Re: Fiat Abarth Punto : Official Review Quote:
Originally Posted by S2!!! I wish you well with your Abarth purchase, but do reconsider. It isn't a car that's easy to drive and isn't something very practical to replace a car like a Wagon R. It's easy to be impressed by the superb 145hp engine or the tank-like build but I hope your mother has driven the Abarth enough and is fine with all its quirks. Do consider a Hyundai i20 Active or a Ford EcoSport petrols, keeping all the preconceived notions aside, as these will really be much better than an Abarth to live with on a daily basis. |
As I mentioned earlier, lot of cars were considered and over 4 weeks of time has been spent in test drives. Initially the requirement chosen by Dad and I was for a Petrol Automatic.
We started off with the Tiago loved the value for money package that it posed but hated the 3cyl. The the C2 segment sedans were considered. Vento and Rapid knocked out due to the central console constantly scraping against left leg, Ciaz and City were knocked out due to their build, Yaris was knocked out due to its terrible rear seat headroom which was totally unexpected leaving us very miffed.
Then Ford Figo and Ecosport were looked at. The Figo 1.5 DCT impressed however the reliability of powershift transmission left us a bit unsure. Ecosport worked perfectly well except that it lacked grunt on the highway for effortless overtakes must be due to the silly 3cyl dragon series engines being used. It is excusable for the Tiago being a 6.5 lac rupee car but for Ecosport? No way was that acceptable.
We then moved on to the Creta and while it was uninspiring, it did do most things if not excellently, at least properly. However we were not feeling any sense of occasion with the Creta which is something we expected to feel after the prospect of spending 17 lacs on a car.
Eventually Mom expressed her discomfort with driving an automatic and then manual Brio was considered. While the Brio was mostly good, the need to rev the guts out of its motor and the flimsy looking seats made us a little unsure about it.
Eventually Dad suggested the Abarth. We were all quite surprised; Dad, I, Mom, and the Salesman the testdrive car was a lot different from what I remember it to be like from few years ago. The steering was not scary feather light like most modern cars, but it was still much lighter than the Kizashi's steering at low speeds, clutch also felt far lighter than I remembered and was much lighter than the Forester's clutch. Infact these two elements were what surprised me the most since my memory of the clutch and steering were very different. The suspension was excellent, low-end torque delivery we all found to be a boon, seat comfort, easy ingress/egress and the ability to connect phones via bluetooth made us all feel, "what more do you need?" We are a very simple family and we all believe that if we spend over 10 lacs on a car, no compromises should be made.
Brio and Tiago and the likes were all excusable but cars like the Ecosport and Creta did not deliver what we expected. The Abarth Punto was the only car which did everything asked of it while also remaining an exciting prospect to own (something the Creta failed to impress with). The cost of the car being just about 10 lacs and still towards the lower end of our budget makes us feel a certain sense of relief also as we were beginning to feel very worried about maybe having to lower expectations and make compromises even if we spent 16-18lacs. Maybe it is the fact that they have driven and appreciated the Kizashi and the Forester, but trust me, Abarth Punto was not even recommended by me, yet this is now the winner for us.
Last edited by suhaas307 : 7th June 2018 at 12:27.
Reason: Edited post for improved readability
|