Team-BHP
(
https://www.team-bhp.com/forum/)
-
Road Safety
(
https://www.team-bhp.com/forum/road-safety/)
Quote:
Originally Posted by skanchan95
(Post 2712551)
...God knows what would have happened if I had been on the highway doing 80-90 kmph.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by vikram_d
(Post 2712935)
...And after reading your post above it is clear that the failure in your case was electronic and not mechanical. If it was mechanical, the steering would have completely jammed up or you would have lost complete steering (steering wheel would turn but your car would not react) and you would not have been able to steer at all. So on your trip with you dad you would not have realized this problem at highway speeds and would have driven normally.
...
|
skanchan95,
vikram_d answered your fear as in the first quote.
What he meant was you wouldn't have realised the "hardness" at highway speeds of around 80kmph
Quote:
Originally Posted by skanchan95
(Post 2714220)
Even if we assume that the EPS cut off automatically, why did the EPS warning light come on immediately after the steering became rock hard? Had it not been a malfunction, the EPS light should not have come on. The steering became rock hard(both times) after I heard a "click" sound from the steering column area. I am dead sure it wasn't the "normal" EPS cutting off.
At the time of the incident, I was within city limits, may be doing 35-40 kmph. The steering surely is not supposed to become rock hard at those speeds. It remained rock hard even after coming to a complete stop, it wasn't normal, whichever way one looks at it. Only restarting the engine seemed to correct the steering. Has anyone ever tried steering a car with the engine off? That's how hard the steering wheel felt that day...
|
Also as mentioned in your post above and the picture in it...
It is not supposed to be hard at city speeds, but because of this "electronic failure" you felt the "hardness" and the light has come on.
That "click" sound you are talking about must be from the ECU.
Because of the electronic failure, it was reset when you restarted and for the same reason, there is only a distant chance of an accident (As it is nothing but like driving a car without PS for example a M800).
This is where a Hydraulic Power Steering(HPS) is better than an Electronic Power steering(EPS) because it is less prone to such frequent failures.
There is a thread on TBHP titled somewhat like
"How Flatbeds would run out of business..." which is like a mirror to the present day fact that too much of electronics in cars leads to more such problems
Anyways for your problem, go and show this to the A.S.S and get this rectified which may need a ECU flashing.
Afterthought: Was the power brake also hard??...If yes, it might be a recipe for an accident than just this steering problem.
Quote:
Originally Posted by hemanth.anand
(Post 2714367)
skanchan95,
vikram_d answered your fear as in the first quote.
What he meant was you wouldn't have realised the "hardness" at highway speeds of around 80kmph
|
Maybe not, but the same hardness could have resulted in a major accident while overtaking or changing lanes(as mentioned before, it remained hard if every after having come to a complete stop). Only I know the hard time that I had trying to make the car stop in time that day. In fact when the steering became hard for the second time that evening, I barely managed avoiding the road divider.
Quote:
Originally Posted by hemanth.anand
(Post 2714367)
Anyways for your problem, go and show this to the A.S.S and get this rectified which may need a ECU flashing.
Afterthought: Was the power brake also hard??...If yes, it might be a recipe for an accident than just this steering problem.
|
The incident happened in
December 2010. The braking was normal.
The EPS malfunction seemed like the ultimate critical failure, after having struggled with Hyundai to get the steering rattle. I was always afraid that thanks to the horrible steering rattle issue, one day the steering could malfunction someday.I had even wrote about this fear to HYundai in my big complaint to Hyundai bigwigs. My worst fear came true that December evening and Hyundai fellows behaved as it was a normal incident, not even caring for the car's and therefore our safety!!
If you want to know what all "experiments" in the name of fixing steering rattle issue were done on the car, prior to the EPS malfunction, please read this( the first post in my ownership thread) :
http://www.team-bhp.com/forum/long-t...ml#post2088225.
If you read further, you will realise that my troubles only got worse thereafter, be it the pathetic little Hyundai workshop in Junagadh or the RO or the company itself.
