Quote:
Originally Posted by shashank.nk We have a highway car so looking to buy a good city car, the only issue with the Punto in the city is the turning radius but i guess i can live with that as the drivability was better than the Ritz atleast, haven't TD'ed the new swift yet. As per ACI the turning radius of i20 and punto differ by 0.1m, punto being on the higher side. My dad is pretty okay with the Punto in the city. FYI, he drives an Hyundai i10 & is chauffeured in his Fiesta.
I don't understand how neither in the official reviews nor during ownership reviews of i20 no one cribs about it.
Make no mistake; all the reviews and ownership reviews of the i20 are w.r.t the 6 - speed model. For the record, I'd told my dad that he'd definitely have bought the i20 for it's performance, had Hyundai NOT chucked the 6th gear without changing the gearing ratios.
On the highways i'm never seen doing less than 100kmph plus this will be my car so any highway outing will be enjoyed to the fullest only in the Punto. For highway usage, Punto's the best; forget the rest.
Btw, you mean 7.85 right ? For the Swift ZDI or the 90HP Punto. I'm not eligible for any corporate discounts being practising CA's.
Nice! But Docs and Dentists can get Corp. Discount, so you too can try. Are you going in for exchange?
I think i'll book the car tomorrow. Are you dealing with the same dealer i mentioned
? |
Nice! Yes. Jayanagar. What color do you have in mind?
And please look at my replies in bold above.
BUT, however convinced you and I might be by the Punto, I urge you to TD the New Swift & i20 once before inking the deal. All the best & keep in touch.
OT: Add me on facebook (First Name: Arkin ) or PM me, if you need to talk about it.
Quote:
Originally Posted by .anshuman My Replies inline in BOLD- |
What I get with the Punto:
1) FIAT
How is this an advantage? The brand value in India is poor.
2) Mightier Engine
But slower real world performance
3) Better ride.
Agreed
4) Better Bootspace.
Agreed
5) Betterr rear bench.
Only marginally, both are tight at rear. Front seats roomier in Punto
6) Enough features.
Blue&Me great but Audio quality is POOR
7) Scintillating looks (my perception)
Stunner no doubt but facelift is due. Swift is also a very good looking car. Remember, looks are subjective
8) Better BUILD & RUGGEDNESS.
Agreed, vault like build unmatched but fit and finish of plastics better in new Swift.
9) ^^ implies SAFETY
Not really. Both cars have 5 star euro NCAP rating. Come with similar safety equipment.
10) EXCLUSIVITY.
Can be a bad thing too, check out the resale prices.
11) 15000km service interval.
But extra cost of Oil and filters offset the balance making it more expensive to service than Swift.
Thanks for the reply .anshuman! I understand you've had bad experiences with your Punto....
FYI, I'll be keeping the car for at least the next 10 years, so dad has told me himself, not to care about the resale value. About the performance, my dad had nothing but praise for the 90HP's performance; he doesn't mind the T-lag as long as he can keep the revs above 2k rpm; we need this as a highway hatch, and the i20 (comes with the 5speed box now
![Frustration](https://www.team-bhp.com/forum/images/smilies/Frustration.gif)
) was disappointing from the 4th gear on - the guys at Hyundai don't seem to have changed the gear ratios after chucking the 6th gear,
Agreed, both cars have 5 star NCAP ratings & similar safety equipment, but I have no doubts about the rigidity of the Punto. About the audio quality, after saving ~1.5 lakh by not going in for the City + saving at least 40% on fuel, an audio upgrade is affordable. Coming to the Punto Evo, I'm not such a great fan of its looks; I like the plain looks of the Punto in comparision. I myself love the Swift's looks, but my parents have never liked it's backside.
No. 11) - Food for thought, but given our priorities, the Punto 90 seems more lucrative.
![Smile](https://www.team-bhp.com/forum/images/smilies/smile.png)
Again, thanks for your unbiased advice.