Re: Renault Duster : Official Review Thanks a lot guys for all your valuable inputs. Quote:
Originally Posted by Tgo There's just too much done to the car to pin point the problem. Can you recall how and when did this problem begin? Was it after an accident repair, going in a big pothole, a service, a wheel rotation, a tyre change? |
I drive mostly on tar roads with full of pot-holes , rough and uneven surface. Pot-hole must have to be the main culprit here. AFAI remember, this problem has started about a year back. Quote:
Originally Posted by revvharder The Service Centre is just fleecing either you need a good FNG or you need to pin point it yourself.
As bhpian Tgo said, do share when it started.
It could be that the rim has a bend enough to affect the ride quality but not to leak the air, this can be simply ruled out by swapping wheels with another duster or swapping the front to back and vice versa. |
I completely agree on FNG part. However I am a bit skeptical as I have never exercised that option yet. "Dusty" has been to ASC only.
Tyre+wheel swapping is done regularly whenever I go for Wheel Alignment and balancing after every 5k kms. So Front-Back swapping happens regularly. Swapping wheels with another duster is the way to go but finding another duster for this task seems difficult. Quote:
Originally Posted by DirtyDan From what you describe, this sounds like simply a classic case of worn out tie rod ends. However, this SHOULD have been one of the first things that your mechanics checked. Also, the alignment guys should have noticed if the tie rod ends were bad. Steering rod assembly sounds plausible. But it also sounds like just an educated guess as opposed to a clearly diagnosed fact. I would ask around and see there is a mechanic shop with a superior reputation in your general area and I would take it there.
Have you ever hit any bumps in the road very hard, front or even rear? Do you have any uneven wear pattern on your tyres e.g. tyres wearing on the inside or outside edges? Or, any scalping/cupping of the tread? Front or even rear tyres?
Anything like this in the steering is potentially dangerous. You could possibly lose steering control completely if whatever is wrong fails completely. That can kill you and/or somebody else easily.
I hope you will attend to this IMMEDIATELY. Expense is secondary to safety. |
It looks like Reputed Mechanic shop is the only option left now. I would get Tie rod ends checked and changed if needed in the next visit.
I mostly drive on rough tar road surface with full of pot-holes and uneven surface. All 4 Tyres are brand new and I had changed old tyres only to get rid of this problem but new tyres could not solve it either and the problem still persists.
Maybe I failed to state my problem accurately regarding steering. I wanted to say, the returning ability of steering (Spring Action) has not remained as quick and responsive as it used to be till first 75k kms; when on one unfortunate day, battery and alternator failed simultaneously leading to stiff steering. So I changed both the battery and alternator post which the power steering started working again however I could not retrieve the original steering returning response like how it used to be before. Quote:
Originally Posted by redliner83 Hi Dusterboy. Your problem could be due to damaged rear axle bushings, ....
Or maybe an "intentional" misdiagnosis helps the Service Centre sell more parts & services to an unsuspecting customer, going by your case that you are being asked to shell out another 60000 rupees to replace all four wheels after all the replacements already done, when the SA could've simply borrowed another set of tyres&wheels from another car for a short test drive. Also, replacing wheel bearings on all corners at one go was totally unwarranted. |
I will get 'rear axle bushings' checked and changed in the next visit for sure. ASC guy himself suggested me to get all repairing done from garages outside as they were instructed directly to replace with new spare parts without repairing anything. Quote:
Originally Posted by Tgo You must however, shoot a mail to Renault customer car describing the parts changed on your car without any result. State that you feel you are being taken for a ride by changing parts based on poor diagnosis. Let it be logged that you have spent enough and whatever needs to be changed should now be on Renault's head or the Dealer's head since you have had enough of their incompetence.
Do this before you send your vehicle to them for whatever part they have told you needs to be replaced now. |
Suspensions/ Shockers were changed only because they were worn out and damaged. I myself changed all 4 tyres from outside though old tyres could have lasted for another 10-15k kms. Only thing Renault SS guys asked me to get changed was all Wheel Ball Bearings with bush pressing which I consented to. Other than that there was no result driven diagnosis as such from their side but mere guess work. Sometimes I even felt whether I was talking to a layman or what upon listening their suggestions (I don't dare to call them diagnosis). |