My search for our family’s second small car (my mom’s trusted Maruti 800 – workhorse for 26 years, clocked 1.28L kms yet not even once it’s guts have been opened is now showing signs of age) has been confusing (gross understatement).
I followed the amazingly helpful Team-BHP’s first New Car buying guide and its guidelines –
1. FIX THE BUDGET (one cannot emphasize enough on this) – however this basic principle is way too tempting to break and I happened to break it the first thing itself. I started with Alto K10 Vxi (o) in mind but test drove Eon, Amaze, Celerio, Grand i10, Polo and now I’m looking at Tiago XZ (petrol) – this car just too good to resist for all the creature comforts and a VERY plush city ride.
2. Test Drive, test drive and again test drive – every time I test rode a vehicle I discovered something I missed in my last ride. Every manufacturer approaches consumer problems in a unique manner and they all seem to be correct (in their own way)
Tata Tiago has simply changed the game for the likes of Celerio, i10 (kappa 1.1) and Grand i10 (base version). I’m not even considering the dead Beat.
Initial impressions upon laying my eyes in showroom:
1. Build quality is now on-par with the likes of Maruti, Chevy, Toyota (Liva) and just a touch below Hyundai
2. Interior design has this European flair to it, the hexagonal head unit, ergonomically placed switches all add to the feel good factor while seated inside the car.
3. From outside, I couldn’t fault with the design even one bit. Be it the rear of the car - no ugly bulges, just the right size of tail lamps or the very tastefully added chrome bits (I’m personally not a fan of chrome) and the side profile (Thank God, Tata has finally ditched the egg shape design and Christmas tree tail lamps).
4. The doors have this nice ‘thud’ when closing them – exudes heft and structural rigidity (although heft has no relation to crash worthiness)
5. Very generous boot (bigger than Swift) and thoughtfully designed to maximize luggage capacity.
6. Few things worth mentioning –
The arm rest is very conveniently placed and is of good width, I particularly liked this when observing the interiors for the first time. It was boon when riding shotgun during test-rides.
The slightly scooped area where Bluetooth mic is placed – is there in-front above driver and shotgun’s seat.
Look at Tata – NOT skipping boot covers, Maruti, Honda – please take note. Dimple of my finger press to demonstrate adequate cushion
Some areas where Tata still needs to fix up their assembly line – uneven panels gaps
Tata is PROUD of its new baby and rightfully so, look at the comparisons in the official handout booklet with sales guys.
Petrol Comparison
Diesel Comparison
Extended warranty is on-par with the competitors (I think Tata’s new engine family is dependable – only time will tell though)
Appreciation from everyone –
Tata Tiago’s Pièce de résistance – blows everyone out of the water (introductory prices though). Prices for Lucknow, UP.
Interesting note, the RTO (calculated at 8% of ex-showroom price) has additional Rs. 2000/-. Upon checking with the sales person he informed me these are required at RTO. Look at the side note below price sheet.
7. Driving Dynamics (I drove only petrol as this is what I’m planning to buy) –
Bad and Worse parts:
• [bad] The three cylinder thrum is present, prominently! No matter what and how many reviews say it’s not, it’s pretty audible when the air con is not running. Air-con drowns the outside noise (more on air-con performance later – it’s BAD).
•[bad] I found the A-pillars intrusive and blocking. While navigating the tight turns, I did find them to be an obstruction and in my line of sight at corners. Not a huge dislike and can be easily forgiven and adjusted to.
•[bad] Gear level’s vibrations are VERY prominent while changing from 3rd to 4th. There is this shudder and a strong push from gear stick once you upshift and accelerate. I noticed this because I have this habit of placing one hand on the gear stick.
•[worse] The air-con performance is BAD and unacceptable! I took two test rides, one each from two separate dealers in Lucknow (Motorsales and SRM). Upon ending my first ride of approx. 12 kms round trip the cabin was still not cool – kept the air-con speed at three as two was simply useless. Fan speed 4 is blower, no cool air. I first thought that it might be this specific test car’s problem and thus requested another dealer for a test ride. Same issue – this time the test drive was for about 6-7 kms and the air-con simply couldn’t cool the cabin. It was like, while the air-con is ON at three, front passengers could feel some cool air on their face however rear passengers were boiling. The moment you stop the air-con, there was no effect of chill left in the car. Spoke at length about this point to the sales guy and he agreed that from previous Tata cars, Tiago’s AC isn’t as effective and definitely not at par with Celerio and i10. First test ride was done at 11.20am in the morning (outside temperature 31 degrees) and the second test ride at 5pm in the afternoon (outside temperature 34 degrees).
Good and Better points:
•The suspension is an absolute delight – it soaks up bumps and pot-holes like no one’s business. You have to hand it to Tata’s engineers for the brilliant job they have done here. Kudos guys!
•Cabin insulation from wind and road noise is good, I wouldn’t say great but it’s perfectly acceptable for a city car – speeds of up to 60-70kmph.
•The steering is nimble, car is small, and can be chucked around with ease – as there aren’t overtly flared up wheel arches or protruding bumpers you have a fairly good idea of this dame’s dimensions and whereabouts
8. Additional Points to note:
•Comparing it with Amaze - Dual horns on Tiago are great, no cost cutting by Tata;
•Cabin air recirculation button is electronic (Honda take note – Rs. 8L Amaze has an ugly manual slider)
•Headlight throw not known – none of the reviews have mentioned anything. Hope it’s acceptable.
•Brown color (looks a lot like a shade of grey) is very appealing. Named as Espresso brown in Tata’s language.
•Wifey made a comment that interior dash design is better than Grandi10 and driving both successively, gear slotting is better in Tiago. Don’t know why but Grand i10’s gear slotting felt very notchy. (Sportz model – petrol)
•Driver seat height adjustor has a VERY good range, I’m 5 feet 8 inches and on full uplift of seat my head was touching the roof and tilted.
My current dilemma is which car to book. Tiago ticks ALL the boxes but I just can’t seem to get myself around the fact that its AC is simply not effective and if I buy this car every time I sit, drive and look at it, I’ll be reminded of the sub-par performance of the AC but the sweat drop on my brow.
Yesterday took a test drive of Grand i10 Sportz (petrol) and the AC was a chiller – same road and same time as that of my second test drive of Tiago.