Quote:
Originally Posted by motorworks No offence to your views, but have we come to the point of comparing the compass to every car around? And especially the cheaper ones?
But now comparing it with the ecosport? I get the point that you own one, so comparisons are inevitable,
Just because FCA ain't in the best situation in India and they haven't disclosed the prices ( their mistake for sure) it doesn't mean that we start comparing apples to oranges. |
The first reason I compared them is because obviously it is a more objecctive way to judge a car. Just sitting in back and thinking how comfortable this is, doesn't give me much to measure. The most obvious thing would be to compare to a car I own.
2nd, The Ecosport is another crossover SUV, and if you take away the 4x4 system of the compass and consider than it weighs close to 1800Kgs, you wil notice that the Power to weight ratio of an EcoBoost ecosport is nearly identical to the Compass Petrol. That reflects in the 11-12 sec 0-100 time that Overdrive magazine recorded. And I know for a fact that Ecosport drives and handles great for an enthusiast. You can see where I'm going, even though they are different segments their USPs and customers that it appeals to the most are very similar.
If a car like compass which could very well cost double the ecosport and still have similar performance, features and only marginally more space. The only reason to go for it would be the better finish.
3rd: The comparison of doors was just about the doors. Just mentioned it because multiple reviews mention about how heavy they are. So checked it out, and tried to clear the air that they are not made of some Un-real Steel that no other car has. They feel only as good and heavy as some of the best built ones out there. Just trying to keep everyone's expectations to a real level unlike some exaggerated reviews.
Quote:
Originally Posted by CrAzY dRiVeR I don't think he is comparing to the Ecosport. Just that he is explaining his POV as an Ecosport owner looking at an upgrade. Which is fine IMO.
If I were to go to a showroom as well, I'll check each car and think what the new car will be providing in addition to the existing car and at what additional price. Not fully in terms of features - but engine, build, safety, quality etc. |
Yes, Exactly what I was thinking. The only real benefits that I could check at this point are
-More active safety features (DTC, ESP etc.)
-A more plush and better built cabin
-Bigger boot(but not a lot)
I hope the drive is much better because they need to deliver something great in order to make this segment move. Remember the D1 segment sedans in India? Its shrunk to tiny levels now thanks to Cars from the C segment like the City, Ciaz which are so grown up that nobody really wants to pay 50% more for only a marginally better car. XUV has its looks/presence and 7 seats so it stays appealing to many indians. The compass has none of those so it needs the driving dynamics.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Behemoth Well guys it is natural to compare any car with the existing car that one has! The Jeep Compass's strength is not really supposed to be its interior space but the ride quality and the driving dynamics. Both of these have been highly appreciated by most reviewers. Inside space is not really a criteria on the basis of which expensive / premium cars can be judged as most of them would fail miserably.
Jeep is trying to fill this void and provide a car which offers driver excitement and also is of a higher quality than Hyundai. I know people will want everything at the same price as the Creta, but that will not be viable for Jeep and they will try to price it realistically. Given the recent GST reduction, I do hope that they are able to pitch the top diesel variant sub 20 and the base variant starting at 14.5 lacs. This should be the pricing sweet spot for them and they would be able to get the 2500 monthly sale that they are aiming for. Anything higher will be a challenge and lower may not generate enough profit for them.
However the challenge for Jeep in India is not the price, but the network and service which they really need to focus on to woo customers. The initial experience of Compass owners will really drive the success or failure of the Compass in India. |
well put, but I think anybody going for the Compass needs to be aware that size wise it is definitely half a size less than the Tucson, even though in other aspects it would be much more appealing to us enthusiasts. But I can't comment on it right now, No TDs
Quote:
Originally Posted by ToyotaFan Just curious where did you check out the compass near Mamc I thought the nearest dealer is at mathura road only. Wanted to know since am frequenting ito these days (thameem). Coming to the Jeep compass how did you find the space in the back and the front. Is it significantly more than the ecosport. Considering the estimated on road price would be twice the ecosport I expect it to have a spacious cabin. The engines and the specs look all good it's just the pricing that will make or break the product. Jeep should keep the base model price to below 15L to make this product an instant hit. Let's hope it establishes FCA back in india. |
Checked it out at Landmark Fiat/Jeep in Moti Nagar. Had gone to get some work done on the Spark. So killed time in various dealers there. The legroom at the back is about 20-30 pc more than Ecosport. You could touch legs easily at the back of the seat if there is a tall guy upfront in a laidback position.
For another objective comparison between totally unrelated Segments BTW (Don't hate me for this).
Rear Legroom : BMW X1>>LR Disco Sport >Compass=Evoque> Ecosport
I was surprised with the X1 but weirdly enough it has more space in the rear. And another thing I would emphasise is the LR cars had a pano roof so the feeling of space was more than the Compass. They've tried to help by using a super light shade for interiors but I think a Pano Roof would be a masterstroke(Consider that no other SUV under the 30 Lac Tiguan or Audi Q3 comes with a Pano roof, and for the indian market it could be a great marketing tool as well