Quote:
Originally Posted by manolin Hope you have read the Lambhorgini story. Forget piddly little Jeep or Landrover, they were a tractor manufacturer who put Ferrari to shame.
3) Currently they are making motorcycles only because there is gap between Demand and supply of cruisers and they can mint some cool cash pretty fast ,not because they are passionate about Motorcycles! Whoaa! And Harley cares? and Harley is on an evangelical mission to bring real motorcycling to the misguided? |
Points well-taken. Moto-Guzzi's V-Twin was also of tractor-origin... and ultimately, 99% of all companies out there are in it for nothing more than market-share...
BUT:
While HD may not exactly be on an "evangelical mission" let me share this: I visited their assembly plant in York, Pennsylvania (USA) in the mid-nineties and can say that at that time, at least, the parking lot was full of Harleys of all ages (bikes got to park right in front of the building, too, whereas car-drivers needed to walk across it from further recesses); ALSO it was the case that the assembly lines were staffed with "real bikers" - people absolutely passionate (and blindly prejudicial) about Harleys - traditional long-haired biker types in denim vests and bandanas, sporting tattoos on bulging biceps; the type who probably would've been full-time hoodlums if they'd not found this one sort of useful daytime employment they were willing to be engaged in. Now, that might not be the kind of image that the typical Indian buyer is after, but it does speak to the fact that it is a machine that has long inspired strong emotions and loyalties - a
religion, if you prefer - and has created a variety of images for those who ride them during the various periods of the company's existence. Hyosung may someday create their own image and following... but I don't think it will ever compete with H-D on the same terms.
Harleys at the time of my visit (as they had been for a long time) were notoriously unreliable - oil leaks and the occasional electrical fire and whatever... I had thought of buying stock in the company (as certain market analysts recommended) till I saw the shoddiness of the plant and heard the bad ownership stories and realized (from spec-sheets) how under-performing the machines were compared to the Japanese copies. Surely they could not keep duping customers indefinitely. Could they??? But for some reason, there was at that time a two-year waiting list to buy a new H-D; Used ones cost more than new for that reason. And inexplicably as time went on, people kept buying these inferior machines; I'd have become a rich man if I'd invested my money in their stock back then. It just seemed WRONG. But this was before I realized that at this level of motorcycling, common sense is not really involved that much in the purchase / ownership experiences.
So let me say this in conclusion: If I was going to buy a premium cruiser bike and run it for five years and then replace it with my next toy, the Hyosung would be very tempting over the H-D indeed, since it probably is as reliable and rides as well in every way, for a bit less cash. I do think it is an interesting machine that will probably serve a certain kind of buyer very well.
But if I wanted to keep a bike and live with it and keep it / ride it till I grew old, there's nothing current in India that could better the H-D (or, on the relatively lower end, a Royal Enfield, which philosophically and historically seems to have been on a very similar track as HD the past several decades). H-D R&D has always been slow and methodical and a bit "behind" the rest of the world, with the benefit that they've remained comparatively simple and serviceable, with many owners (abroad) continuing to do their own maintenance / modifications, etc. Biking tends to inevitably involve this sort of "individualistic" image - so if you can't modify your bike to your own tastes, then how much of that image are you able to rightfully own? Parts supply for H-D in the U.S., Europe and elsewhere is supported by numerous aftermarket suppliers - for upgraded clutches, gears, pistons, valves, exhausts, carbs, big-bore cylinder kits, chrome, straight-pipes, etc, etc, etc... and it will probably always be that way.
And it will probably NEVER be that way for Hyosung. It must be a great machine, but it's also a niche-market, uniform cookie-cutter thing made by what has been till now something of a third-rate Asian manufacturer. It wouldn't be unprecedented if the company was able to upgrade its image somewhere down the road (as humble Hyundai did to some degree in the North American market, and like Guzzi and Lambo somehow did in their own time); but I just can't quite believe that it will ever capture the
imagination of the masses the way HD or RE have done - which is, for better or worse, a lot of what also defines the ownership experience for many. You can draw numerous other comparisons - CBR vs. Ducati, etc (twenty years from now, the CBR will probably be little more than a tired and outdated sportbike, and the Ducati will be a sought-after classic). Right or wrong, that's how it's almost always gone.
Let's be honest. Nobody in India really NEEDS a large-displacement bike of any kind. It is a toy, a luxury, a status thing, unchecked hedonism, whatever. So we're not talking strict practicality and bang-for-the-buck here, and thus such bikes can't really be evaluated from a spec-sheet. The overwhelming majority of those who dream of owning one never do - but it's the history, the image, the elusive possibilities that make such machines desired and satisfying. Never mind the fact that the majority of those who DO come to own one never actually break loose of all their encumbrances and just take off on an extended, open-end exploratory ride across the country... But people were doing that sort of things on H-D's all over the world a few generations before anyone heard of Hyosung. I think that at the heart of all human aspirations is - on an actually spiritual level - FREEDOM, ironically hand-in-hand with a kind of perseverance (i.e., "ETERNITY"). It is impossible to truly attain in this world; indeed, and the One who promised it taught, "Narrow is the path that leads to life, and few that find it." Maybe a certain kind of machine can better connect with such inner yearnings. It can't actually fulfill them. But in faith, some believe it will. At the least, there may be a fleeting glimpse that seems (for some) to make all the impracticality and excess worth it...
I suspect that the Hyosung service network is never going to be very extensive in India, and that these bikes are going to just get old and die - probably when the FI ECU fails, if not before. Ironically, H-D's may always be a bit "inferior" and impractical compared to would-be competitors; but their lasting presence, the loyalty they evoke, the passion with which many owners regard them, assures that in the LONG run, they might end up being the most practical and satisfying after all. Strange twist, but true. Depends what you're in it for, and for how long.
In the meanwhile, enjoy your ride. The Hyosung should make it easy to do so, and will likely grant many smiles.
-Erik