RE resolution to rich mixture/jerk /sooting/misfiring issue and "All is well"
Anyone who has been reading through this thread silently or has participated with their experiences of ownership on here knows all about the issues mentioned above.
I have been saying from day one the cause of the
Black smoke issue and related problems from it was due to the ECU mapping and much needed O2 sensor. From time to time RE has been admitting to this and then dismissing this problem all together. I had plenty of heated arguments with RE officials during the last year and so did rest of the comrades across India who were not happy with their C5's. But they never provided us with a proper solution, reasons best known to RE.
All I ever got from them was some info on and off about the solution and some plugs to keep quit. Nonetheless things never came out too positive from their end.
Things went from RE planning to remap ECU ended up with the hotter plugs which were supposed to heat up quickly to burn the soot created within few seconds of cold crank. Well the new plugs did helped a bit but still needed some dedication from the owners to adapt a bit to keep them plugs from sooting too. Some still have issues worse then others and the saga continues..
RE has worked out another solution temporarily for now and supposedly working on remapping the ECU to get over with this issue once and for all.
What I am not sure about is that what if their promise again turns out to be a rumour just like what happened with the swing arm update. What surprises me with RE is that one part of RE works out a solution and then the other part says no to it and all the planning gets scrapped. I know for sure they did developed the swing arm and it was about to go into production but got scrapped just at the end and we got was a 19inch front tyre and they showed us the door. That tells how much they care about people who spent their money on their bikes and ride a dangerous bike which has the ability to snuff out a riders life.
So their permanent solution to black smoke issue is to remap ECU which according to them will be done by end of April. But if thats the case then probably the new UCE 500 planned for launch will get delayed.
What I have got to know is that they will swap the ECU of C5 owners who have soot problem but again not sure if this will be applicable to all existing C5 owners who are way past the warranty or those who have not registered the issue with them so far. Will there be a official recall? which I think will never happen and anyone who can push the right buttons will get the new remapped ECU.
So what is the new temporarily solution has RE offered now!
It's a
another spark plug and darn
it works
Some
history of C5 plugs.
1. First batch
Primary plug- WR7DDC4
Secondary Plug UR5DC
2. Second batch
Primary plug- WQR8DC
Secondary plug- UR6DC
3. Latest upgrade
Primary plug-WR8DP
Secondary plug- UR6DC
So we have got another plug upgrade but only a primary plug needs to be changed.
Whats so special about WR8DP AKA -Bosch Platinum Plus?
Some info
Bosch Platinum Plus
Features
1. Only Bosch uses a platinum center electrode, heat-fused into an extended insulator
2. Tapered, yttrium-enhanced v-profile ground electrode
3. Nickel-plated rolled threads
4. Lower ignition voltage requirements vs. other plug designs
Bosch Platinum Plus
Benefits
1. Reaches self-cleaning temperature only seconds after starting
Electrode gap remains virtually unchanged throughout the plug's longer service life; no need to clean or re-gap
2. Extends service life by 25% vs. original Bosch Platinum, reduces electrode temperature, and improves access to air/fuel mixture
3. For complete anti-seize and corrosion protection
4. For reliable cold weather starts and superior operation under all driving conditions
Above is just the typical Bosch info on the plug and there is only one thing which really matters to us is the burning up of carbon on the plug in seconds.
How good is the plug and does it really resolves anything or it's just another upgrade to keep us busy!
Well after seeing the dude happy after complete one year of dissatisfaction related to black smoke issue and misfiring. I was so excited and I just wanted to try it out for the benefit of others as I am doing just great with my religiously warming up mantra and existing plugs.
Well this is a bit funny incidence and how I caught them off guard with this new upgrade.
Went to RE workshop and met this guy with his troublesome C5. Ok this guy suffered the most because his C5 has never seen a life above 55km/hr in 8k(his Guru ji has ordered him not to ride his bike above 50- RE should speak to his guru personally). I had given up any hope on this guy as personally I had tried my level best to explain the issue and what needs to be done to avoid misfiring. His bike is the first bike in my life I have seen who's front brake jammed(under 5k) because he never used it properly. Seriously he should be riding one of those electric cycles.
But nonetheless he came religiously to workshop trying to sort his bike out. Religiously RE tried to make him happy by whatever parts they could change for him. Knowing the issue and solution still RE kept changing his parts and as usual he got another new part yesterday- a new fuel injector. As usual the missing was as prominent as always.
Then I hear the engineer saying today we will sort it out and I was just grinning silently for the outcome. So the Er orders two mechanics to take the bike and get something fitted. Well my sharp ears got more curious as this was out of the ordinary so waited impatiently to see an end to this episode.
