|
Search Forums |
Advanced Search |
Go to Page... |
![]() |
Search this Thread | ![]() 38,867 views |
![]() | #31 |
Senior - BHPian ![]() Join Date: Sep 2012 Location: Pune
Posts: 1,186
Thanked: 4,625 Times
| Re: Hidden costs of owning an EV From a savings perspective, I think EVs do make much sense over fuel guzzling, expensive to maintain ICE cars. But I still feel ICE cars come with one big advantage that EVs don't have yet. You can refuel them quickly and be back on road. This can sometimes trump all other cost savings one can make. Case in point: back in 2022 I did a trip to the US and I went camping to a remote place with my friend and his family. The car was a Tesla Model 3. Once we reached home, the car had a charge of 7% left. We did not stop on our way back to 'super'charge the car as our kids were getting frustrated and throwing tantrums. Few minutes after we reached home, we had to go to the doctor urgently as one of the kids started feeling seriously sick, but the charge in Tesla was not enough to go to the city and considering how remotely located homes are in the U.S., an Uber was not getting confirmed for almost 30 minutes (also a Sunday evening). As expected, we got a friend to take us to the doctors in his petrol car. I consider this careful and sometimes meticulous planning needed for EVs to be 'available' at all times as one critical 'hidden cost'. A survey should be taken where we ask how many owners have only one EV in their garage, and what is their frequency of using other vehicles (Taxi's, friend's/relative's/rented ICE cars) and the purpose (city commute or go anywhere long distance, unplanned). This should give us a picture of whether EVs can become mainstream. |
![]() | ![]() |
The following 9 BHPians Thank NiInJa for this useful post: | carnutfrombanga, d_himan, FlankerFury, InControl, lifeinpune, roy_libran, Sharanam, TheCamShaft, voldemort |
|
![]() | #32 | |
BHPian ![]() Join Date: Feb 2022 Location: Bangalore
Posts: 29
Thanked: 133 Times
| Re: Hidden costs of owning an EV Quote:
Personally I feel 100% BEV does not work for someone with a single car garage and is not the future as none of the countries produce enough electricity or have the infrastructure nor will ever invest in the infrastructure to support all BEV. The global Auto industry also has recognised this and most including Toyota, GM, BMW, Ford are pausing their BEV investments and in the long run I feel something like Hybrid could be the answer. | |
![]() | ![]() |
The following BHPian Thanks SolitaryRabbit for this useful post: | Ray379 |
![]() | #33 |
Newbie Join Date: Sep 2024 Location: Kolkata
Posts: 8
Thanked: 22 Times
| Re: Hidden costs of owning an EV Having owned an EV as primary car (for city rides) and a diesel secondary car (for additional city duties / highway drives), I can vouch for the main hidden cost for EVs - PLANNING. All your EV trips need to be pre-planned meticulously factoring in range, charging capabilities (or lack of it on road) and minimize impulse drives. Over my ~10k EV drive in the last 8 months - I only charged it at home. Slow home charging does not deteriorate the battery (not that I have observed) and gives you the cost benefit for opting for EV in the first place. Last edited by Axe77 : 11th March 2025 at 19:02. Reason: u —> you. No SMS lingo please. Thank you. |
![]() | ![]() |
The following 4 BHPians Thank Drive.Thru.KKS for this useful post: | androdev, arvindmanju, FlankerFury, voldemort |
![]() | #34 | |||
BHPian Join Date: Feb 2019 Location: Kochi
Posts: 231
Thanked: 676 Times
| Re: Hidden costs of owning an EV Quote:
Tyres in cars are getting bigger and bigger regardless of the powertrain. That’s not an EV specific drawback. As an aside – this is a separate matter – I don’t understand why anybody thinks bigger tyres are a good idea, because it results in a worse ride and higher chance of tyre or wheel damage. Brakes are supposed to last much longer in an EV because of regenerative braking. Quote:
Quote:
Heck, when going on a trip in my Taigun I get annoyed for having to figure out ahead of time where to get XP95, even though in the worst case I can just fill in regular petrol ![]() | |||
![]() | ![]() |
The following 3 BHPians Thank voldemort for this useful post: | carnutfrombanga, Drive.Thru.KKS, InControl |
![]() | #35 |
BHPian Join Date: Jan 2023 Location: Palakkad (KL09)
Posts: 745
Thanked: 2,297 Times
