31st January 2023, 19:07 | #61 | ||
Senior - BHPian Join Date: Oct 2013 Location: Stickn' Around
Posts: 1,158
Thanked: 3,092 Times
| Re: Suzuki Gixxer SF 250 vs VStrom 250 vibrations Quote:
Another dissident is how can Suzuki handicap their Gixxer couterpart vis-a-vis their V Strom counterpart is beyond me. I sincerely believe there's more to this issue than what meets the eye, unless we as owners are given a justifiable answer from someone higher up in the R&D which is tall order I guess. But Neil, what you've done here is not the end of a saga, it's the beginning of a new awareness saga that should reach every 250 owners out there. Quote:
Cheers! VJ | ||
(5) Thanks |
The following 5 BHPians Thank VijayAnand1 for this useful post: | AnAntinspired, neil.jericho, shancz, sukiwa, t3rm1n80r |
|
31st January 2023, 19:29 | #62 | |
Team-BHP Support | Re: Suzuki Gixxer SF 250 vs VStrom 250 vibrations Quote:
I doubt Suzuki has a separate metallurgy (as claimed) for just one bike from the same shared platform. Last edited by CrAzY dRiVeR : 31st January 2023 at 19:30. | |
(7) Thanks |
The following 7 BHPians Thank CrAzY dRiVeR for this useful post: | neil.jericho, rahul4321, rbp, Sebring, shancz, sukiwa, t3rm1n80r |
1st February 2023, 22:39 | #63 |
BHPian Join Date: May 2021 Location: Gujarat
Posts: 63
Thanked: 126 Times
| Re: Vibration issues with Suzuki Gixxer SF 250 Hey there neil.jericho, thank you for keeping us all updated. I agree with you that Suzuki should have voluntarily replaced the entire series of parts on affected motorcycles. Instead, looks like they are unwilling to take responsibility The SF 250 was always my first choice of motorcycle. I'd always found it a very good looking motorcycle and the specs were to my liking as well. I'd even taken a test ride back in June/July and was almost set on buying one. However after following this thread I started to have second thoughts. That the bike has issues is bad enough, but that Suzuki would be so unhelpful and left their customer helpless and running around was completely unacceptable to me, and last week, I took delivery of the FZ 25. It was not on my list originally, because of its low power output and no 6th gear. But after weighing pros and cons I decided to compromise on performance and preserve my sanity instead. Do you expect this "mini-overhaul" has fixed the vibration issue permanently? Or do you think they will come back after some more kilometers? |
(3) Thanks |
The following 3 BHPians Thank SkylineGTR for this useful post: | neil.jericho, sukiwa, t3rm1n80r |
3rd February 2023, 17:46 | #64 | |||
Distinguished - BHPian Join Date: Aug 2009 Location: Cochin
Posts: 3,841
Thanked: 20,037 Times
| Suzuki's cold shouldering ways Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
After hearing me out, the regional service head for Kerala promised to look into the case, and check whether the same warranty replacement would apply to my friend's motorcycle. Based on our discussion, I sent an email to the regional service head for Kerala, with photographs of the motorcycle, requesting him to check if the warranty replacement would be applicable. Also, my friend was facing issues due to the low availability of spare parts in Suzuki dealerships in North Kerala. Despite sending a thorough email to the regional service head for Kerala, with all these points and contact details, nobody from Suzuki has reached out to my friend. It has been a week now. So much for my belief that the officials from Suzuki will be putting in genuine effort to make things right. Sadly, Suzuki is back to sweeping things under the rug, unless you complain long and hard, on a platform such as Team BHP. This is exactly how Suzuki should not be handling customer complaints, and yet, chooses to do so | |||
(7) Thanks |
The following 7 BHPians Thank neil.jericho for this useful post: | BigBrad, carthick1000, ITZ_Zeta, krishnaprasadgg, shancz, t3rm1n80r, vaasu |
3rd February 2023, 22:35 | #65 | ||||
Distinguished - BHPian Join Date: Aug 2009 Location: Cochin
Posts: 3,841
Thanked: 20,037 Times
| Third party perspective My friend and ace mechanic from F Motors, took my GSXRRRRR for a short spin. His feedback on the engine matched what I had posted earlier on this thread - Below 6,000 RPM, he found the motorcycle was really smooth! - From 6,000 RPM onwards, there was a slight buzz from the footpegs and the handlebar. As per his experience, that is par for course, considering that it is a single cylinder motorcycle. I only wish that he had the opportunity to ride the motorcycle in its honeymoon phase of the first 6,000 kilometers, when it was smooth all through the rev range! Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
