Re: Manufacturing defect in Kia Seltos-Serious Safety hazard due to poor visibility Quote:
Originally Posted by Axe77 Thanks for that extremely detailed outline. I’m curious if this is a problem in corresponding Hyundai sister models too. If not, surely they can move asap to the Hyundai approach to these lights as opposed to let this issue carry on.
Agree that Kia should cover the consequential replacements beyond the warranty period as well under a goodwill gesture if this is indeed a design flaw. |
Yes, it is, the severity and pattern of condensation differs on different car models. I have visually inspected my cousin’s older version Creta and my friends new Hyundai Exter showing similar issues, aesthetically it looks very bad and you can't remove it, it’s recurring in them too, both suffer from this visible moisture condensation issues. Flawed design and aggressive cost cutting measures to reduce size, absence of mechanical ventilation like a heatsink with fan are leading to these issues. i am attaching images which were shared online by other owners of these vehicles facing high moisture condensation issues with their Car for your reference. from my experience i have learnt that the condensation severity is a function of time, the longer the vehicle is driven with lights on ,more severe condensation and fogging appears. Yes, it is, the severity and pattern of condensation differs on different car models. I have visually inspected my cousin’s older version Creta and my friends new Hyundai Exter showing similar issues, aesthetically it looks very bad and you can't remove it, it’s recurring issue in them too, both suffer from this visible moisture condensation issues. Flawed design and aggressive cost cutting measures to reduce size, absence of mechanical ventilation like a heatsink with fan are leading to these issues. I am attaching images which were shared online by other owners of these vehicles facing high moisture condensation issues with their Car for your reference. From my experience i have learnt that the condensation severity is a function of time, the longer the vehicle is driven with lights on, more severe condensation and fogging appears. This issue is not just a design flaw—it’s incredibly annoying and frustrating for owners. I experienced this firsthand while driving to Pune from Nagpur on the Samruddhi Mahamarg at night. I had to stop multiple times since I was continuously losing visibility on the road due to the severe condensation in my car’s front lights. This is a serious safety hazard, especially during nighttime driving, and there’s no permanent solution available till date. It’s unacceptable for such a critical defect to remain unresolved, putting drivers and others on the road at risk. Quote:
Originally Posted by NomadSK Unfortunately that’s incorrect, you are actually defying the laws of thermodynamics. It’s a normal ambient air inside the assembly which will have moisture depending on the temperature. Higher the temperature higher the capacity to hold moisture. That’s why you use hair dryer (warm) to dry yourself, it sucks the moisture from your skin.
But if I would be a designer, I would put pure nitrogen or any inert gas (that’s why you have halogen) in the assembly because they are huge heat sinks and don’t expand or absorb moisture, but I’m sure automotive engineers would have thought about this and would have challenges to implement this, which I don’t know of.
It’s not if you know what you are suggesting.
Sealed to what, air or water ? For water, dust, particles ingress, yes they are sealed. But if you seal for air/moisture ingress/egress, you will explode/implode the assembly while heating/cooling cycles. Pls don’t mix water with moisture.
Yes true, that’s what engineers do.
I’m not denying that it would be a design flaw. I’m just giving the explanation behind the WHY’s. To me it looks like the breather vents aren’t designed properly or are not capable for the heat generated by all the components installed or crammed in a small space. That’s why in my earlier post I wrote about installation of a breather vent.
Anyway nothing more to add. |
I’m sure it’s a design and manufacturing flaw. It seems like the breather vents alone just aren’t enough to handle the heat generated by all the components crammed into such a small space in newer designs. The vent holes in my cars light assemblies are similar as shown in the representation image, but they’re simply not enough to control the humidity and moisture levels inside the light assemblies of my car. What’s really needed is mechanical ventilation with fans to actively move moisture and humidity out of these assemblies. Unfortunately, this was likely removed as a cost-cutting measure, which has led to all these ongoing problems. Quote:
Originally Posted by electric_eel Just curious How do these ventilation vents look like ? Are they (in general) visible from outside ?. I have been driving in Kerala for the last 7 years and during monsoon humidity is generally high here. Even when there is heavy rains I have rarely seen this level of condensation both in my old Maruti zen or in my Nexon EV. Granted they are both fitted with Halogen lamps and not leds but still it suggests something seriously wrong with the headlight assembly. |
I completely agree with you. I owned a Hyundai I20 for ten years and drove it for over 1.2 lakh kilometers, in all kinds of weather and even cross-country. Despite having aftermarket LEDs fitted, I never faced any issues with the headlight assemblies of my I20. The car was reliable throughout, and I never had to worry about condensation or fogging reducing visibility and damaging light components prematurely and permanently. Now, looking at the new car with so many defects, I can’t help but regret selling the I20. The issues new owners facing are a clear result of failed quality control and assurance by KIN, which is incredibly frustrating. It’s disappointing to have a brand-new car with so many built-in problems, especially when the old one was so dependable. Aggressively cutting cost is causing all sorts of problems and disregarding customer satisfaction and safety which is unacceptable. Neither KIN dealership nor KIN has a permanent solution to this severe defect till date. |