Re: Tata Hexa : Official Review Finally, I had some spare time to take an extensive, proper TD of the XT 4x2 MT demo car at the nearest dealership.
My observations, with comparisons based on my extensive TDs of the XTA 4x2 and my current steed, the Creta SX+ (Lazarus).
- Got inside and almost immediately felt that the MT has messed-up ergonomics.
Pushed the driver's seat back to the position I am most comfortable in and the ABC pedals felt too far back (specially the clutch lever).
Adjusted the seat for the proper bite of the clutch and felt I was too close to the steering wheel, plus my left knee and chin brushed against the central console and lower part of the dashboard.
At that sitting position, I couldn't see the ABC pedals either. Had to crane my neck a bit further downward to see where my feet actually rested. The pedals are placed a bit too close together for easy comfort, IMO.
Pushed the seat a bit lower and felt more easier. My feet murmured a silent thanks to me, as they settled better on top of the clutch & accelerator pedals. Still didn't help my left leg from brushing against the central console, though.
Comparatively, the AT's footwell is MUCH better with plenty of space between the A & B pedals, and the nice footrest on the left side providing ample free space for the left leg to rest on.
No such problems with the Creta. The leg space and the pedal placement is optimal.
My preference = Creta.
- I shifted the gears about, and felt that the 1st gear was too far out from the normal reach of the driver. Shifting was easy for the first 4 gears, but the 5th and 6th gears take some getting used to. The gear lever has an unnecessary long travel range to the top right when you need to shift to 5th, and doesn't slot in either. The trick is not to move the lever all the way to the top right, but shift only slightly right from neutral (or 4th) towards the top right, and the gear lever slots into 5th. Once you do it 4-5 times, specially when the car is on the move, and you feel more at ease with the 5th gear slotting.
The 6th gear was getting missed too, and I kept shifting into Reverse. Tried to move into 6th from 5th, and that was easier and smoother. From neutral, it's not easy to move into 6th. Again, one has to be mindful of not moving the lever all the way to the bottom right, but move just enough from the 4th-neutral. It's best to move into 6th from the 5th gear.
The AT is a completely different cup of tea. Need I say why?
Can't beat the Creta here. All sure-slotting, smooth and precise gear shifts, with the button below the gear lever and same shifting into 1st to engage reverse (wish the Hexa had such a system too). No cause for complaints.
My preference = the AT.
- Started the car and moved out. Coming from the Creta, the Hexa's steering felt tougher to deal with at slow, crawling speeds. Once the speeds climbed up, the steering eased up and felt better. I adjusted the steering wheel more towards the top so that I could have a clear view of the instrumentation and the binnacle on top. How I wish the Hexa had telescopic adjustment too! Still, it wasn't to my liking and didn't give back adequate feedback from the tyres/road conditions. Turning the car around was also slightly cumbersome. Anyone who is coming from a Safari/Storme will feel at home, but for Hyundai/Honda owners, the Hexa's steering will take plenty of time to get used to.
The AT's steering felt slightly better than the MT. Feedback was noticeably better and it was slightly better at low speeds, too.
The Creta's steering is quite light. Atrociously light at crawling speeds, which makes you feel slightly nervous when backing out from/getting into narrow spaces. Cross 40-ish speeds and it gets better, although there's a lack of feedback here too. Comparing both, the Hexa's steering is better, even though it's quite tight at 1st/2nd gear speeds.
My preference = AT again.
- The pickup, ride quality and braking is top-notch. The car masks it's hefty weight quite easily. At no time do you feel that you are sitting inside a 2 and a quarter tonne car with an equally-sized engine inside. The suspension, engine response and gear ratios have been tuned perfectly. Triple digit speeds come up in no time.
A Swift was chasing us from town square, it's driver possibly curious about this new Tata behemoth. As soon as we reached outside city limits, I gave a gentle nudge to the A pedal while coasting in the 4th gear, and the Hexa literally flew away from the Swift!
The car is at it's happiest in the 4th gear, and the pull is amazing. Shifting between 4th and 5th in the moving car was much better, as was shifting into 6th from 5th. The first 2 gears are just for the high revs, while the 3rd is well suited for closely knit urban traffic.
Size-wise, you don't feel like the car is a 4.7 meter giant, either. The closely spaced controls all around you, the central console and the instrumentation make you feel that the car is more compact than what it's outer dimensions actually are. Not a bad thing at all.
But here come my biggest grudges with the Hexa MT - the gear lever's NVH levels. The vibrations filtering back into my hand were totally unacceptable in such a premium car! It was as if a full-sized boom-boom discotheque was in full swing somewhere inside the gear lever's innards!
To add to this, the AC's blowers were literally in typhoon/whirlwind mode and that added further to my annoyance. They were not in the mood to relent anytime soon, either.
The AT's pickup is gradual in comparison. But it is also at it's happiest in the 4th and 5th gears. Pulling away from standstill/crawling speeds is only slightly better in the MT. AT owners won't be complaining about this aspect.
The Creta, in comparison, has a nice clean pull from the 1st gear onwards. Mine is a petrol so can't compare directly, but in terms of driveability and practicality in city traffic, the Creta scores better than the Hexa. Also, the parking and road footprint of the Hyundai is half a meter lesser, so that's a big boon for urban commuting too. Braking at lower speeds is quite effective, while high-speed braking still needs improvement. Hyundai needs to address an issue with the Creta's ABS unit - when it kicks in during sudden braking, it feels like your foot has stepped on a crate full of pebbles!
No such thing in the Hexa - AT or MT - braking is absolutely superb.
The Creta's AC, however, is a silent chiller, and also the gear lever is absolutely silent. Full marks to Hyundai for scoring big on these feel-good factors.
My preference = Creta for practicality, Hexa AT for driveability, braking and riding comfort.
Back to the drawing board again now, regarding our booking.
I was thinking of shifting to the XT 4x2 MT because the AT misses out on some crucial safety features, but the AT is still tugging at my heart's strings because of it's absolutely beautiful response.
Got quotations for the XM 4x2 (16.2L OTR), XMA 4x2 (17.6L OTR) and XT 4x2 (19.04L OTR) and left for home.
Weighing all options, and it could be the XMA 4x2 for me in the end.
Still debating, though.
Last edited by RavenAvi : 24th April 2017 at 17:47.
Reason: edited a point.
|