| ||||
(3) Thanks |
The following 3 BHPians Thank neil.jericho for this useful post: | SchumiFan, Sebring, t3rm1n80r |
4th February 2023, 16:53 | #66 | |
Senior - BHPian Join Date: Apr 2011 Location: Dubai/Bengaluru
Posts: 3,734
Thanked: 11,588 Times
| Re: Third party perspective Hi Neil. I have a 6-8 month overseas assignment, post which I'll be riding the bike again. Unfortunately it's not being ridden currently. I'll update you once I resume
Quote:
| |
() Thanks |
14th February 2023, 10:41 | #67 |
Newbie Join Date: Jul 2022 Location: Hosur
Posts: 6
Thanked: 3 Times
| Re: Vibration issues with Suzuki Gixxer SF 250 Thanks Neil for sharing your experiences. I am planning to get a quarter litre soon and 250 sf was up there in the top of the list. I'll reconsider the order now. |
() Thanks |
14th February 2023, 12:33 | #68 |
Senior - BHPian Join Date: Nov 2009 Location: India
Posts: 1,920
Thanked: 2,297 Times
| Re: Vibration issues with Suzuki Gixxer SF 250 This could also be due to the clip-on handlebars in the SF250 as opposed to the regular bars in the Gixxer 250 naked and V Strom 250. |
(1) Thanks |
The following BHPian Thanks DRIV3R for this useful post: | neil.jericho |
30th March 2023, 23:02 | #69 |
BHPian Join Date: Feb 2015 Location: Thrissur
Posts: 465
Thanked: 992 Times
| Re: Vibration issues with Suzuki Gixxer SF 250
I can confirm that this is not true. The naked Gixxer with regular flat bars also suffer from the vibes. It is not the kind of buzz that's normally associated with big singles. It feels like an engineering issue from Suzuki |
(1) Thanks |
The following BHPian Thanks b16h22 for this useful post: | neil.jericho |
31st March 2023, 00:14 | #70 | |
BHPian Join Date: Feb 2015 Location: Thrissur
Posts: 465
Thanked: 992 Times
| Re: Suzuki Gixxer SF 250 Ownership Review Quote:
I would also like to see if the valve clearances are out of spec. I do hear a good deal of valvetrain chatter at idle. The bike is 15k run and I don't think it was ever checked or adjusted. According to the manual, Suzuki specifies a valve clearance check every 5k. Since these are shim type, I bet they'll take their own sweet time to do that as they have to measure and order the correct sized shims Last edited by b16h22 : 31st March 2023 at 00:30. | |
(1) Thanks |
The following BHPian Thanks b16h22 for this useful post: | neil.jericho |
31st March 2023, 18:08 | #71 |
Distinguished - BHPian Join Date: Aug 2009 Location: Cochin
Posts: 3,841
Thanked: 20,037 Times
| Isolating the 2 issues with the Suzuki 250 platform Suzuki's 250cc engine that is shared between the naked Gixxer, the faired Gixxer SF and the pseudo adventure VStrom, has been a cause of consternation for many owners. While the VStrom 250 owners seem to be a happy lot, the Gixxer and Gixxer SF owners have been struggling with the vibration issues on their motorcycles. Thanks to Team BHP, several of us owners have had a singular platform to share our frustrating experiences. I believe that there are 2 separate issues, that we have conflated thus far. Once we unentangle them, all the problems that were faced by owners, are probably easily explained. Problem #1 is the silky smooth engine refinement going for a toss at ~ 6,000 km mark. Problem #2 is the engine's Achilles heel of it's oil cooling system. Problem #1 - Balancer Related For the Gixxer and Gixxer SF 250 motorcycles, what has been established so far is that - out of the box, the engine is butter smooth all through the rev range. There is 1 exception to this, though. An unsold motorcycle had excess vibrations which were similar to what the rest of us find on our bikes. - the 250 cc engine breaks in at roughly around the 6,000 kilometer mark. That is when the annoying vibrations start creeping in. Again, there are a few exceptions which I have found but this 6,000 kilometer distance seems to be the ballpark. - rather than do a pan India recall for the Gixxer and SF 250, Suzuki did a face saving recall for 199 motorcycles that were manufactured in a particular time period. It has been proven that motorcycles made both, before and after, that time frame, suffer from the same excessive vibrations. - motorcycles that