Half an hour went by and the guys came back saying all is well. I was not expecting any happy moments so me being me, got more curious. First time in whole one year, I see this guy leaving within minutes with his bike with the biggest smile I had ever seen on his face.
It was enough for me to get to this new mysterious upgrade and I used the invisible Quickfix to get whatever I could from the Er.
So politely he explained me what they had done and what it was. From what I gathered about the plug was that RE had imported some special plugs from germany and they have handed out the plugs in limited numbers to dealers throughout India. He did not had a spare one for me as this plug was not available in India and specially imported through Bosch India.
Now I was pissed off and I had every good reason to find this plug in India. Got the plug no from him and thought of trying to find some info on this plug. Spent last night being excited and looking for this plug but got no success finding it online in India. So today went straight to the Bosch main dealer and armed with only the part no. So the guy at the reception quite politely tells me this plug does not exist in his inventory. I asked for the catalogue to search it myself and did mentioned him that this plug is not made for Indian market but probably being imported by Bosch.
To my surprise and his surprise it was listed as an OEM replacement for few cars in India. He had only one left and I grabbed it straight away. Although this plug is not meant for two wheelers but fits like a glove in our C5. Called Er and told the story about the plug, he was surprised too as compared to what RE had given him a goofed up story of these specially ordered plugs which were not available in India. RE had provided them with hardly any plugs and RE was also refusing them for any more new plugs telling them about how hard it was for them to get these plugs specially imported into India. RE Er wanted 50 more and this dealer could get him within two days so gave him his details to Er to conduct their deal directly by-passing the RE Chennai with their cooked up story for shortage of plugs.
Came home, fitted the plug as per instructions and waited for the rain to stop. Went out for a 30km ride so I could give you my feedback on this magic plug.
Is this new plug really a improvised solution to our long lasting problem? Yes it does, finally we have something which works. Hallelujah.
Observations based on a short 30km ride
What I looked for while testing this plug;
1. Warm up time
2. Starting-
3. Missing/misfiring - at idle to speed upto 80
4. jerks- during sudden input to throttle
5. Hiccups- usually felt under 60km/h while going at constant speed in any gear
6. Throttle response and top speed
7. Smoke
Results!!!
1. Warm up time- Usually my bike takes 3minutes to dispense vapours from rear but this time it took 2.5min to warm up.
2. Starting- Very crisp and I intentionally cranked it 4 times on/off. Normally if you crank it more then twice in succession, bike starts burping the moment it comes to life but this time it started fresh at every crank.
3. Missing/ misfiring- None but I cant say much as I did not suffer from this so those people who are actually facing this issue could comment.
4. Jerks- As I said earlier, due to EFI it will always be there but felt a reduction of 20%
5. Hiccups- Just this point is worth spending money on. Usually it comes when going in 3,4,5 gear at constant speed and under 60. I tried everything and failed miserably trying to get the hiccups even once. I tried in 3rd gear for 4km at a speed of 30, 4th gear at 40 for 4km. Darn I lugged it for first time intentionally and still not a faint hint of a hiccup. Note- people may term things differently and some might call this as a jerk or missing so I have specified above in detail. Whatever makes sense that term applies to you.
6. Throttle response/ top speed- It's crisp throughout the rev range and in all gears the feel is very consistent. Topped the same on my usual test road but torque felt different and very healthy.
7. Smoke- It was dark so cant say, will see in the morning.
I give this Bosch Platinum Plug
and highly recommend to those who are facing any of those issues above.
Where you can get it.
It's a Bosch Platinum Plus, plug no WR8DP. Bosch catalogue no is -0242 229 555 000. MRP Rs 250. Should be able to get it from a Bosch dealer in your town. If that fails then you can rob it from Maruti's stable from M800, Omni, Zen, Esteem 1000 (all carbed versions) & Matiz. But if you are civilised then you can just drop in at any descent Maruti dealer and get one form their parts store or any spare parts shop which keeps spares for Maruti.
Special Installation guide from RE- yes kid you not.
It's a word to word instructions copy so please keep profanity at bay. I izz not be be blamed for this tedious guide and rest.
Things to be taken care of while fitting the new WR8DC Platinum Plus spark plug
1) Remove booth spark plugs
2) Add one additional washer in UR6DC spark plug(no need of replacement) use only spark plug washer which can be reused from any damaged UR6DC
3) Apply the kick 4-5 times
4) Remove the +ve terminal from battery
5) Put ignition key in on position
6) Apply the all electrical function 4-5 times like horn, head light, indicators, front & rear brake light & electrical starter
7) Fit the booth spark plug (WR8DP & UR6DC)
8) Apply the kick 4-5 times
9 Re connect the battery terminal
10) Start the vehicle and put in ideal RPM for 1-2min.
I hope whoever tries the new plug gets positive result.