This is my first car, I wanted to buy a car that provides a comfortable ride and reliable over the long term and it should be diesel (its Torque!! Not just for mileage).
Choices:
I had done test drive of almost all hatchback, sedan available at that time, started with swift and i20 went all the way up to XUV 5OO, Test drive and the selection process took around 3 months of time. After test driving multiple cars which include VW Vento, Verna, Polo, Linea, Punto, Ecosport, Duster, Swift, i20, Etios Liva, Etios, XUV and Ford Fiesta, I had shortlisted the following.
Hyundai i20 :
Likes:- Best looking hatchback, looks better than swift.
- 1.4L Diesel engine, fast and fuel-efficient.
- practical book space for a hatchback.
- A lot of new features.
Dislikes:- Never liked Hyundai steering at high speed, its light lacks feedback.
- Ride and handling at high speed.
- Hyundai service cost higher than competitor and premium price tag.
Hyundai Verna:
Likes:- 1.6L Diesel, the most powerful engine in this segment.
- Ride quality at city speed.
- Spacious cabin, interior quality.
- Many segment-first features, reversing camera, electric folding mirrors, and more.
Dislikes:- High-speed dynamics and ride quality. Softly tuned suspension.
- Light steering, Lacks feedback at high speed.
- Low ground clearance.
Ford EcoSport:
Likes:- Futuristic design, Looks stylish (especially from front and side).
- Well sorted dynamics and handling for SUV, car-like to drive.
- Safety features, 6 Airbags, ABS + EBD, ESP, and Hill hold (AT).
- Build quality.
Dislikes:- Stiff suspension, ride quality not as comfortable as Duster.
- 1.5L Diesel, Nowhere close to Hyundai's 1.6L Diesel in terms of performance.
- Sub 4 Meter SUV.
- Narrow cabin, best suited for 4 people not for 5, cramped interior.
Renault Duster
Likes:- Excellent ride quality. Comfortable over any kind of road.
- 205mm of ground clearance.
- 1.5L Diesel offers good drivability, Consistent Mileage, and Reliable.
- Practical Boot space (475 - 1064 liters).
Dislikes:- Interior quality fit and finish, not up to mark.
- Renaults after-sales service quality is unknown.
- Large boot but mediocre rear legroom would have liked more legroom.
- Missing features, mid variant(RXL) doesn’t has automatic climate control, ABS, etc.
XUV 500:
Likes:- Powerful diesel engine.
- The new design and looks stylish.
- interior quality, a lot of features and was well priced.
Dislikes:- The suspension setup is on the softer side, gets bumpy at high speed.
- Reliability issues over freshly designed Mahindra cars.
- Niggles and issues reported by XUV owners.
After considering the pros and cons, I booked Duster 85Ps RXL, soon after Ecosport was launched, I did a short test drive( There was a queue for TD). I liked the car and thought of booking it, after a couple of days I requested for TD during the weekday, I did 5-6 km TD didn’t like the suspension it was on stiffer side and cabin was not as spacious as Duster. Even though on paper EcoSport Engine is 5 PS more powerful than Duster 85Ps, I felt the duster engine was more drivable.
Day 0
80k+ km on odo
Most recent pic
Good part:
Out of all these cars I test drove, duster was the only car which offered the best ride quality and decent handling under 15Lkahs and only car in C2 segment which is comfortable over any kind of road and at both city and highway speeds, I liked 85PS because it has less turbo lag, offers Good drivability in the city and has adequate power on the highway, cruising at 90-110 is not a problem at all and steering feedback is good (it's hydraulic). Only when you cross 120 mark steering becomes light, it doesn’t give much feedback and the engine starts losing grunt. It takes a considerable amount of time to reach 150kmph(driven only couple of times to test top speed).
Duster engine(85PS) is low rpm friendly, there is not much turbo lag and you won't feel sudden surge once turbo kicks in, power delivery is linear, once you cross 4k rpm it starts making harsh noise it doesn’t like to revv further(there is no point in revving beyond 4k), unlike 1.3MJD which is high rpm friendly and best-driven post 2.5k rpm.
The engine hasn’t lost its power even after 80k and it still gives consistent mileage. One thing I observed is the engine is very sensitive to rpms, you will see a change in the mileage( I mean mileage differs even within a narrow rpm range 2400,2500,2600 rpms) when driving at different rpms on the highway.
Likes:- Excellent ride quality, comfortable over any kind of road. Comfortable at both city and highway speeds.
- 205mm of ground clearance.