have gotten this balancer related warranty fix done, are a lot smoother than before. Bear in mind that these engines are still not as smooth as what they were in the first 6,000 kilometers. By the end of December, the Suzuki superbike dealership in Cochin had done the warranty recall fix on my bike. In early January, I observed the vibrations were shifting left, which was a phenomenon that really puzzled me. Since then, Ive had the opportunity to clock several thousand kilometers on my motorcycle, most of it while touring. In parallel, I have been chatting with a couple of TBHPians who own the Gixxer and / or the SF 250 and our observations are exactly the same. I believe that now, I have a fair idea on what is behind these unsolved, left behind vibrations that tend to "shift left". This leads us to ... Problem 2 - Oil Cooling System Related In order to understand this issue, below are the observations that led to my conclusion - The sweet spot while touring continuously, is an indicated 90 kmph (actual speed 81 kmph) which is when the engine is spinning at 6,000 RPM in 6th gear. From this point onward, the vibrations increase, almost linearly. Its best to stick to this cruising speed and avoid the fatigue inducing vibrations. - While on a highway ride, I find that the vibrations start to increase after ~ 45 minutes. - On day 1 of a multi-day solo ride, I took a coffee break almost an hour after I left home. When I got back onto the motorcycle, I found that it was a lot smoother than when I stopped. After some time though, when I repeated this, the engine wasnt as smooth when I restarted my riding. Basically, half way into a day long ride and / or in the afternoons, the engine's vibrations were noticeably more pronounced than before. I checked this with different TBHPians and all of them confirmed that they have seen the exact same thing on their bikes. This leads me to believe that the real weak point of the engine is its oil-cooled system. To reduce the engineering complexity and cost of ownership, Suzuki has opted for an oil cooled system, rather than the traditional liquid cooling system that is adopted by say, the TVS Apache RR310 or the Honda CBR250. Ironically, while the oil cooling system does a phenomenal job of keeping the engine temperature under control (this engine simply never gets hot!), the engine oil falters in what should have been its primary responsibility! Apparently, the 250 platform comes with a fan, which I have never heard coming on. As a result, in the mornings, the oil is able to cool faster, while the rider takes a tea break. Thus, the motorcycle appears to smooth after a 15 minute break. On the other hand, once the ambient temperatures are high, the oil needs a lot more time to cool down. Thus, the motorcycle appears to be less smooth after a 15 minute break, as compared to the same situation occurring a few hours before. Simply put, Suzuki's approach to value engineering a simple bike for select (less discerning?) markets, has led to this unrefined and gruff engine. In the grand scheme of things, whether or not owners get the balancer problem sorted out under warranty (a saga in its own right), their motorcycles will still face the issue of the oil cooling system being unable to keep the engine smooth, when it run continuously on highway trips. Long story short, what does this mean for commuters? Absolutely nothing! The Gixxer 250 and the Gixxer SF 250 are great bikes for commuting. They are nimble and have more than enough performance for city conditions, without feeling suffocated. At the same time, you will easily get a mileage of 35+ kmpl. Long story short, what does this mean for tourers? Even if your motorcycle gets the warranty recall done, the 250cc platform isnt great for sports touring. While doing a day long ride / weekend ride / multi-day ride, you cannot keep stopping every 45 minutes and wait for the oil to cool. As a best practice, I typically stop once every 60 minutes to take a water break and keep my mind fresh. Ive had to reduce that to 55 minutes or sometimes even 50 minutes. These frequent stops can get a bit frustrating while touring. Also, to reduce vibrations, you have to keep your GPS speeds in the 80 to 100 kmph zone, which is rather low for a 250cc motorcycle. Unless you are a slow highway rider, this may not be the best motorcycle for hardcore tourers. In summary It is sad that Suzuki, a company which has built its reputation