Hi Everyone,
Since all the hype has shifted to the ROXX thread, thought of putting in a short review of the Thar 3-door D HT AT 4X4. This is possibly the only car after the New Figo Diesel we owned, which clocked as many Kms in such a short period. The Figo D had done 50k kms in 2 years at the time of selling it. In comparison, the Thar has done 24k kms in less than a year. While most of the miles munched on the Figo were solo drives and mainly to a single destination (BLR-Coorg-BLR), in the Thar it has been family outings to multiple short distances and few multi-day drives as well.
Breaking down the review into the below points & will also try to capture the cost where appropriate.
- Modifications
- Drive Experience & Passenger Experience - Highways, Hills, Cities
- Luggage carrying ability.
- Fuel Efficiency
- Miscellaneous
1. Modifications External:- - Right out of the showroom, got the car fully wrapped in PPF from a known contact that costed 75k. Since it is a black car, wanted to maintain the shine and not lose the beauty of black to the swirls!!
- Garware tints which costed 20k for all glasses.
- Wrangler type front grille costing 9.5k
- LED Headlights & Projector fog lamps costing 25k
- Post completing 23k kms, got full underbody cover (mild steel) from a known contact for 18k
Internal:-- Front Arm rest - Got one from the Mahindra dealer costing 3500 and used it for 20k kms. It was not very convenient and was installed in the cup-holders. It also started making creaking noises post 10k kms itself. Finally got it changed to a Bimbra type one that was in a neighbor's Thar which he ordered direct from Delhi which costed 4.6k including shipping. This is wide and convenient to use for both the passenger and driver.
- Rear Arm rest - This is also from the dealer but this is much better finished and adds to the ambience at the rear. It costed around 11k IIRC. It also comes with USB chargers for both arm rests.
- Front and Rear recording dash cam - This is a rear view mirror mounted dash cam from DDPAI with both front and rear recording. Including the memory card & installation, costed 16k.
- After using the stock seat upholstery for 23k kms, got the interiors done up in Tan leatherette upholstery & also got the steering wrapped in original Nappa leather in Black. Costed 30k.
2. Drive Experience & Passenger Experience Use Case: The Thar is only used by our family of 3: Me, Wife (both 40 year olds) & our 14 year old son. Elderly have never travelled in the Thar from either of our families.
We have used the Thar extensively on different types of highways - the BLR-MYS expressway, BLR-HYD highway, undivided state highways with good tarmac, state highways with broken roads etc. Driving the Thar AT has been a pleasure on the highways. Once you get used to the high seating and high CG of the car, you will be able to hold speeds upto 110 on the expressways without any fear. Since I usually travel the BLR-MYS expressway at night time, I can set the cruise at 105 & get to MYS with hardly 4-5 braking events. It is as easy to manoeuvre the jeep across lanes as needed to overtake slow moving traffic. We were able to get to HYD in the usual 6.5hrs with breaks that we were able to do earlier in the Seltos or Polo. So no penalty in terms of time taken. In fact the journey feels effortless and less tiresome. On good tarmac there is very less lateral movement even when changing lanes & steady 3 digit speeds are definitely possible.
On undivided highways with rough roads, no need to slow down. Just glide past without as much as a noise inside. Suspension does a stellar job of insulating the road sounds. Yes as a driver you will feel everything on the steering as there is no steering dampers in the Thar. Once you get used to loosening your grip, you will not feel much as well. If the roads are well and truly broken with craters for road, then you have to navigate them slowly. There is lateral movement here as well but passengers dont feel the stiffness or the "hit" from the bumps if you call it that.
Driving in hills and ghats is a treat in the SWB Thar. It feels planted and grip levels are pretty good to give you confidence to navigate the twisties at a brisk pace. Passengers also dont feel thrown around as long as the surface is good. Taking bad twisty roads at a slow pace is comfortable enough for the passengers too. The only sore point in the hills with broken sections is the heavy steering which takes a toll on your arms and tires you out if driven for over 2 hours at a stretch. Taking breaks and proceeding reduces this strain but it is there nevertheless due to the heavy hydraulic steering.
