Quote:
Originally Posted by amalji
This is the comparo, I have for Figo/Liva
Figo Positives
Better NVH Control
Meter - Tacho/Fuel status
Alloy Wheels
Looks good inside
Liva Positives
Better Drivability
Better power delivery ( The Fiesta classic Felt really sluggish especially on trips to hills )
Sure slotting gears
Better Driving Position
Progressive Acceleration
Ergonomics ( The speedo was useless for me, after I used the steering tilt on Fiesta. It cut right across the speedo and rpm meter ),
the horn was so hard to press from a comfortable position while steering,
the indicators accidentally turns on, if I'm not careful while using the dim/bright button carefully,
The indicator button on the left side means you cannot turn it on while having your hand on gears.
The travel for height adjustment of the new Liva is leagues ahead.
|
The Figo does not have the same speedo as the Fiesta and it has never been a problem for me in the Figo.
The horn is not at all hard for me. Infact I press it with tip of my thumb. Indicator and headlight high/low beam has not been a problem for me for the last 3 years. Never have I accidentally turned on the indicators. Indicator button on the left is not a negative at all. Infact I prefer it that way compared to my Altis that has on the right. There are 2 ways to this and Ford, VW, Skoda, Mercedes, BMW, Audi prefer it on the left.
And besides you should not need to use the indicators when turning. The use of indicators is to signal before a turn.
All the points you mentioned are not at all negatives but minor differences between cars. Just because the Etios Liva does it one way and other cars do it in another it does not really make it a negative.
Seat height adjust is the only thing I agree on. The Figo has a poor adjustment.
Quote:
- Does Figo/Swift ( the cars which we compared give FGT ? )
- With an older technology, smaller FGT and bigger engine combination, Toyota provides a better torque curve shape, peak torque over an rpm range instead of on a single point, progressive acceleration and better mileage at the cost of 4% lesser torque to weight ratio. I would take that any day.
 |
I was saying in the segment and not just between 2 cars. FGT is there in Figo and Swift but Swift has a DOHC engine 4 valve per cylinder engine. The Etios is pretty much the oldest technology similar to the Figo so Toyota is not doing anything ground breaking.
Quote:
They gave- a bigger cabin
- a bigger boot
- piezo electric injectors
- fuel filter design that lasts the lifetime of the car
- air filters that lasts 40,000 kms
- coolant that lasts 1,50,000 kms
- the best brakes in its class
- an excellent engine with fantastic drivability
- and a car that is so cheap to maintain and run
|
I don't really care if the injectors are made of piezo electric or some exotic material. In the end how the car drives is what matters to me.
They might have given all that you mentioned but does it translate to sales numbers?
Quote:
In contrast, 30% of Toyota sales constitute flop model ( according to you ). Still they are financially healthy. So, I'm not sure how much of a flop they are.
Now regarding sales, these are the numbers from February 2013
Figo - 3804
Fiesta - 503
Total - 4308
Etios - 2797
Liva - 1698
Total - 4495
While the hatchback version of Ford churns out good numbers, the sedan variant churns out pathetic numbers. And inspite of the fact that Liva doesn't offer a premium variant for Liva Diesel, the total sales still exceeds the Fiesta/Figo combination.
|
This is a biased comparison. Mind you the Fiesta classic is a much older model although based on the Fiesta. It was never meant to be in the C1 segment.
Instead of comparing the combined numbers let's just compare the Figo vs Liva numbers which is 1698 vs 3804. The discussion was on these 2 products and not on the sedan. I have already acknowledged that the sedan is decently speced but priced on higher side.
Etios should be compared with Dzire, Sunny and even Rapid.
Quote:
This is what I felt after the trip to Munnar on Fiesta Classic.
|
No problem at all. In my case I felt the Liva was extremely poor at speeds in terms of stability, the steering felt very light with zero feedback. The gearbox did not like quick gear changes and it was a pain sitting inside with the diesel clatter on the highway.
The new one might have lesser noise but the highway stability, steering feel, handling still has a long way to go.
Quote:
Why doesn't the same car sell in volumes in countries other than in India ?
Reasons are simple.
|
So why did Toyota bring to India a cheaper stripped down car? If you want volume comparison lets compare the Swift sales as well in other countries. Oh wait we can compare swift but there is no Liva in other countries cause it was only for 3rd world countries.
Figo and Fiesta Classic are nothing but UK variants of the Fiesta. Pretty much the same package as UK just facelifted. They are a generation old but are still the same vehicles.
Quote:
single wiper -
Plastics - |
The single wiper feature has been openly advertised by Toyota as a cost saving feature and it is very assuming that you are actually saying it is an added feature.
The plastics on my old Maruti 800 also never had an issue in the 8 years I own it. I guess your trying to say that the Etios feels similar.
At the end of the day, one may argue that the Etios is better than the Dzire and the Liva is better than the Swift. But Maruti is the one laughing all the way to the bank and Toyota is the one who had to go back to the drawing board to fix some glaring omissions in their cars.
They heavily underestimated the indian public and thought that they could shove down basic, stripped down built to a cost product and get away with it by assuming that the Toyota brand name would be enough.