Since 2013, our family has had a hatchback (Suzuki A-Star) and a sedan (Honda City CVT) which would go back and forth between my parents' house and my apartment. Since my parents shuttled between Bengaluru and Mumbai, these two were enough to meet our needs. In January 2021 however, the family decided to relocate to Bengaluru for good. This began a search for a 2nd larger car so that we didn't have to move our cars around repeatedly.
As a general rule, I don't see value in spending more than Rs. 20L on a car in India. This is an internal limit I have always set myself and look for the best within this budget. All 5 members in our family have been biased towards sedans. Despite a wave of SUVs and Mini-SUVs flooding the market in the last decade, we're still not convinced it is the right fit for us. Before we started our search, I was eyeing the Honda Civic as I thought the new model looked very cool and having owned two Honda Cars over 15 years, we're sure of its reliability. However, we soon found out that it had been discontinued. We then searched for a Skoda Octavia (Since we own a 2011 made Laura 2.0TDI in Mumbai) but it turns out that that too was discontinued and was making way for a newer model. And so began the list of possibilities as I combed through various websites (Team-BHP not included).
1. Tata Nexon EV
A friend of ours owned one and had been signing high praises with regards to the quality, comfort, ingress/egress for elders (my parents are 65/70+) etc. Since my parents would soon have been living in an independent house, setting up a charging station would not have been an issue. However, for some reason, both Dad and I felt that we were still 5-10 years away from having an electric car as our primary vehicle. Also, at this point it was not sure which house the new car would be in so an EV would certainly pose a challenge on long distances and could not be a primary driver in either place.
2. Toyota Innova
My mother's wish to have a large(ish) car so that the family could do long distance trips together in one vehicle. Even though we have a driver, Dad and I were not too keen and besides, as a family, we probably do 1-2 road trips a year at best so we could always hire a nice taxi.
3. Maruti Suzuki Ciaz
Trusted reliability of Maruti and having seen a few of them within the extended family, this was a really strong contender. Nothing wow about it but purely from a practical point of view, there was nothing we could find wrong with it. This was kept as an open option.
4. Honda City Hybrid
I had read online that Honda India was planning to introduce a real hybrid car by Mid 2021 and this was certainly a very promising option. Dad also got excited by this possibility. In my personal opinion, the Honda City is about as perfect as a sedan of that category can get when majority of your driving is within the city. Comfort and space are really top of the category.
5. Vento / Rapid from VW Group
Solid cars and I heard many good things about the new engine with the Torque Converter ATs. However, there was some apprehension on my part towards European Petrol cars and the amount of fuel they guzzle. It was a pity that VAG stopped selling Diesel cars in India else the VW Vento Diesel AT would've been a no brainer. Yes, despite the issues with the DSG, I would've bet on it with my sedated driving style.
6. Jeep Compass
I'd driven a Compass in Switzerland towards the end of 2019 for a few days and had enjoyed the handling of the car. And the thought of owning a proper SUV was exciting. The excitement was short lived since the petrol engine wasn't reviewed well and the Diesel was way out of budget.
7. Kia Seltos
With the repeated "suggestions" from friends to look at the Korean Twins, I finally called up KIA's dealer in Yeshwantpur and asked him to brig over a Diesel AT to our office in Peenya for a test drive. This was sometime in February 2021. We drove around for 3-4 km and came away extremely impressed with the car. Drove well, Dad slid in and out of the back seat with no trouble and I personally thought the Seltos really looks nice. We got the prices and told the Sales guy that we'd touch base again in a week's time. He never bothered to call back again. I assume Kia is flooded with orders so letting go of the odd customer isn't going to kill them. When discussing this with BHPian keroo1099, he sent me this link about the safety ratings for the Seltos. (
https://www.team-bhp.com/news/kia-se...ap-crash-tests). And then began my spiral down the Team-BHP worm hole! :-)
Now before we get into how I finalise the car, it is important to note that of all the cars we bought in the family since 2003, I have been part of the decision making along with my Dad. Our criteria for selection was mainly driven by factors such as does it fit our parking, does it "feel" nice to drive, estimated cost of ownership, interiors and stereo and finally the price. Never have we bothered about airbags, safety rating etc. So when I started to read every review on this forum, it confused the hell out of me so much so that it seemed that no car was worth buying and yet every car was good in its own way. Buying a pre-owned car was never an option for various reasons until I read multiple accounts on this forum about the benefits of considering one.