My wife feels very comfortable in the passenger seat and feels Thar has been the most ergonomic for her and she can peacefully nap in the seat during the journeys. Owing to the comfort over bad roads, even if there is lateral movement she can continue to nap without much disturbance or discomfort. My son feels that the rear seat is akin to a lounge and he feels that the recline feature in the rear is a boon and a stand out feature adding to the comfort at the back.
His verdict: Thar rear seats are more comfortable than the front passenger seat & overall comfort in the Thar over good / bad roads is superior to all the cars we have owned so far [Figo, Polo, Seltos. He was too young to notice the earlier car's comfort as he would be busy dozing off in the back seat ]. 3. Luggage carrying ability
The boot as already very evident to all is smaller than a Wagon R boot. But if you pack smartly, you can stack soft duffel bags in such a way that you can carry 3 people's luggage for a 7 day trip in the boot alone. We use 2 Wildcraft large duffel bags and one medium size one stacked up. There will be some space left for misc. items such as shoes/slipper bags and some knick knacks. The rear footwell behind the driver is also put to use in case we have to carry stock of snacks and of course all bottle holders will have 1lt. bottles in them. We have total of 2 bottle holders in the front doors and 2 each in the arm rest at the rear. Of these only 1 can be used if its a wide bottle so it makes it 4lts. of water + we can carry additional bottles in the snack bag stashed in the rear footwell/unoccupied seat. This way for a family of 3 travelling for 7-8 days is quite possible without having to compromise on the comfort or the luggage you get to carry on the trip. Also since we changed the front arm rest we get 2 cup holders and a flat area ahead of the gear lever for storing the phones/tissue paper rolls etc. The dash is useful only to keep the service booklet and nothing much else.
4. Fuel Efficiency
As indicated above, mine is a 4X4 Diesel AT Hard Top. Given the added weight of the 4X4 hardware and the nature of this engine, The Thar gives anywhere around 14-15kmpl on expressways if the speed is maintained at 100-105kmph. Going above these speeds may feel unsafe until you really get used to the way Thar drives and stops. On undivided and hilly sections the best I have seen is 13.5kmpl and the worst is 12kmpl. We dont use the Thar either in Bangalore city or within town limits in Coorg as we have the Altos to do the city duties in either place. But the occasional city drives in Bangalore during slightly off peak hours returns around 10.5kmpl & same in Coorg gives around 9.5kmpl owing to the shorter distance we need to travel in Coorg.
5. Miscellaneous - The 4X4 is deployed very rarely when we have to enter into a relatives farm and if it has rained heavily with slushy uphill sections involved. This is very rare and in the 24k kms we have used it probably 2 times. Thar is more of a Grand Tourer for our family than an off-roader.
- I have got all the services done in Coorg and never once had the chance to try out the service in Bangalore. Service experience has been good so far as there was no issue to troubleshoot and it was just the routine stuff that had to be carried out. Maybe because it is a Tier 2/3 town, the 20k service came to about 5k including all oils and consumables and also a voluntary replacement of the air filter from my side. I think the bill might be dearer by 500-1000/- in Bangalore mostly (not sure).
- No rattles or squeaks in the jeep so far. Barring the front arm rest which we duly replaced there is no rattling or squeaking in the Thar so far even after taking it on all sorts of road conditions. Seems to be built well.
- One of the fog lamps conked off around the 11k kms mark, and it was diagnosed to a blown fuse which was of a lower capacity than needed for the projector unit. It was replaced post which everything is working as expected.
- Alignment and balancing have always been done outside and has been flawless so far. The only issue was the first time when it was done at a shop known to the SVC where they messed it up. Got it corrected at my regular guy in Bangalore and no issues since.
And finally, I owe a big thanks to my wife who was the inspiration to realise the dream of owning the Thar. She was the one who said that if we are changing the Seltos it better not be to a vehicle that feels similar on the inside and it should be a totally different experience altogether. The Thar has lived up to her expectations as well as mine in all respects. It is so good that we are not even inclined in the least bit to test drive the Roxx. In fact son has already declared that he wants to retain our Thar for as long as it can last even if it means re-registering it multiple times. Given that we have now completed close to 24k in less than a year, we also have a plan to do a trip from Bangalore to the North as a family and plans are underway for this trip during his summer vacations. Hoping it turns out well.