- 1.5L Diesel offers good drivability, Consistent Mileage, and Reliable.
- Practical Boot space (475 - 1064 liters).
- Mechanically reliable (no issues with engine, transmission, and suspension).
- Car-like to drive, good highspeed stability.
Recent Highway drive returned a mileage of 20.8kmpl( around 20kmpl considering errors) for a distance of 787 km(below pic)
Niggle and Issues:
Rattling noise from the front left side, rear doors whenever you go through a rough patch. The issue with AC knob which is used to adjust the direction of airflow, it was hard initially and gave up after 5 years, multiple owners reported AC knob issue. Few owners reported water leakage into the cabin but luckily never faced this.
- AC is not powerful, it takes time to cool the cabin(in summer).
- Tough to find a comfortable seating position(driver seat).
- Less storage space in both front and rear, no armrest in the mid variant.
- No Dead pedal.
- Diesel 1.5L 85PS lacks punch on the highway.
- No Rubber beading on Door (added in the later model).
- Heavy clutch.
Cost of ownership:
Initially, I changed engine oil every 5k km to just to keep service interval multiple of 10k, Post-warranty period that after 4 years I am changing oil at every 7k km. Have changed the clutch at 77000 km, it was not completely worn out but it had become hard (clutch is already on the heavier side in the new car) and was difficult to drive in Bangalore traffic, the mechanic suggested changing post 85k km. but I insisted to change to make it less heavy ( I like the clutch in my other car Punto, it's very soft).
I haven't maintained all the receipts, so it's difficult to give the exact amount of money spent on maintaining the car.
The list of parts changed:- Clutch Plate @77000km
- Rear drum brake actuators @ 77000km.
- Running on the 3rd set of front disc brake pads ( changed twice).
- Front tires changed at 45k km and rear tires at 55k km.
- AC knob ( the one used for adjusting airflow direction).
- Headlights.
- Transmission oil changed once.
- Front right and rear left suspension had oil leakage @30k km.
- Rearview mirror (right side).
- Underbody anticorrosion treatment had worn out after 3 years, re-applied at free of cost by the service center. It was identified and suggested by SA, I didn't notice.
Timing kit is due for a change, mechanic advised to change after 85k km, there is no noise related to timing kit. The engine is running smooth.
Accessories/upgrades:- Race Dynamics DieselTronic
- Head unit - Atoto A6 pro android HU.
- ODB reader.
- TPMS ( 1st with a separate display, then bought one compatible with an android head unit).
- USB Dashcam( Compatible with HU).
- 90/100 w headlights with wiring kit.
- Morel Tempo 6'' 2-way component system.
- JBL amplifier and subwoofer( Removed now).
Race Dynamics DieselTronic - Have installed this recently( a year back), Comes with 4 modes, can select modes with a remote.
Modes: E - Eco mode, this is for mileage, have rarely used this.
S - Stock mode(stock mapping), This is the mode I use most of the time.
P1 - More powerful than stock, they also claim better mileage ( I haven't tested mileage part). I use this mode in highway drives, don’t have to downshift for overtaking, and provide good throttle response.
P2 - Most powerful, I have used this few times just to check the acceleration, Engine makes harsh sound and I don't use this mode.
Head unit: Atoto A6 pro Android HU
Amazon Link:
https://www.amazon.com/ATOTO-A6Y2721...7093408&sr=8-1 Features- Dual Bluetooth one connected ODB reader and the second one for mobile.
- Android 6.0( Have received 2 firmware updates).
- Toshiba pre-amplifier with 4x29w (RMS) power output: For most users, this is enough, don’t need an additional amplifier, and sound quality is good.
- Bluetooth 5.0 with Aptx.
- Fast boot - less than 2s, it doesn’t switch off for at least 1 week(don’t know if other HU also does same), it stays in low power state for a week ( using this from 1+ year, haven't faced the issue with the battery, bit early to judge).
TPMS: Comes with USB receiver, you need an android head unit for this. Bought from AliExpress.
Removed one sensor intentionally for the pic (to show warning).
Morel Tempo 6'' 2-way component system: Best speakers in the car I heard till now, it cost me around 13k for pair, you need an amplifier if you want to get best out of these, these speakers have excellent midrange and highs. Bass is decent not the best.
Even after 7 years, whenever I drive it, even though it looks old school by design and interior quality is not up to mark. Its suspension, handling, drivability and reliability of engine keeps me happy, I wouldn't sell this car even if I upgrade!!