I replaced my 2007 Nissan quest with 2017 Acura MDX last year, Black interior and exterior. I didn't find any threads on MDX ownership so I am hoping I can provide some of the information. So far I have driven a little over 15K miles.
I had been driving Nissan quest minivan for 10 years which had started to show it's age. Here was my criteria for a replacement:
1. Comfortable seats - First and foremost, I am a thin man with no natural cushioning whatsoever on my back. and because of my low weight I barely make a dent in the seats. so not only the seat had to conform to my shape ( I can't stand lumbar support, I need it to be concave) but it also needed to be soft. most of the cars I test drove had seats that felt like a rock to me. Only Acura passed this. If I had bought another car, I would have had purchased a cushioned seat for myself.
2. AWD - Our driveway is at about 20 degrees incline, and getting a car up in snow has always been a challenge. Also we have hills in this area which I didn't feel comfortable driving in fresh snow.
3.Space - It had to provide space for our long trips, and possibly extra seats for guests if needed. so sedans were out for the most part.
4. driver assist technology - This was the reason I had been postponing the purchase because I wanted something close to an autonomous driving.
5. Misc - I was still open to other things like convertible, performance/prestige cars etc, but that will come at a cost of other factors mentioned above. In which case my wife's (upgrade to 2011 BMW 328i xdrive, from the VW beetle convertible she had been driving since 2010) would become our family car.
Decision 1: what car? here is a list I actually was maintaining while researching, each had at least something to contribute to my requirements above.
points to note:
- Honda civic is probably the most convenient option if you need driver assist technology
- infiniti is the best option if you need performance and driver assist
- Honda pilot has the same AWD as MDX. but once you add all the options, it's priced at the same level as MDX too.
Long story short, after considering all the variables, Acura MDX SH-AWD turned out to be the final winner. I ended up gong to Colombia Acura and their response was pretty good.
Compare that to almost any Honda dealer who do not even want to talk to you if the car you need is not in stock, which is almost always.
Decision 2: Lease or buy?
I ended up leasing the car because
1. I wanted the payments to be low.
2. I was sure either the effect of technologies will wear out and I will go back to old school (it didn't) or there will be something newer in 3 years I would want and will just return the MDX back to Acura at that point (yet to find out).
For anybody trying to make the decision, here are the key numbers to look at. these are not the exact numbers because of dealer confidentiality, but they are a good representative. The only discount I received was the SH-AWD for the FWD price, which was about $1,500 difference. The car was in high demand and didn't have many incentives at the time.
Car price: $43,000
Dealer premium for assuming the risk: $4,000
taxes, fees etc: $3,000
Total:$50,000
Estimates value of car after depreciation of three years: $29,000
i.e. Balance that I needed to pay: $21,000
Down payment: $3,000
monthly payment on the remaining 18,000 for 36 months ~ $500
In contrast, I would have paid upwards of 1,000 per month If I had financed it, even if spread across 4 years.
Here is a picture of the car while visiting our cabin, it was snowing. And it was clear no matter what kind of AWD you have, you till need control over your mind and hands to keep from drifiting into a ditch
The third screen you see at the bottom is a Garmin GPS I have kept next to the cupholder.
This was when we drove it in times square over the summer vacation.
And this is how the AWD system looks when driving.
Coming back to the car itself, I got the basic version, with SH-AWD (Acura's super handling all wheel drive).
Following are the specs that matter
- 3.5 L 290 HP NA engine
- Acura's SH-AWD system: it provides power to the wheels that need it in real time. I will post a video of it showing it on the dash. e.g., if you are turning left, you will see that the most power goes to the rear right wheel, providing steering torque. It also does something funky with braking the forward wheels while accelerating the rear, to grip the road in adverse conditions. I don't know if I will ever get ti experience it.
- 9 speed auto transmission
- button gears (push to engage park, drive and neutral, pull for reverse.there are individual buttons for each mode except sport, which engages with the drive mode. I have accidently put the car in sports mode many times by pressing drive twice inadvertently.
- 3 driving dynamics settings (comfort, normal, sport)
- pandora and aha connectivity for music
- multi functional display - the dash can toggle between remaining miles left in the fuel tank, tire pressure, fuel efficiency, oil health, SH-AWD power meter etc. I usually keep it blank to keep the dash clean.