on manufacturing over-engineered engines, has come up with this cost engineered platform which has such a glaring weakness. You dont need to be a rocket scientist to know that the level of R&D which has gone into this, is nowhere close to a similar offering from the very same company that is sold in global markets. That said, most owners have made their peace with the roughness post 6,000 kilometers and are happily enjoying their motorcycles. Barring the engine, there is literally nothing that we can really criticize of the Gixxer and Gixxer SF 250, unless we are really being picky. My suggestion to fellow 250cc owners is to push your local dealer for getting the balancer recall done under warranty. Then, see if you can manage with the reduced vibrations and try out different engine oils to make things smoother. |
(18) Thanks |
The following 18 BHPians Thank neil.jericho for this useful post: | Agarwal_Aayush, b16h22, BigBrad, deerhunter, ITZ_Zeta, krishnaprasadgg, man_of_steel, PreludeSH, pugram, Rocketscience, shancz, Skyline_GT, SnS_12, Srg_99, t3rm1n80r, tchsvy, vaasu, Xaos636 |
|
1st April 2023, 01:10 | #72 | |
BHPian Join Date: Feb 2015 Location: Thrissur
Posts: 465
Thanked: 992 Times
| Re: Isolating the 2 issues with the Suzuki 250 platform Quote:
I took out the bike next morning just tot observe the characteristics and found the first 5 kms incredibly smooth but it got progressively worse as I rode on in traffic and morning heat. Before I bought the Gixxer, I had a discussion with a friend of mine who owns a Strom 250 in KA and he was mentioning about some vibes kicking in after he crossed the 7000km mark. I asked him if the engine was hot and he said yes. The bike used to be perfectly smooth before. And he said he didn't notice the vibes at night the same day. I'll keep an eye on his bike to see how that situation develops. Unfortunately he had a mild accident and the bike is in SVC waiting for parts. I'll update my findings in coming days. I just put 120kms over the 15k by the previous owner. My Duke 390 had out of spec (tight) valve clearances at 32k used to have similar behavior. It used to be gruff when it was hot. I wish I could open up my valve cover and check the clearances myself to see if something is wrong. Since it is under warranty I'm not taking that risk for a while. | |
(4) Thanks |
The following 4 BHPians Thank b16h22 for this useful post: | Grimlock, ITZ_Zeta, neil.jericho, t3rm1n80r |
3rd April 2023, 21:00 | #73 | |
Newbie Join Date: Apr 2022 Location: Wayanad
Posts: 16
Thanked: 129 Times
| Re: Isolating the 2 issues with the Suzuki 250 platform Quote:
| |
(3) Thanks |
The following 3 BHPians Thank ITZ_Zeta for this useful post: | b16h22, neil.jericho, t3rm1n80r |
4th April 2023, 01:27 | #74 | |
BHPian Join Date: Feb 2015 Location: Thrissur
Posts: 465
Thanked: 992 Times
| Re: Isolating the 2 issues with the Suzuki 250 platform Quote:
I might try a different grade oil just as an experiment. Been noticing the gearshifts getting harder and harsher as the engine gets hotter. It is normally fairly slick. | |
(2) Thanks |
The following 2 BHPians Thank b16h22 for this useful post: | neil.jericho, t3rm1n80r |
5th April 2023, 22:29 | #75 | ||||
Distinguished - BHPian Join Date: Aug 2009 Location: Cochin
Posts: 3,841
Thanked: 20,037 Times
| Re: Isolating the 2 issues with the Suzuki 250 platform Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Now I wonder, how have Suzuki VStrom 250 owners (barring your friend, that is) not complained about this issue? One potential factor could be that they are running the bikes for shorter durations / commuting with it, and hence, there isnt enough time for the engine oil to heat up, and cause the infamous vibrations. Also, many VStrom 250 owners might not be hardcore enthusiasts who obsess over every fine detail. Hence, they many not be able to observe these issues, the same way as almost all Suzuki Gixxer / SF 250 owners dont complain about excessive vibrations, even when its clearly there (if you know how to look). Lastly, the VStrom 250 is a market flop, so the sample set is negligible. Overall, this is a very productive and engaging thread but the truth is that the Suzuki 250 motorcycles are simply not cut out for doing sustained touring speeds of 90-100 kmph. Hence, my bike is slowly on the way out the garage. | ||||
(2) Thanks |
The following 2 BHPians Thank neil.jericho for this useful post: | b16h22, Cyborg |