Today's Times of India report paints a sad picture of the aftereffects, post the massive traffic offence fine hikes effected from September 2019. The report displays statistics reflecting the fatality figures, comparing it with 2016-19 when 12,500 deaths were reported. Correspondingly between 2019-21 a total of 12,138 deaths were reported. The lock down year 2020 has though been mentioned, when the crude oil import bill and accidents were quite lesser. E-challans yielded Rs 7,870 crores between September 2019 to February 2023 to the respective state /UT exchequer that the report says is 450% higher than that realised during the previous corresponding years.
The TOI report dwells upon the sadistic attitude of our traffic authorities, who are not well behaved, extract fines and feel that their jobs are done. Fines multiply, add to the govt coffers and violation and injury/death figures also rise . Driver behaviour needs improvement. It says that scientific enforcement with proper education and corrective measures for offenders need to be taken as is done in many developed countries.
Discussing the TOI report, common sense says that apart from the amount officially realised as fines by traffic authorities, an unknown amount that could be much, much higher than the Rs 7,870 crores collected, could have ended up as black money in the way of bribes to waive off penalties. If the official fine is Rs 5000/- for an offence, bribing anything between Rs 500 to 1 K make both the offender and enforcer happy and hence the magnitude of such illegal transactions are not known nor reported.
And as regards accidents, deaths and injuries we have people travelling by the dozens in MUV taxis, a dozen or more on a three wheeler, scores on a tractor trailer, three or four on a two wheeler and so on. Coming to heavy commercial vehicles, trucks are as a rule overloaded by upto 1.5 to 2 times or more of their official capacities. Buses are dangerously overloaded. More than 80% cars on our roads have the coveted ZERO STAR NCAP rating.
I remember a joke about an overloaded Ambassador taxi being challaned in Bihar. It was carrying 28 passengers. When produced before a judge, the driver was asked:
Judge to driver : I am curious to know how you could fit all the 28 passengers into your car.
Errant taxi driver: Your Honour, you can please come with me outside. I can also fit you as the 29th passenger.
-With such a backdrop, where do we apply scientific methods for traffic management?
-When, how and where do we undertake driver education?
-How do we conduct strategic enforcement going by what the TOI news report quoted experts suggest?
-How do we improve driver behaviour as the report also suggests?
The only pittance or microcosm of knowledge added to our brain's reservoir about traffic laws is when we prepare for our driving licence tests. Thereafter, the licences get automatically renewed every five years. After many 5+5+5+.... years, the pittance or microcosm of traffic law knowledge gets deleted or else the file becomes corrupt in our brain, over the years for a majority of us.
It's sad that pragmatism and realities at the ground levels are ignored and we talk about some western concepts that cannot be copied and pasted to get applied here. Boardroom ideas need to be shunned and other root level causative factors should be identified. It needs constant, level headed thinking.
Quote:
The fines for violation of traffic and transport rules were increased manifold after the amended provisions of the Central Motor Vehicle Act came into force from September 2019. The data provided by the road transport ministry to the Lok Sabha shows that the revenue collected for such offences through e-challans rose to Rs 7,870 crore between September 2019 and February 2023.
However, analysis of the road death data shows that the average fatalities per month during 2019-21 was 12,138 compared to 12,500 deaths during 2016-19. The government is yet to publish the road accident data of 2022.
The purpose of traffic enforcement is to improve driver behaviour. In the developed world, police understand the law and consequently the causes and consequences of road traffic violations. They conduct strategic enforcement where they ensure that as enforcement of such violations is conducted, driver behaviour is also improved and deaths and injuries are reduced. In India, police are unaware of the law and also of the causes of violations. They have a sadistic outlook to book drivers and collect fines. Fines go up and so do violations, accidents, deaths and serious injuries," said road safety expert Rohit Baluja. |
The link :
https://m.timesofindia.com/india/ste...w/99000641.cms