- Auto high beam - the high beam automatically comes on if it's dark and there are no cars around. I find it to be less than intelligent and ended up turning it off quite a few times. On the other hand, I like this feature because it helps in keeping wild life away especially since so many deer collisions happen on highways.
- 7 seats
- MPG- I get an average of 18 MPG in mixed driving. on highways upto 25 MPG.
- base comes with Lane keeping assistant, collision mitigation system, adaptive cruise control, backup camera etc. The only safety option it is missing is blind spot warning that is included in higher variants. More on that below.
1. Lane keeping assist system (LKAS): When turned on, it reads the lane markings on the road and steers the wheel to keep you in lane. on moderate curves it keeps steering so you don't have to. While it does that, you can see the steering move and if you resist, it will let you steer the car. Also, if it detects no driver input for about 15 seconds, it flashes a warning on the dash saying "steering input needed" and disengages. This is a safety precaution from drivers giving up all control. Even when off, if the car goes outside visible lane markings, the steering starts shaking and corrects to some extent, avoiding unintentional off-roading.
2. Adaptive cruise control (ACC) with low speed follow: This is fairly common these days in cars. You set a speed for cruise control, the radar keeps watching the car in front and maintains a safe distance. if the car in front comes to a complete stops and starts within a second or two, it continues to follow. Any longer than that and it will need accelerator pedal pressed to start from standstill. However, I have found that the response is quite jerky at low speeds and I prefer to press brake (which disengages the ACC) and engage it again when I am at cruising speeds.
3. Automatic Brake hold: it needs to be activated every time the ignition is turned on, I wish It could be left on all the time. Then every time the car is stopped at a red light, the parking brakes are engaged so you don't have to keep pressing the brakes. once the accelerator is pressed, the brakes are released automatically. It's also avoid unintentional creeping of the vehicle.
4. Collision mitigation system: it keeps an eye on the front and when it detects a risk of collision, gives a beep and then applies a brake. I have not experienced the third stage yet (complete slamming of brakes
)
With 1 and 2 above engaged, I have found that my long drives (usually 10 hrs+) have become amazingly relaxing. My feet are completely off the brake and accelerator, and I lightly keep my hand on the steering (when I am driving on a long stretch of highway) and gently nudge the steering every 15 seconds to keep LKAS awake. I take the control back when I am in city limits with more traffic. Also, minor lapses in attention (say glancing sideways to check for traffic when changing lanes) are more forgiving in case the traffic ahead had come to a stop (has happened to me before) or the road turns. The car slows down as soon as it detects the car in front slowing down. I was afraid this will be one of those gimmicks that will wear out with time, but it has been an amazing help.
With number 3 above, the feet are again fairly relaxed in city conditions when stopped at lights.
As far the drive, it's luxurious as an Acura can expected to be. in fact, I test drove the TLX and MDX and didn't see much difference in drive dynamics, so opted for MDX for the extra space. But again, I am not a car connoisseur. The NVH level is pretty low, even in the sports mode.
So far I have driven 15,000 miles, my work commute is pretty short (about 2 miles each way), so most of these are our vacations to Florida, NY, Smoky mountains, Carolinas etc. And I found it fairly easy and intuitive. The visibility all around is excellent, I do use extra mirrors on the side mirrors for parking in addition to the rear view camera because of it's size, it has to fit correctly in parking spots with mot much space to play with. So far I have only serviced it cone based on oil health meter, another service should be due in another 2000 miles. No other expenses yet.
I read another thread on self driving cars and I think this is a fairly good compromise until a technology emerges which is safe enough for me to trust my life with it. Hoping in another 2 years something else comes up that makes me want to exchange it for newer technology .
In summary,things I like
1. The luxury of Acura, plush interiors, comfort controls, connectivity etc.
2. Space. even with the rear seats up it leaves a good amount of space for carrying stuff.
3. Driving experience. Responsive, accurate, and with SH-AWD it is a dream to drive.
4. technology. As mentioned above, it's the sole reason I bought the car and it totally met my expectations.
5. Safety. The safety options are top of the line.
Things that could improve, nothing really, but if I had to nitpick
1. the intelligent settings are not to intelligent. e.g. on the curves car doesn't take the steering into consideration and thinks I am going to slam into an obstacle straight ahead.
2. Ditto with auto high beam, continuous switching between high and low beam starts to bother you after a while.