Quote:
Originally Posted by adimicra You are wrong.
The I20 petrol is priced slightly higher than Xcent (comparing the base models).
Hyundai i20 Era 1.2 - 4.81 Lakhs
Hyundai Xcent Base 1.2 - 4.66 lakhs
The I20 diesel is priced significantly higher than Xcent diesel.
Hyundai Xcent Base 1.1 CRDi - 5.57 lakhs
Hyundai i20 Era 1.4 CRDI -5.95 Lakhs
-------------------------
|
Well I am not wrong cause unlike you I was not comparing the base models. I was looking at the top end trims cause manufacturers are known to strip the low end trims just to market lower starting price. Not knowing exact features difference between the Xcent and i20 base model I took prices of the top end Xcent SX(O) and i20 Asta. Both with similar safety features as well as gadgets as an equal comparo. So neither are you wrong or myself.
Petrol:
Hyundai Xcent 1.2 SX(O) - 6.5L (ex-showroom Delhi)
Hyundai i20 1.2 Asta - 6.31L (I am considering Asta and not Asta (O) as Asta (O) is with side/curtain airbags as well as sunroof which is not there in Xcent)
Diesel:
Hyundai Xcent 1.0 CRDI - 7.41L
Hyundai i20 1.4CRDI Asta - 7.52L
In the diesel I agree there is 11K difference but that's cause engines are different and just 11K for one extra cylinder and 6 speed gearbox plus more features is nowhere considered premium.
Quote:
Now, the Xcent still has advantage of have a much larger boot than I20.
The Amaze does not have that advantage over the Jazz..boot space is similar and the Jazz offers more flexibility.
|
If it was down to boot space alone, then the Dzire and Swift would have seen lowest sales.
Quote:
Also, the difference in quality between Jazz and Amaze is more than the difference in quality between I20 and Xcent (my opinion, subjective).
|
I agree it's subjective but the difference is i20 is much better than Xcent whereas the Amaze is very poor well below the Xcent. The Jazz going by what we saw in the Auto expo and the new City will be just about acceptable. Too much cost cutting. The older Jazz has better interiors than what we saw in Auto Expo and that was imported model. Expect cost cutting in India which means better than Amaze for sure but not premium stuff for sure.
Quote:
So, as I said, the difference of 40-50K over Amaze is justified
The earlier Jazz was priced way way higher than the competition...Honda is not gonna do that this time. I believe the pricing will be quite close to I20, albeit slightly higer.Also, the earlier Jazz din't have any base version so to say which made it appear more costly. This time Honda is gonna have several versions including the bare bones base trims to lure more people.
|
If they do put the 1.5 petrol the 40-50K is justified else it will tough as buyers will either go to Amaze or upgrade to a city.
Take a look at the pricing between Amaze and City.
Honda Amaze 1.2P VX-Mt - 6.64L
Honda City 1.5P E MT - 7.19L
The difference is 55K between a top end Amaze and base model City. The base E City gets single airbag as well as ABS.
Now as per your logic, you think it's ok for Honda to charge 40-50K over Amaze which basically means price the top spec Jazz on par with the base model City and with the 1.2L petrol engine.
Now lets see the diesel.
Honda Amaze 1.5D VX-MT - 7.49L
Honda City 1.5D E MT - 8.37L
Here the difference is 88K and a difference of 40K could work but hopefully Honda puts the 6 speed gearbox from the city and not the 5 speed from Amaze. The 6 speed was there in the Auto expo so the chances are higher.
Now remember in all this the Mobilio is expected this month and is supposed to be priced between the Amaze and City.
Quote:
Some cars are not meant to be chart-toppers and Jazz is one of them, at least for the India market.
|
You can call them niche but they are usually known as flop models. If the car is not selling in numbers then the manufacturer is not doing the customer a favour by telling him pay more cause the car is niche and premium.
There were several people who thought that and bought the Jazz initially at the premium pricing. Once sales started to dwindle and Honda realised they had realised they had bitten off more than they could chew they got a facelift variant with substantially reduced pricing. By then it was classified as a flop model and no price reduction could save it.