Re: Ola S1 Electric Scooter Review Today got a chance to test ride OLA S1 pro. So, wifey wanted to go to Forum Shantiniketan(FS) mall for some shopping, I knew that the test ride campaign is going at the FS mall, booked an appointment at 6:00pm. Last week I have also tested TVS iQube and exactly on the same date 4 years ago I took a test ride of the Ather 450.
After reaching the mall I went to the OLA booth, where the sales rep explained me about the features, the scooter has move OS 2 beta, the switches on the scooter are easy to remember, I was able to check and feel the scooter.
Compared to my Suzuki Swish(access with different body panels) the plastics seemed slightly better, the plastics of the iQube are comparatively better than OLA S1 and far better than my Swish. The hard plastic used on the iQube dashboard looked very hard and may resist any scratches.
The charge port flap looked very flimsy on S1, it was touching the grab handles while opening and closing, they need to redesign this I believe. I also did not like the charging port on iQube, it is very small, the pins are also very thin, just as thin as my laptop charge port.
After checking my license I was given the scooter for test ride, I was asked to take a uturn at the next signal which is 50m ahead, and again take next u turn which is 150m to reach the mall, total of 300m, that too in a crawling traffic.
I said OK, closed the stand, the stand was firm, I thought it was delicate, seeing that some scooters have fallen. Have put it in reverse, slowly backed out, still worried it may jump forward even though I am not hearing those stories anymore.
I switched to forward and normal mode, reached the traffic signal in the slow moving traffic, took right turn(not u turn), the road was very wide, the scooter was very fast, within few seconds I crossed 70kmph speed, I was not feeling uncomfortable even at that speed. Changed to sport mode, the acceleration is just amazing, reaching 70kmph is so fast, I am more worried any traffic police personnel will stop me. I remember similar feeling with the Ather 450 4 years ago, S1 seems to be faster than the original Ather 450 in sport mode itself. Finally changed to hyper mode, felt the pull is too strong and dangerous, switched to sport mode immediately.
I almost never crossed 60kmph on my Swish, it is too slow and not very confident inspiring after crossing 60kmph, the handling seemed better on S1, I can ride happily at 70 or 80kmph, though those speeds are not possible on our Bangalore roads. I had to give a special mention to the rear suspension of S1, it absorbed all the pot holes very well, I was initially worried about this horizontal setup of the suspension, looks like this setup on S1 is better than the vertical setup on my Swish. The front single fork suspension felt almost similar to my Swish's double fork setup.
The iQube test ride was almost like riding my Swish with electric motor swap, it is slightly faster than other ICE scooters on the road, the suspension also felt like my Swish. I never felt that I was riding an electric scooter with hub motor, it felt like any other scooter. All these talk on sprung weight, unsprung weight is of no help, the hub motor did not give any difference in feel.
May be it is because of my riding style or did not had the need to use both brake and accelerator at the same time in my short ride, I never felt the engine cutoff when holding the brakes, the sales rep specifically warned about this behaviour before the test ride. One issue though, when I reversed for the test ride, it had a slight incline, I need to give throttle without leaving brakes, this issue may be resolved with hill hold feature which is still not part of Move OS 2 beta.
As it happens always with me I forget to test the most important element of an EV, the regen braking, I forgot to test on Ather, I forgot on S1, also may be that I never felt the regen was there on these scooters, the regen may be very mild. The regen on iqube is quiet noticeable, I initially felt why the wheels are not freely rotating, realized that the regen is stopping me.
There is a very slight whining sound compared to Ather on the S1 which I liked, the iqube is dead silent, except the wheels and suspension noise there is virtually no noise at all.
The half face helmets given for test rides are the same helmets sold by OLA, which are very small, both my ears are not covered by the helmet, don't know how ISI approved these helmets, would suggest buying helmets outside even if they are half faced.
I could not test cruise control or the speakers, both useless features for me. I had a short chat with the OLA sales rep after the test ride, I raised my concerns about front suspension failures, according to them the front suspension failures are due to those particular scooters hitting a wall or road divider. At this point I am not particularly concerned about battery fire incident, let's see if it repeats.
Overall I am satisfied with the S1, will wait for few more months for all these issues to be sorted. According to me, iQube is a good product, anyone who are looking for a fuss free 125cc scooter like performance should buy it. I have realized today, as an EV enthusiast I cannot buy an electric scooter with a 4.4kw motor, i want something which is fast. It is either OLA S1 pro or Ola S1 or any future Ather product with higher range, I wanted to particularly avoid established players, I can take risk of startups on a scooter atleast.
Last edited by SKC-auto : 19th June 2022 at 02:22.
|