Re: Royal Enfield Thunderbird 500 : My Motorcycle Diaries Dear Mr.J Ravi – hello again after quite sometime. I salute you, hats off to you for living my dream. I always wanted to do 1000 kms in one day on a Bullet, which you have realized. I need your opinion / help because the “Bullet Bug” just refuses to stop pestering me.
About a month back, in my good old "Dadar Parsi Colony" in Mumbai, there was this nice “Parsi Owned” 2010 model 350cc Black Bullet Thunderbird, owned by my son’s school friend’s father. The gentleman wanted to sell it because he wanted to buy a brand new 500cc Bullet Thunderbird. I saw it late at night inside the colony. It had covered around 22000 kms. All the parts were absolutely original. The shining black and chrome gleamed brightly in the streetlights. I particularly loved the straight and long silencer protruding behind the rear wheel and the fantastic riding position which was absolutely perfect for my average height. The seat cocooned me perfectly. The foot pedal positioning was spot-on. I took a small round. The bike was very easy to handle around corners and did not feel heavy at all. I did not buy it for three reasons, as follows: 1. There was pronounced piston slap noise from the engine. 2. Gear shifting was completely vague. 3. Fourth gear was noisy in drive mode; there was no noise in coast mode. He has since sold this bike.
Last week, he bought a brand new 500cc Bullet Thunderbird. I saw this bike also, again late at night. It had covered only 200 kms. I did not like the matt black finish, I prefer the shiny black but that’s my personal opinion. I was disappointed with the stubby silencer, personally I preferred the long one (maybe it's required due to emission / noise norms or the styling guys goofed). The seat position for riding was also not as comfortable as the older version’s; the cocooning effect was not there, although the seat height was just about OK. The foot pegs were positioned a little forward, due to which I found the riding stance a little awkward. I took a small round on this bike also. It was quite easy to handle around corners, although not as good as the older one. In this one also, the gear shift was vague and hard and fourth gear was very noisy in drive mode (absolutely not acceptable), but there was no noise in coast mode. The chain was noisy too. There was no piston slap but I guess it is too early to comment @ 200 kms!
I work in the automotive industry (I am based out of Pimpri, Pune) and I am a vehicle development / vehicle evaluation engineer by profession. My daily job is to conduct tests as per DVPs (Design Validation Plans), identify vehicle issues, conduct root cause analyses and implement corrective actions to eliminate them in production. Therefore, I guess these inferences come naturally to me. These are clearly manufacturing related issues. Manufacturing and build quality-wise, this powertrain and chassis integration platform needs to go a long way to attract potential customers like me. At a price of Rs.1,87,000 on road in Mumbai, this thing is not exactly cheap; it just cannot have a noisy gearbox, vague shift and a noisy chain. Also, the 2010 model looked better, this one is not as good looking.
I absolutely love the Bullet as it gives me a unique sort of pleasure to own it. I really don’t want it but I must have it. It will be used for Sunday drives. I don't mind the price. However, I just cannot accept the presence of these product issues. The last thing I want to hear is “Saar, drive till first free service Saar” / “Saar, oil is changed now Saar” / “Saar, all vehicles are like this only Saar”. I just don’t have the time or inclination to get into such situations with dealers' workshop managers and technicians who are well meaning and simple folk but have no power to do anything to actually correct the issues. I know that they will replace the entire gearbox @ "level 1 part number production part as supplied to the assembly line" under warranty as I won't allow them to touch the internal parts, what if the other one also makes noise?
So, what I am asking you is this: In the worst case scenario, if I finally consciously decide to live with this thingy as generic and not touch any aggregate even if it "misbehaves" to a tolerable extent, will the severity remain at current level or will it worsen as mileage builds up? What is your feedback on your Bullet as far as these specific issues are concerned? On a scale of 1 (worst) to 10 (excellent), how would you rate these specific issues on your Bullet 500? I request you to please revert.
The cheapest Harley Davidson costs double, also, I really don’t know how the flat belt that transmits the drive will actually behave in typical Indian conditions (with the dust and grime of the notorious Mumbai monsoons thrown in for good measure)!
Best regards,
Behram Dhabhar |