| Re: Hidden costs of owning an EV People who are going for a new ICE instead of new EV just because of resale value fears should consider the following point 1. One should agree at least that the current crop of EVs are technologically at par with ICEs. I would say they are much much better in all aspects except may be the planning aspect but let us not argue the point here 2. If future EV tech is going to make current EVs obsolete and thereby crashing its resale value, what do you think it is going to do to the current ICE cars resale value ? EVs price is currently almost at par with equally spec-ed ICE car. Unless you have a very special situation, I do not see much sense in buying an ICE car currently. Certainly not if you are in the southern part of India where even public charging infrastructure is quite good. |
![]() | ![]() |
The following 9 BHPians Thank electric_eel for this useful post: | anandhsub, anb, avchrono, darkgamer, Raskolnikov.R, Ray379, shankar.balan, Sharanam, Shresth_EV |
![]() | #36 | |
Newbie Join Date: Sep 2024 Location: Kolkata
Posts: 8
Thanked: 22 Times
| Re: Hidden costs of owning an EV Quote:
![]() The additional mental capacity used in PLANNING for EV drives are more than compensated by the ease of driving, lack of NVH and in general the easiness of driving an EV (more so in case of choc-a-block city traffic which is ubiquitous in all cities in India). IMHO, this is the single biggest ROI for driving an EV, over and above the Green tag. ![]() Last edited by Eddy : 11th March 2025 at 20:57. Reason: Fixed quotes | |
![]() | ![]() |
The following 2 BHPians Thank Drive.Thru.KKS for this useful post: | shankar.balan, voldemort |
![]() | #37 | |
BANNED Join Date: Apr 2008 Location: Bangalore
Posts: 11,797
Thanked: 27,222 Times
Infractions: 0/3 (13) | Re: Hidden costs of owning an EV Quote:
Do be assured that I have no intention of arguing with you or anyone else on the relative merits of both cars. All I was doing is to share the real cost based on my experience. Of course, anyone here is welcome to make whatever surmise they want to. My only intent was to provide information. I chose whichever car I chose and paid for the same. Not sure that anyone else can be the judge of whether the car I chose suits my use case or not. Actually if you’ve observed various threads, I do love Jeepy things and do also own one in the form of a Jimny. So I’ll let that rest. Of course, if it is deemed inappropriate, the Mods are welcome to scissor my posts! Last edited by shankar.balan : 11th March 2025 at 21:08. | |
![]() | ![]() |
The following 4 BHPians Thank shankar.balan for this useful post: | ComicCharcoal, Livnletcarsliv, sri_tesla, suhaas307 |
![]() | #38 |
Senior - BHPian ![]() | Re: Hidden costs of owning an EV I own the 2023 Tesla Model 3 Performance for 2.5 years now and clocked 29,000 miles (~ 48,000kms). In this period, my costs have been negligible to non-existent compared to the savings that I was able to get out of this ownership and not to mention the super fun of driving a Tesla. 1. Gas savings are literally 90% of a gas car. 2. Tires supposed get eaten up faster but, then if you drag race signal to signal like I do. They won't last. I changed my first set at 25,000 miles ( 40,000kms). you figure it out if it's less or more mileage for a single set of tires. 3. Insurance is higher for EV's. It's about $100 more than a gas car per month. 4. Spent $0 in maintenance till now. In fact, never visited a Tesla center till date. 5. I bought a home with a EV charger set up already pre-installed so no costs there as well. 6. In last 2.5 years, I may have charged < 10 times at Tesla Superchargers but, even their cost is not too high compared to a gas car. I pay $0.10kwh at home and $0.30kwh at Tesla superchargers. What is really bothering me now is the antics of Elon Musk after Trump became the president. He is focusing more on politics vs. growing Tesla. Growing resentment with his behavior and people getting angry with someone who is driving a Tesla is becoming mainstream (I had an incident on last Sunday when 2 Americans in Dodge truck were tailgating me/kept changing lanes and sticking their neck-out and screaming at me, I could not hear what as we both were around 80mph but, from their gestures and facial expressions they didn't look too happy.- For no reason apparently. ![]() All this stupid behavior is impacting the resale of the Tesla and it is tanking rapidly. Long story short, My experience with Tesla as a EV product has been nothing short of a beautiful dream from an ownership experience perspective. My 2 cents from US of A. ![]() |
![]() | ![]() |
The following 8 BHPians Thank mobike008 for this useful post: | anb, androdev, avisidhu, FlankerFury, Hayek, Mur7!r3ddy, shankar.balan, voldemort |
![]() | #39 | |||
BHPian | Re: Hidden costs of owning an EV Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
I don't at all think the price difference is so low between comparable cars. The highest specced ICE car in a segment vs a really basic EV in the same segment would still have a bigger price difference. Last edited by supermax : 12th March 2025 at 01:07. | |||
