I have been looking for a thread on "How OTR Price is Arrived at" by dealers.
Couldn't find any such information, so thought of posting it here. While there is a lot of discussion on inter-state tax, I couldn't find anything specific on OTR calculation.
I am currently researching on purchasing a new car and I was surprised to find a few things, these at present maybe specific to Maharashtra (taxes)
How is the On Road Price arrived at by the dealer
Ans. Usually when we go to any dealer for a car, they have a printed paper, which gives us the "break-up" leading to the On Road Price
Ex- Showroom Cost + Tax & Registration + Insurance + Handling Charges + LBT = On Road Price Ex- Showroom - Varies from State to State as depending upon existing laws and taxes
Insurance - Best to purchase from outside, unless you're getting a good deal
Handling Charges - Dealers charge this amount, check if you can negotiate
Local Body Tax - After octroi, this is a new thing applicable for people who reside within Octroi limits, 2% for Vehicles below 10lacs
Tax & Registration - What percentage of the ex-showroom is applicable for payment of One time tax for vehicle purchasers. Previously I had never given a thought to this calculation, believing the dealer and the cost break-up shown therein.
This time I was checking the applicable taxes, as per the Pune RTO website, tax applicability is 7% (One time tax) for Motor Cars / Jeep & Omni Buses.
Pasting an excerpt from the site (
http://www.rtopune.info/taxation.htm) :
A) Individual Owner 7 % of the cost of vehicle (Cost of vehicle = Cost of vehicle + Central Excise + Sales Tax)
B) Imported/ Company Owner 14 % of the cost of vehicle
This does not specify the type of fuel, though I would still go by the legal rule, that unless specified otherwise, the same rate would apply. Also, from the fact that they mention 'Jeeps/Omnibuses' which are Diesel vehicles.
Now, with this information, I checked with a couple of Dealers (Ford & Mahindra) and asked them to give me the On Road Price for Figo & Bolero.
Lets look at both;
1. Figo - Registration @ 11%, No Local Body Tax
and in the small print written at the bottom, they mention that Registration & Taxes also include some 'Other' charges which may be applicable.
When I asked how were they calculating the Tax @ 11% when the mandate was 7%, he first didn't have any answer, then after a while he said that 7% was applicable for Petrol Vehicles and 11% for Diesel Vehicles.
What I feel :
If it was indeed 11% just for One Time Tax then the calculation should have been
One Time Tax (11%) + Registration Fees (500-600) + 'Other Charges
Whereas, the sum quoted including the above totalled to 11% of the ex-showroom cost.
Obviously, the dealer won't be paying from his pocket for my registration/other charges
2. Bolero - Registration @ 11% + Local Body Tax @ 4%
and in the small print written at the bottom, they mention that Registration & Taxes also include some 'Other' charges which may be applicable.
Upon pointing that Local Body Tax if applicable should be charged at 2% for private vehicles under Rs. 10 Lacs he did not have a clear answer again.
Regards to Registration again there was no clear response, I have been asked to drop in a mail to him and he said he would need to check with his manager on my queries and then revert.
Now after visiting these 2 dealerships quiet a few things come out
1. Why the difference in approach regards to Local Body Tax?
2. What are the 'Other Charges' at the time of registration and how much do they amount to?
3. If One Time Tax itself is to be charged @11%, then how come the total of registration and tax comes to 11% and not higher
4. What is the actual %age of one time tax applicable in Maharashtra for Private Vehicles?
5. Sites referred:
http://www.mahatranscom.in/tax_calculation.aspx
http://www.rtopune.info/taxation.htm
Both the above sites calculate the one time tax at 7%, are both the sites giving incorrect information?
I know maybe visiting the RTO would shed some more light, but I would want to rely on something documented rather than some verbal information. Is there something available which can be referred to?
And lastly, the questions which I have raised do you find them valid? Or am I just getting overly inquisitive?
Would appreciate inputs and clarifications, I will also paste in the reply from the Mahindra dealership.