Hi guys,
It is time I share my long term ownership experience and move to a new vehicle.
My good time with Petra 1.6 in Hyderabad was super. Bought in 2005, a 2004 model, really gave a great driving experience and fun. Let it be in the city or highways. We used to leave behind many other cars, including Scorpios, Ikons and others.
I bought it new and drove it for 65K KMs in 10 years in Hyderabad. I had to move to Bangalore around end of 2014, with a little apprehension about how my car would do in Bangalore traffic. That is when it started hitting on my pocket. Multiple issues that tired me
1. COPs after out of state vehicles that time, paid ~ 47K for LTT again. Just to point out, this is close to what I paid for a new vehicle in Hyderabad 10 years before.
2. Tires replaced, Yokohama all four. Michelins fitted prior lasted for less than 28K for 5 years in almost unpaved roads in my locality in Hyderabad.
3. 60K service, water leak, alternator gone, head light stalk replaced.
4. Engine mounts struts, kit bearing, etc.. gone ...
In essence, spent a good deal on repairs. That is when I realized both running costs and repairs are heavy on my pocket. Highest FE being under 10 KMPL and lowest of the order of 7 KMPL. All for BG Road to Cantt side route.
This is when I realized I need an alternative. Do not want to spend a lot, hence pre-owned is the choice. For someone used to American and European cars, Hyundai, Maruti, Tata have never been appealing. I gave one consideration though, would buy Hyundai if the price is reasonable. Researches online and offline revealed: Verna and Duster out of reach. Did not like Nissan Sunny or Renault Scala much still researched.
What I looked for: Top build quality, handling, lower running costs, reliable
It looked like I would like Volkswagen Vento. Both running costs and driving fun to have. I found one blue color and one champagne in Yelahanka. The blue color one I gave up as it seemed to have been owned by a realtor, can't recall KMs on it, probably 60K. The champagne one looked good, less than 3 years and around 20K KMs on it. We could not settle on price for this.
As I continue my search I came across Renault Fluence that looked beautiful to me, black, big enough. I drove the car, it felt light and good. I got it evaluated, we fail to settle down on price.
That is when I see a Vento TDI 1.6 ~ 38K from an IT employee. He was nice enough to bring the car for drive to times. The price seemed good, evaluator says one injector weak, that being a common problem to all Ventos. Settling the price was quick and the owner delivers it in Nov '16 to me.
My observation and feel of models looked at (all pre-owned)
1. Nissan Sunny: Seemed a passenger's car, big wheels. Not known to provide great driving experience.
2. Verna: Pricy compared to other cars. Handling keeps cropping up in my mind.
3. Renault Duster: Pricy
4. Renault Fluence: Looked good, not a great drivers car, but felt good enough with lot of space. It would have caused trouble in present parking for me.
5. Vento TDI: Felt good driving, almost like a petrol. Good build, handling did not seem bad. Spacious enough.
To present (from 2016)
Vento pleasure: I continue to like the build quality. Lower GC is relatively a pain. Good FE. Proves apprehensions about mtce costs to be true.
How do I compare it with Petra petrol: Good, not as good as Petra in driving. Petra used to drive me and now I drive Vento. What I mean is, Petra would keep on inviting go further kinds, TDI seems to be a controlling boss while letting you do the same slowly. Vento probably is a better handler as the family does not warn me to slow down in curves as much or was I lost in driving pleasure earlier.
My family feels: Seating comfort and luggage space were better in Petra.
I have had three minor accidents and two injector fails so far. Fitted new shoes (JK for economics). Was looking for continental, but ended up with India tire for indian roads
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e13f9/e13f952d7725b3bbc2939446cf28d4982f5f55bb" alt="Smile"
.
First accident:
An on coming taxi fellow takes a sudden right. He had not been toward the middle of the road either. I had no way of guessing he'd do that. As usual accuses me of going fast. I showed him, it is still in 3rd gear. Asked him to shut up and go. Only minot scratches on the bumper and one side head light.
Second:
A scooty guy suddnly come sin front of me from the side of a parked truck. Despite best braking efforts, the hit happens. The guy tried to play giddiness, this that and all that game. He was lucky to survive. The usual over speed blame game starts. I showed him the gear I was in after he claims I was speeding at 80-90 KMPH.
Insurance claim: total damage of bumper, radiator, front fram including grill, minor dent on bonnet. Total cost around 35 to 40K. Just less than half from my pocket.
Third one:
Dog hit. Cost me 8K as the plastic lining, fog lamp and a few other parts broke.