![]() | ![]() |
The following 2 BHPians Thank supermax for this useful post: | FlankerFury, shankar.balan |
![]() | #40 |
BHPian Join Date: Feb 2025 Location: Ernakulam
Posts: 35
Thanked: 250 Times
| Re: Hidden costs of owning an EV As a seasoned EV owner (almost 100k KM driven) and user of 4 electric cars( Nexon Ev, EV Max, and now Creta EV and Comet) let me clarify on some points discussed here. My house is not 3 phase, but we do have solar. I have always used 15 A charger to charge all of my cars. We never plug in car at 0%. The battery is topped up occasionally as needed in day time. If I have a long trip coming, my Nexons used to charge full overnight ( if I plug in around 4 PM). It is not possible in Creta and I charge it in 2 days, as it takes more than 18 hours to charge from 20 to 100. The cars need to be charged from 20-100% once every month to avoid BMS corruption( which was in the case of Nexon EVs). Never pay additional price for the charger- Most of the chargers bundled by manufacturers are from third party players and rebranded with MG/Tata/ Hyundai logo. You can easily get same brand chargers for half the price in Amazon or manufacturers. Make sure to not to go cheap on wiring. New earthing and MCB and voltage cut offs are must or your charger will go bust. This is actually done free by Tata. EV tyres can wear down fast, so make sure you get tyres with unconditional warranties. I changed both my Nexon tyres to Conti UC6 from MRF stock ones, both were going strong when I sold them 40k km later. Creta came with good tyres (Goodyear) and I am keeping it. The resale value of cars is going to be bad- Especially in case of Tata cars. You won't be able to sell the cars in a day, but in case of Kerala, you will come across genuine buyers once a while. My original Nexon was sold for 14.5 lakhs in 2022 (38k driven and 1.5 years old). There were not a lot of second hand electric cars in market and i got a decent price back then. I struggled to sell my Nexon max this year and was sold for 11.50 lakhs (50k driven). Last edited by graaja : 12th March 2025 at 06:23. Reason: Capitalizing I's and car names etc. |
![]() | ![]() |
The following 8 BHPians Thank axm0316 for this useful post: | atin001, DigitalOne, myavu, narayans80, Raskolnikov.R, shankar.balan, varkey, VWAllstar |
![]() | #41 |
Senior - BHPian ![]() Join Date: Aug 2011 Location: Pune
Posts: 1,187
Thanked: 5,465 Times
| Re: Hidden costs of owning an EV People contesting the resale value point, picture this. You can buy a 15 lakh Nexon.EV Creative 45 and a 14.7 lakh Nexon Creative Petrol DCT and a 16 lakh Nexon Creative Diesel AMT. Use all 3 for 15 years in Delhi. (Well the diesel can be used only 10 years so you have to buy another one 10 yrs later). Mumbai is also contemplating doing something similar. Nobody has seen the future so who is to say that this greedy government will not implement this in most tier 1/2 cities? Where will the resale buyers for your ICE cars come from 10/15 years later? Coming back to the cars, all 3 are the same trim and roughly the same cost and ATs. Which one do you think will have the highest resale? Diesel is losing this one badly, Petrol is now down to Zero too. EV, even if the battery capacity is now down to 25-30, it will hold *some* value. So I would say, if you want your car to hold the best value, buy a used EV over practically anything else. The car will run practically for free and you would have recieved the benefit of high depreciation when buying. There is a hidden cost though. That is in long distance drives. We are planning a trip to Jaisalmer in a couple of weeks and we are on the fence on whether to take my 5.5 yr old Figo Diesel or my brother's brand new XUV400. The thing with that part of the country is that there are very very few chargers along the way. We had to replan the entire thing and approach Jaisalmer through a route that is almost 200km longer. We have to go there via Udaipur instead of the shorter route via Palanpur-Barmer. It seems there is not a single functional DC charger between Palanpur, Gujarat and Jaisalmer, Rajasthan. A distance of almost 400km! I wouldn't trust even a 50 kWh ZS EV to be able to do this journey. 