Firstly Neville, let me welcome you to this forum. At least my post has bought you to become a member here.
We look forward to your future posts in which I hope you will share your vast experience and knowledge with us and hopefully solve any query, a member may have, which you might have know of.
Now coming to all this uncalled for commotion, let let me explain a few things.
Looking at your intercooler, it is obvious that it is a FMIC which is not stock, hence I deduced that you were running a bigger turbo. In fact in the post where you have clarified that part I have no reason to disbelieve you and I will take your word for it being the person you are and the reputation you enjoy, with me and im sure, with a lot of others on the forum. Only the tone needn't have been as it was...but thats in the past. So if you say you were not running a larger Turbo, so be it.(you will admit with the monster aftermarket FMIC and missing vent grille pods, it did look suspicious) I will very happily take my words and some of my disappointment in you back and will happily stand corrected.
Now even if you maintain that your intercooler is stock...im not in the habit to argue. For those who know cars (even those who are not as knowledgeable as you) a look is enough. I would like to draw your attention to my post below which I have reproduced
for your benefit only. Please read the highlighted, bold parts.
Quote:
Originally Posted by V-16 Yes a big congrats to all!!
Its a shame that a person of so much repute like Neville Poonawalla with so much going for his name and past super performances had to enter a "Souped up" RS for the speed run and run it in both classes, street stock [in which he got placed (shame-shame)] and the pro stock. I cant understand what the Autocar people were doing? Wasnt it just plain favoritism? How can your car run in both classes. Firstly it had a huge intercooler and a bigger turbo. What one will do to get a place and its a sheer in your face attitude. ''Im so and so and so im above the rules''. For me, he was an icon and ive lost respect for him after this antic!!
Sad Neville...very sad seeing you resort to such tactics.
And shame on you Autocar!! Shame-Shame!! See the huge intercooler!! By what stretch of imagination was this car entered in the street stock category? |
In my above post which has lead to a limited outcry, you will notice that I have never questioned your skills or abilities. I have maintained that I have admiration of your capabilities, which will remain, contrary to what you may feel.
Coming to your short outburst, I will, point by point, give answer to the best of my ability. Please note that I am in no way interested in any controversy that some
one may be trying try to create. I do not subscribe to this forum to argue or to get uncivil about anything that concerns this forum or most of its members. What I feel is true, I say...in a civil manner, hoping that reciprocation if any, should be handed over in the same tone. Not a lot to ask I feel.
Quote:
Originally Posted by neville1507 Dear friends,
The truth is out there in the form of supplementary regulations published in english by Autocar. |
You have
not posted the rules which say that cars participating in the pro stock class are not allowed to take part in the street stock category my friend. (Or was it vice versa...experts or those who have a copy of these rules kindly post to put an end to the controversy). I remember reading, discussing and clarifying this point at the Autocar office.
Quote:
Originally Posted by neville1507 Intelligent people should read them and maturely understand them. |
Exactly, so why didn't you read them Neville?? I guess you might have missed this one in small print.
Quote:
Originally Posted by neville1507 also i would seriously question your technical ability and understanding in automobiles to tell the difference between a standard and bigger turbo
Wish you all the best Mr. V-16. |
If you care to read my posts Neville, I have openly said it and will still maintain that your knowledge about cars in most fields is more than mine. No shame in admitting the truth is there? We all live and learn..
....But to cast aspirations on the ability of another, whoever he/she may be without even knowing the person is uncalled for and throughly disappointing, especially coming from you.
I guess partial wrong interpretation of my post had temporarily clouded your perception. I hope things are clearer now.
Quote:
Originally Posted by neville1507 if the intercooler is not part of the intake system of the engine - then which part is it of. frankly no one thought of or has thought of cooling the intercooler as i did to increase performance. also the coc did stop me and asked me to move it to the area outside the zapp pits... which i finally did move to .... also why is un-sporting of me to cool the intercooler ??. on the other hand, what if another competitor's engine had overheating problems ?? he would be using water to cool the radiator down and then run !!! its sad people find it un-sporting when they find someone doing something out of the ordinary. Give me a logical reason why i should not have cooled the intercooler. i can assure you next year everyone will be doing it. all competitors can do what they like as long as they are within the rules, to keep pushing the envelope...
cheers |
Sorry Neville, you are not the Pioneer in cooling your intercooler in this way. Last year Karan Shah of KS Motorsport was already using that technique which IMHO is quite ok but doing it in the line up area is not done buddy.