Please start a thread on the i20 steering issue! This isnt the thread to be discussing this as its completely OT.
Cheers!
Quote:
Originally Posted by binand
(Post 2714361)
The car they were travelling collided with a tipper lorry on the Sulagiri bypass at 5:30 AM. The lorry was going to Krishnagiri.
|
Thanks. Here is an article with picture. http://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/Coimbatore/article2994411.ece
Horrible accident. May their souls RIP. It says the vehicle is an SUV, but looks like a sedan to me.
^^
Bad bad crash. Looks like a Fiesta to me, looking at the rear quarter panel and the door!
May their souls RIP!
Quote:
Originally Posted by anachronix
(Post 2714664)
^^
Bad bad crash. Looks like a Fiesta to me, looking at the rear quarter panel and the door!
May their souls RIP!
|
The article says SUV. It does not seem like one, doesnt seem like a Fiesta too. Seems like a Skoda or VW to me. Alloys say so.
Quote:
Originally Posted by DRIV3R
(Post 2714696)
The article says SUV. It does not seem like one, doesnt seem like a Fiesta too. Seems like a Skoda or VW to me. Alloys say so.
|
Look at the tires, those are GY GT3! None of the Skoda or VW came with the GYs!
The alloys looks like the one that comes in the Figo Titanium. The Fiesta Classic is now available in this color!
Quote:
Originally Posted by anachronix
(Post 2714705)
Look at the tires, those are GY GT3! None of the Skoda or VW came with the GYs!
The alloys looks like the one that comes in the Figo Titanium. The Fiesta Classic is now available in this color!
|
Well, could be! Or could be a Polo/Vento? Does Ford stick variant bar code labels on the right rear quarter glass?
Quote:
Originally Posted by DRIV3R
(Post 2714740)
Well, could be! Or could be a Polo/Vento? Does Ford stick variant bar code labels on the right rear quarter glass?
|
Yes, Ford does. This cant be Vento because vento has a black plastic cladding in the rear window.
The scary part is, the tipper crossed over the median and hit this car.
EDIT: this is a fiesta.
Image source: Dinamalar tamil epaper.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ramzsys
(Post 2714780)
Yes, Ford does. This cant be Vento because vento has a black plastic cladding in the rear window.
The scary part is, the tipper crossed over the median and hit this car.
EDIT: this is a fiesta.
Image source: Dinamalar tamil epaper.
|
Todays Hindu carried the same report but mentioned it as SUV and the photo also was from a front angle of the car from which you could not identify the vehicle.
May the souls RIP!!
saw this Zen on the OMR this morning, near the NGEF bypass signal. looks like someone t-boned it while crossing the signal.
Just got news of four RV college engineering kids in a swift crashed on NICE road (Bangalore) this morning, and one girl died on the spot!! May her soul RIP.
Hear the kid driving was doing 120+ and panicked when a truck changed lanes. Apparantly his second car after he smashed up his first. Kids dont learn or parents ?!?
Quote:
Originally Posted by NIP
(Post 2715003)
Just got news of four RV college engineering kids in a swift crashed on NICE road (Bangalore) this morning, and one girl died on the spot!! May her soul RIP.
Hear the kid driving was doing 120+ and panicked when a truck changed lanes. Apparantly his second car after he smashed up his first. Kids dont learn or parents ?!?
|
:Shockked:I would say parents are at fault here. Going by the temperament of the kid, he shouldn't be allowed to drive at all for a long time. He is playing with other peoples lives here. :Frustrati
Quote:
Originally Posted by prateek_ch
(Post 2715019)
:Shockked:I would say parents are at fault here. Going by the temperament of the kid, he shouldn't be allowed to drive at all for a long time. He is playing with other peoples lives here. :Frustrati
|
and got one killed too.. :Frustrati
what's with kids and speed these days? got a death wish or something? so many accidents reported in the news involving teenagers; lives lost families shattered. makes me :mad:
| All times are GMT +5.5. The time now is 06:48. | |
