Team-BHP - Mahindra Scorpio : Official Review
Team-BHP

Team-BHP (https://www.team-bhp.com/forum/)
-   Official New Car Reviews (https://www.team-bhp.com/forum/official-new-car-reviews/)
-   -   Mahindra Scorpio : Official Review (https://www.team-bhp.com/forum/official-new-car-reviews/157090-mahindra-scorpio-official-review-5.html)

Quote:

Originally Posted by narayan (Post 3568794)
Guys
Has anyone seen the S2/S4 interiors ? Are they different in terms of plastic colour and fitments ? For e.g the earlier Scorpio Lx interiors were very spartan without even an arm rest in the door pad. Wonder if this approach has changed ?

Quote:

Originally Posted by S2!!! (Post 3567841)
Other Points:

BHPian Miyer has put up some great pics of the S4 variant & suspension at this link. Be sure to check them out.

Please have a look at the link where BHPian Miyer has posted interior and exterior shots of an S4 variant.

Great review, S2. Rating it a well deserved 5 stars!

The one thing that always is good about Mahindra is that they keep working at their models, and utilize the Make in India to the fullest. They are not shackled by any international approvals while making changes (unlike the Japs/Germans); and they seem to listen to feedback well. This new version of the Scorpio definitely builds on all the strong points (great driveability, on-road presence), and has added convenience and styling bits.

I am yet to see the vehicle in person - but is the fit and finish worse than the earlier models? Or is it that we in TBHP seem to have really keen eyes for these things? Interested to know this bit from people who have driven already.

Fantastic rating.

One of the best car reviews lately.

BTW, how to make the mundane Scorpio rear look a lot better??

Mahindra Scorpio : Official Review-mahindrascorpio06.jpg

The LTD sticker never looked better in any other car than on this Scorpio.
Contrasting and elegant.

Mother of all reviews. Quality comes at a price (price = time)

I got two of the best selling automobile magazines to read about Scorpio & after reading this review, I feel being robbed off my Rs. 300.

Quote:

Originally Posted by S2!!! (Post 3567824)

There is no independent central lock/unlock button in this Mahindra. The central locking function can only be operated from the driver's door lock / unlock switch. Trust me, it requires a lot of effort to use. ...........
Thankfully, the Scorpio comes with auto-locking doors (they auto-lock at 20 km/h). Not only is this feature good for safety, but it also gives you one reason less to use the unfriendly lock / unlock switch.

What I do is, I use the remote to lock/unlock the doors. The remote is accessible as it is not incorporated in the key fob.

But auto locking of doors? I don't think the current ones auto-lock.

Quote:

Originally Posted by D4D (Post 3568154)
IMO this is going to be a sales dud as:

IMO, you are going to be proven horribly wrong.

Good to know that they have retained the 4x4 for the base model too. Other manufacturers need to realize that 4x4 is more of a necessity rather than a luxury.

Duster 85PS AWD base modelplease:

Quote:

Originally Posted by arnabchak (Post 3568860)
BTW, how to make the mundane Scorpio rear look a lot better??


1. Remove the black strip
2. Remove the pseudo grab handle
3. Bring back the tower reflectors or even better equipped with brake lights which move up with the brake pressure :D
4. Door mounted spare wheel

Quote:

Originally Posted by m_upreti (Post 3568928)
1. Remove the black strip
2. Remove the pseudo grab handle
3. Bring back the tower reflectors or even better equipped with brake lights which move up with the brake pressure :D
4. Door mounted spare wheel

I think @arnabchak was suggesting a solution by adding a Live To DRIVE sticker in the rear :D. He has done a quick paste job on the image & indeed it does look good.

The suggestions you've made are certainly funky, but would need another "next generation" (perhaps 3 years down the line) to come into reality.

Quote:

Originally Posted by arnabchak (Post 3568860)
Fantastic rating.



BTW, how to make the mundane Scorpio rear look a lot better??

Attachment 1304400

Replace the existing rear door with the old one. Retain the lights. There is a direct rear comparison in the first or second post. Plain jane looks butch. Just my opinion.

Quote:

Originally Posted by m_upreti (Post 3568928)
1. Remove the black strip
2. Remove the pseudo grab handle
3. Bring back the tower reflectors or even better equipped with brake lights which move up with the brake pressure :D
4. Door mounted spare wheel

My mistake if the pun was unintended lol:

Your points are valid. My question was asked with a answer below!!:)

In the above blue shade which is really looking good, I think the rear would be better off with a complete blue scheme rather than the black strip in between. Can some PS guru try doing this and post it ?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sheel (Post 3568889)
Mother of all reviews. Quality comes at a price (price = time)

I got two of the best selling automobile magazines to read about Scorpio & after reading this review, I feel being robbed off my Rs. 300.

I have long stopped buying auto magazines ever since I became a tbhpian clap:
Excellent review,well penned down and well complimented by crisp pictures. I am happy but at the same time disappointed as to why M & M didn't sort out the rear suspension issues. I have to agree the darker shades suites the scorpio rather than the white ones.

Like numerous T-bhians have mentioned, there are so many small things left out. And so many design flaws and fit issues. But to come to think of it weren't they testing this vehicle for donkey's years.

After so much of testing didn't they realise these things?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sheel (Post 3568889)

IMO, you are going to be proven horribly wrong.

I added this line-"I mean it's not going to create the same uproar it did way back in 2002".

I meant it in a relative manner compared to 2002. I have reasoned why I feel so in the previous post.

I had written:
Quote:

  • Mahindra XUV 500 is a far better product. And those who have the $$$ will rather buy it.
  • Renault Duster is a great product. For the guy who's happy with a 5 seater with decent space and now it comes in an AWD that's pretty capable for a little off roading. Cheaper running costs and lower maintenance costs too.
  • Those who like a roomy back seat will stick to the Safari/ buy an Innova(Budget permitting?)
  • No AT box.
  • Looks the same old thing. They could have redesigned a lot of side panels at least.
  • Exposed deforgger wiring? Are you kidding me?


Lovely superbly detailed review. Rated it 5 stars.

The Scorpio is not a million rupee vehicle anymore its 1.5 million rupees in the S10 avatar.

The 4x4 option should have started with the S6 variant rater then S4.

XUV makes more sense than the s8 and s10 variants.

Scorpio looks lovely in blue.

The variants other than s10 feel very basic in feature terms.

It is fun to drive in the city. But did not like it too much beyond 100 kmph.

Quote:

Originally Posted by ACM (Post 3569302)
It is fun to drive in the city. But did not like it too much beyond 100 kmph.

My 2009 Scorpio is simply a breeze at least upto 110-120 kmpL at which I drive mostly on all the 4-6 Lane highways in India. On all other roads anything in the north of say 90-100 kmpL is simply unsafe in our country irrespective of the vehicle. I don’t see any reason why should the NG go any worse here.

Having said that, currently I can’t see a NG Scorpio or a Storme replacing my 2009 –Mhawk as an “upgrade”, convincingly. In terms of 'looks' the new Scorpio is a put off where as the Storme under-equipped to my liking.

Again I wouldn’t call one vehicle better than the other at this stage. Prioritise your requirements and then pick the one that ticks the boxes the most.


All times are GMT +5.5. The time now is 21:59.