our highways go from bad to worse, you can still leave your sportbike riding buddies in the dust while keeping up with them on the twisty bits

. Therefore, if you have the budget and want one ‘do-it-all bike’, these are the bikes to have. You wont go wrong with them on that front!