Quote:
Originally Posted by ashvek3141 Sonet has not yet been tested and not even the ‘new’ Nexon facelift based on the revised GNCAP or the indigenous BNCAP. Also, people have survived in a 0 star rated car and have been dead in a flagship Merc, so let’s not get into that safety rating aspect yet! There’s a lot more to a car apart from just dancing around with that safety crown. |
Sonet isnt tested but it's family history shows that safety isn't their forte or priority.
The new nexon isn't tested. The old Nexon crumpled the current Sonet in its crash ratings. So, Nexon wins here by a fair margin.
Also, going by Tata's value for safety, either Nexon should get same rating or improve. They didn't rank low for next gen models.
Yes, there is lot more dancing other than safety as long as people dance only for a cup of coffee when visiting showrooms or service centers.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ashvek3141
No denying that safety is important; but it is one of the factors required in consideration along with the rest.
Also, you cannot have a car stranded in the service centre for days / weeks together with a 5 star safety. That car needs too move too. Just saying. |
Thank you, at least you accepted that safety is important for Tata but not for Sonet manufacturers.
Yes, we cant get stranded by getting bed ridden with injuries or get packed in 6X2 wooden boxes for forever. The person who is in the car should walk out of the car. Just replying. It just sounds that every Tata car moves straight from a showroom to a garage and sits there for days , if true, then every unsafe should result in casualties which is untrue again. So, kindly dont sound that every Tata car makes you stranded.
Quote:
Originally Posted by vvivek85 Top of the line auto costs close to 18 L in Chennai. Seriously TATA?? Moreover, these are “introductory prices”. God knows what will be the price in a month. Moreover, this pricing overlaps with quite a many cars which are a segment above with better engine and space. TATA’s VFM tag has gone for a toss. With their DCT which is not so great, I seriously want to understand what was in their mind while making decision. |
There is no VFM in today's automotive world. Every car is expensive and every month we see new milestones being breached in car sales.
DCT is not great ? Perhaps in drag race. But arent we complaining for jerky AMT's and then demanded DCA? Did we all shift goal posts here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by rakesh_r Fast forward, 2022, went to the showroom at Wakdewadi. Was about to enter the showroom, saw the sales people loitering around with no botheration at all. Left the showroom in flat 5 min, vowed never to buy a Tata car.
PS: I had a better experience at Force Motors showroom, which I had never expected. |
Im really surprised that which showroom of Tata's are empty and staff are loitering around? Because, I always find them to very busy attending multiple families. Why am I saying is this because, when myself and my brother went to a Tata showroom, the response wasn't great. Then, the same weekend, we took all family members and response was fab. Then I realized, we didnt appear to be a prospective buyers for the sales team. This is a valid scenario.
Quote:
Originally Posted by GoBabyGo Hi, get yourself Honda Elevate V CVT at 16.75 lacs, spend 45K on Alloys and you are good to go with one of the best engine + AT transmission + reliability with good space inside out. |
You found Nexon expensive but that doesn't mean one will buy Honda Elevate. Their elevations dont run long. Honda's are "Ek product kaa Sultaans".
Quote:
Originally Posted by ashvek3141 15.50 L for Diesel top end that too an AMT box?? TATA has lost it seriously. Kia Sonet gets a much better TC unit for a Lakh cheaper!
I just hope Kia doesn't go bizarre with pricing their Sonet facelift like the Nexon.  |
Diesel top end was almost 15L in Panipat in 2020, DT with Sunroom and AMT. It was a marginal increase and they didn't lose in earlier avatar too.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pathfinder99 If one scores 5* safety rating and other crumbles like a piece of paper, is it really fair to compare these two?  |
Safety is all what we demand when our hands on keyboard but mileage and a cup of coffee is needed when we are in car/garage.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Explorer... There is <70k difference between Creative+ DCA (14.86, as per company) and Creative+ EV (15.52, as per Cardekho.com).
Does this mean TATA is promoting its EV over its petrol version or am I missing something here? |
Very interesting catch. By showing EV's are priced are close to petrol models, they are marketing EV's too. One's who is price dilemma can lap up an EV model. AFAIK, the margins are much higher in EV's than fossils.