My only issue is that the RS should have run in any one class only as that was the rule. If it wasn't then i stand corrected again. Maybe you did not do it on purpose. What i am trying to say is that, it was the job of someone to point it out to you, and it wasn't done.
Coming to favoritism, lets not even get there because you know in your heart of heart whats true...as do all of us. I do not want to get in those issues. It was for you to ponder and us to see. It was discussed and not many person's are happy with it.
Its simple Neville, there were loopholes in the rules which many took advantage of. There are two faces to that coin;
In their books it might be intelligence....
....The way i look at it it is downright unsporting.
The following post does not even warrant an answer but as it is a singular post by supposedly, a "Fan" and although I am made out to be quite "Technically Challenged", I will try to reply, to the best of my so believed "Limited Abilities" for the first and the last time to this opinionated and judgmental gentleman.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Babin This message is in reply to V-16’s remarks on Neville Poonawala’s Skoda:
First and foremost, the learned person should comment only after reading the Supplementary Regulations (SR – which are authorized by both MAI and FMSCI) governing a particular event (Speed Run 2008in this case) in TOTO. |
May I recommend that you do the same kind sir??
Quote:
Originally Posted by Babin His comments also make me seriously doubt his technical understanding of cars in general (how does he assume that car is fitted with a bigger turbo) and motor sport as a whole. |
My learned friend,
if you spend half the time you have been spending scrutinizing my posts, on reading the rules of the forum, and then posting. you would be doing all of us a great favour.
Secondly
let this be the first and the last time you cast aspirations about the ability of any member of this forum, including mine. You do not know me and your revelation from your first post makes me want to keep it that way.
First introduce yourself in your debut post and then learn the ways of conducting yourself on this forum. That would teach you to
Please Refrain from future derogatory remarks about anybody.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Babin Autocar as an organization enjoys highest repute, does not distinguish or show favoritism to any, and hence has backing of companies like Bharat Petroleum. |
What else can I say??!!
Quote:
Originally Posted by Babin the event’s SR permitted the vehicle to run both in Street Stock and Pro Stock classes with the permitted modifications. |
Babin, read the rules please.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Babin The person himself has commented that Neville enjoyed huge respect in his eyes and should thus understand that Neville wouldn’t be so stupid to show off a large intercooler by removing the bumper grills if he had to hide something. |
"The Person" has himself said these words so needs no Reference To Context, my dear friend. I still respect Neville's abilities and nothing will change that. I do not know him personally, so do you see me commenting on his knowledge? IMHO you should follow this practice too.
...thats why one gets disappointed when he sees something that he does not expect from someone. Please read my post and if I may take the liberty to borrow a word from your post read it
"IN TOTO"
Also you have repeated exactly what Neville has said and clarified. I dont think a
repetitive, ECHO post does anything else, except adds to the confusion.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Babin And lastly but not the least, both Scrutinizers and Marshals of the event plus a dozen learned fellow competitors of Neville would have noticed any above board modifications and would have protested and/or disqualified Neville if something was found out of the order. |
I was not running for Neville to get disqualified, please get this straight.
If the scrutinizers and whoever would have done their jobs a lot of things would have worked well lets not get there.
In fact a protest was made if I remember right but if you care to read the previous posts then you will know the outcome of that protest too.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Babin V-16 should seriously rethink and post a public apology for making derogatory statements and maligning image of organizations like Autocar and a person like Neville Poonawala. |
You sound like a politician
I am not maligning anyone leave alone Neville.
I am man enough to admit when I go wrong and gracefully accept it.
In fact I feel you are Maligning me. Are you man enough to apologize to me? Seriously i am not even looking for any apology. I am entitled to My opinion as you are entitled to yours...only make sure its not personal.
Getting uncivil is very easy and two can play the game, some more adeptly than the other but some of us know how to tackle things more maturely.
Please not do not go advising people whom you do not know about the course of action to be taken, least of all Me.
If I do need your valuable advice, I will PM you but from what I can forsee, That not likely going to happen.
I feel I have clarified the whole issue which was misconstrued.
Neville, I hope you see things in a different light now.
Babin...remember to go through the forum rules!!