In April, just before the second lock down, one of my friends who runs a independent garage told me that there was a 2007/2008 BMW 525i available in great condition and quoted at Rs. 6 Lakhs. It had run only 50K km. My first thought was that it is a 14 year old car so one never knows what to expect by way of issues later on. However, at 6 Lakhs, if the car lasted even three years without troubles, it may still be worth it. So I took a test drive. Boy was it underwhelming!! Maybe I went in expecting that a Bimmer would be a thrill ride. It was not even close so I passed on the opportunity. Another suggestion given by a friend was to scout the websites of the three German giants for company offered pre-owned cars. Both Mercedes Benz and BMW had inventory but well over my budget.
In June, immedaitely after the lockdown, I came across a nice white Audi A3 35TDI on their Audi Approved Plus website (
www.audiapprovedplus.in). This car looked in great nick, was 3.5 years old and had run only 15,200+ km. I asked for the vehicle to be brought home and they did so within a couple of days. My wife and I took a short test drive around our area and I immediately fell in love with it. The 2.0 Diesel brought back the thrill of Diesel (which I had forgotten having driven a Honda City & A-Star petrols for the last 7 years) and was in my favourite white colour. The sales person and I shook hands and agreed to come to the showroom for a more detailed inspection under the hood and to discuss pricing.
A week later, I went there with two people whose judgement and opinion mattered a lot to me. One from the technical point of you and another from the commercial side. Technically the car showed no reasons to worry. A service, some odd painting and a cleanup would've done the job. When we sat down to discuss commercials, we couldn't agree on the price. Audi offered a lower price than they last quoted if I was willing to surrender the 2 years unlimited km warranty. Armed with all my readings from Team-BHP, I knew this was not negotiable. We walked away with my friend being very confident that they would relent and give it at our price.
After a few days, I called again to check whether they wanted to sell the car not and they said that they want to sell me the car but not at the price I quoted. Given that this was a one off piece and in this condition, I was not willing to let it slip away so I countered by asking them to change the battery & wiper blades, repaint the rear bumper and left rear passenger door to rid it of scratches and dents. This time they agreed and we finally closed the deal by Mid July. The final amount was marginally over my budget but this became a case of heart trumping the head. 10 days later, my wife and I picked up the car and drove it over to my parents' house who had no clue that I'd decided to buy this car.
A few days into driving around the car, I saw the tyres had a number of micro cracks and was recommended to get them changed immediately. There was even a misunderstanding on my part which was clarified within a few hours of creating a new post on this forum. (
https://www.team-bhp.com/forum/tyre-...rstanding.html (Why is my 2017 Audi wearing tyres from 2012? EDIT: Was a misunderstanding)) I immediately got them changed to Michelin Pilot Sport 4 on recommendation from Madhus. I have now driven around 800km with this car within city limits and two trips to the airport. Here is what I like and don't like about the car. I am not including stuff like boot space, rear space etc because these were known to me prior to purchase.
Dislikes
- The parking sensors start to go off whenever I am in traffic at speeds less than 10 kmph. These can be manually switched off by pressing a button but needs to be done everytime I get into such a situation. In a city like Bengaluru, you can only imagine how many times the sensors go off.
- For a premium car built in 12/2017, I wish they had included Apple Car Play and/or Android Auto. Not sure if Audi can upgrade the MMI for me.
-
Likes
- The 2.0L TDI coupled with DSG (thankfully DQ250) is just a treat to drive! After the Skoda Laura, this is really giving me highway thrills
- So far, with my light footed driving style in the city, the on board computer shows a fuel efficiency of 14 kmpl which I suspect practically would more in the region of 13-13.5kmpl.
- The minimalistic design of the entire front dashboard. The MMI screen popping in and out does cause me some concern about reliability but when the screen is pushed back in, the design is just flawless.
- The coffee brown leather / fabric combination seat covers
- The audio system (coming from a tinny Honda City) is just a treat to the ears. I know there may be better systems out there but for me, this is pure pleasure.
- Flashy puddle lights with the Audi logo has garnered more reactions from everyone who sat in the car more than the car itself. :-) My Mum thought the lighting (Puddle, DRLs, footwell etc) were very impressive.
A big thanks to
deepfreak15 for his A3 ownership thread
https://www.team-bhp.com/forum/test-...um-plus-3.html (I bought an Audi A3 35 TFSI Premium Plus) which I read in detail before purchasing this car and my good friend
keroo1099 for all the technical help is continues to provide me with all things automotive.
Here are some pictures of the car. I'm looking forward to many drives and memories with this one.

Fancy lights that seem to attract more attention that the car itself :-)

Rear seats with the nice floor mats that the previous owner had purchased and kept in great condition

Side view of the car

Front dashboard view. Brown seats have always been a fascination for me but never actually thought to spend more money that the stock seats that every car came with

Front view. The Skoda Laura from Mumbai has also been driven down to Bengaluru for a complete overhaul since my father wishes to use it for long(ish) drives. He absolutely loves the car.