I did all these research when I was trying to upgrade from my "never say die" yashica analogue P&S camera to a practical and usable Digicam (min 5MP). Here are my findings after endless hours of research across different message boards, review sites (dcresource, dprevoew, steves-digicam included). Costs are as of Feb first week in US, after that I bought my camera.. so don't know the latest price. I also didn't care about video.. because video is best shot in miniDV camcorder which I am already having.
- Canon A610 5MP: swivel lcd, manual control which gives it almost SLR like control without the SLR lens. Of course it has all the accessories to fit in telephoto, wide lens, water protect frame etc. Must for anyone who is short in budget for a D-SLR, However, it's bulky as hell so it was out of my list. Cost approx $255
- Fuji Finepix F10: 6MP, Night performance better than even some well known D-SLRs. All the review sites top choice, lot of manual controls with AF assist lamp. Can shoot till ISO800. I almost bought it. But it uses xD card, which is not compatible with my media card reader in my laptop. So dropped the idea. Cost approx - $250
- Canon SD400/450/500 (aka IXUS series in Asia and Europe): Good overall camera. However a bit pricey, and has problems withred eye (it sure has) and you need some post processing with the software to remove the annoying red eye. Has some manual control with AF assist lamp. Cost $250-$350
- Nikon Coolpix S1: Tinniest camera with budget $199. However, it has problems with processing speed which is a little slow. Othrwise.. it's a good credit card sized camera. Almost none manual control, no AF assist lamp but has D-lighting feature.
- Sony cybershot S600: Incredibly cheap with good performance. It was $175 with 6MP and basic manual controls. But wait a min.. this will just floor you.. it has a 36ft of flash range.. (all the above cameras have a max flash range of 10-12ft) very very powerful flash.. so good for night time wild life photography. In fact I went to wild life photography site to get the word from the horses mouth. However to support the cheap cost the LCD is not great. And it's a bit bulky in my taste. So didn't go for it. It's also introduced in Jan 2006... And did I say that it can take pictures at ISO1000? Still would like to have one for those shos at pitch black night.
- Kodak Easyshare v530/v550: Good camera with a very good LCD and look (metallic black.. change from the usual boring silver tone). Also very compact and has decent performance. Also has the AF Assist lamp and some manual control. I got the v530 for $225 plus NYC tax from J&R. I dropped it in the hard floor once. It survived ecause of the solid metallic body.
I went for this. See my BHP garage for some samples. I will post some good pictures. Here is one on a cloudy day:
http://s42.photobucket.com/albums/e3...t=100_0017.jpg
If you are okay with xD card, I would suggest to go for the Fuji Finepix F10