Re: Fiat Grande Punto : Test Drive & Review Quote:
Originally Posted by CliffHanger I've driven both the cars(Swift & Punto 75HP) extensively for thousands of KMs in Highways. And here are my observations.
1. The performance of Swift will never let you go tired, the car is always hungry to cover miles, whereas in Punto, above 120kmph the engine is always on the boil, and that gives you a feel that the car is sweating it out really hard, while you feel the Swift is always hungry for more. And this observation comes after driving the cars continously for almost 10hours non-stop in a lot of occasions.
2. If you are doing a long jault, Punto's first 2 short gears will anoy you. You would be in a mood to pick up pace quickly, but the car takes its own sweet time. In Swift, you crank the engine, and the game will start immediately.
3. Swift's steering feels dead at amost all speeds above 50kmph, you will not know where the car is heading to your inputs, but the car will handle itself unless you don't make any panic manouvers.
4. Swift handles corners better than Punto. Punto could get shaky, but Swift gets back to line quickly.
5. The composure of Punto is unbeatable, if you are doing around 110kmph, you will feel like cruising in a tank. All the dynamics of the car works best at around this speed.
6. Swift's ride composure will literally break your back and can make you feel sick of travelling. The hard suspension setup is to be blamed for, but that's what makes it handle corners at ease. In Punto, you will find it hard to recollect when you last encountered a pothole on your drive.
7. Swift's Gear shifts are top notch, Punto's is vague and rubbery.
8. In Swift, you feel like being in a toy car, the lightness of everything in the car gives you that feel. In Punto, you feel like you are in an iron monument that has been built over years with undying passion. 17 years of passionate engineering to build a car what it is now, will slowly get into you without your knowledge.
Now, Punto 90HP was launched to strengthen the performance weakness Punto had, and did it bridge the gap?
90HP picks up pace really quickly in highways and the engine is no more in the boil at 120kmph, the car cruises and if you are in the right power band it can give the Swift a real run for its money. Even if the Swift is kept in its right power band, it cannot catch up with a Punto in the right band. |
Today I got to drive my firend's Punto(75HP bought on Aug '11, current ODO- 3.5k)). I was quite suprised by some stark differences between this car and the one I owned(bought on Aug '09, sold with ODO reading `50k).
My observations below Note - Some are just initial impressions. Perceptions might change as you get used to the car.
1. The contour of the gear knob head is altered a bit. I felt more like holding a stick than like holding a gear lever. Slotting into gears is no more rubbery, but still not as precise as, say a Swift.
2. Steering has become lighter. I always believed that ladies will have tough time driving a Punto in city, because of its tight steering. But now I think it will no more be a cause of concern for them. But I'm not sure of in what way it will impact the car's handling.
Now the important part -----
3. Gear ratios are better. First gear is not as short as it used to be, while second gear, now, has become more driveable, neither too short nor too long. Turbo lag is very very minimal. The car is no more a laggard in city. With all these changes, there is a marked improvement in driveability.
4. NVH is better(not that it was bad in earlier Punto's).
4. Coming to Punto's achilies heel - interior fit and finish - While I was in the passenger seat, I couldn't stop myself from peeping into every nook and corner of the car. And I was surprised to see that the fit and finish is almost perfect. Also, a lot of small plastics, such as seat reclination lever, have been replaced with strong plastics.
I'm happy to see that Fiat has implemented all the feedback from the early birds.
Good going Fiat!
Last edited by CliffHanger : 4th November 2011 at 20:13.
|