200 extra km on a short range EV like an XUV400 is an extra 40-50 minute charging stop and 4 hours of driving. These 5 extra hours could potentially add an entire driving day to the travel time compared to what the Figo (which can do higher avg speeds on open roads since there is no reason to hypermile) would have taken (about < 1.5 driving days to travel 1000km from Nashik to Jaisalmer). Such a scenario would never have occurred in an ICE car and given a choice, it would have been a no brainer for the newer, safer, faster, larger car with the higher ground clearance and better suspension be preferred for such a trip. Assuming the electricity cost when using DC fast charging will be around 3-4/km compared to Diesel cost of 5/km a 2500km round trip (including sightseeing) on the Figo will cost about 12.5k with no charger anxieties. Compared to this, the XUV's trip will be almost 3000km due to charger related detours which at 3.5/km will be almost 10.5k. That is not life changing amount of money saved. Any savings there would be spent on extra days in a hotel. Add to that the time value of the extra days lost to traveling. Had the trip been to something more densely populated like Goa or Konkan or even Kerala, the EV would have managed fine without taking too many detours. But if we are going into less population density areas, or the mountains, the planning hassles outweigh cost savings, at least for the shorter range EVs. Planning hassles reduce as battery capacity increases. Till 60-70-80 kWh EVs become even more mainstream at mass market price levels, these hassles will continue. When such EVs are available at 15-20 lakh, they will be more ubiquitous and then maybe the PSU OMCs will find value in keeping their chargers, that already exist, in working order. |
![]() | ![]() |
The following 4 BHPians Thank antz.bin for this useful post: | itwasntme, narayans80, Red Liner, Sharanam |
|
![]() | #42 | |||||||||
BANNED Join Date: Apr 2008 Location: Bangalore
Posts: 11,797
Thanked: 27,222 Times
Infractions: 0/3 (13) | Re: Hidden costs of owning an EV Quote:
Urban dwellers and those who remain mostly on the beaten tracks will definitely benefit from EVs. Quote:
It is true that brakes seem to last much longer in EV’s. At my recent servicing experience, the Advaith Hyundai Senior Service Advisor told me that in the last few years he has seen Kona’s come in with very high mileage, in excess of 60-70K Kms and their brake discs and pads apparently were in excellent shape and did not need to be changed. I think the subtle irritant of range anxiety is largely a thing of the past, at least in Southern India. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
In reference to price differences between EVs and ICE cars, at least in India, they seem to be more or less comparable and are becoming more so with the advent of the mainstream manufacturers mass segment EVs. Quote:
In my case Hyundai gave me the 7.2KWH charger free with the Kona. There is no line item in the invoice for that. The Goodyear tyres in the Creta EV are interesting. I like their pattern and the tall and fat cushiony looking sidewalls. I wonder if I can find them in the right size for the Kona whenever Im up for change. I think it is just sensible to not keep worrying about resale value when one is buying a car. Buy it and use it well. Look after it well. And keep it for longer, thus extracting maximum value from the purchase. Here’s to an Electrifying Drive/ Ride to all those who are on the fence as regards EV’s. Speaking as one who is a relatively recent entrant to the EV world and loving every minute of it! Drive it for its utility value as well as for the sheer joy of driving, acceleration, silence, efficiency, comfort and exhilarating performance. Its certainly worth it (in my estimation as an urban dweller) from the points of view of both common sense and fun factor. Last edited by shankar.balan : 12th March 2025 at 09:02. Reason: Pic | |||||||||
![]() | ![]() |
The following 5 BHPians Thank shankar.balan for this useful post: | ADI7YAK, anb, Drive.Thru.KKS, NiInJa, voldemort |
![]() | #43 |
Distinguished - BHPian ![]() ![]() | Re: Hidden costs of owning an EV One more 'cost' (if I may classify it in that manner) is the sudden price cuts on EVs during this transitionary period where taxation, import duties, trade agreements etc. are wildly changing. Trump has not helped with his game-changing demands either. For example, the 2025 BYD Seal RWD/AWD has been introduced in Australia with desirable feature upgrades BUT at a lower cost: https://www.drive.com.au/news/byd-au...-2025-updates/ These upgrades should probably have been there from day one. Personally, I'd feel short-changed to have bought a Seal AWD with the older FSD dampers or the RWD with the bog standard ones. This is probably why the Seal's India pricing will be announced in April. I suspect they will be slashed to reflect various efficiencies, and to prepare for the Tesla CBUs. As a fence-sitter as of now, I am hoping the EV landscape will settle in the next few months. Hybrids are also making a comeback globally, and that may well be the logical step for me at least. Last edited by itwasntme : 12th March 2025 at 09:05. |
![]() | ![]() |
![]() | #44 | |
BHPian Join Date: Feb 2021 Location: TN66/TN14
Posts: 940
Thanked: 2,303 Times
| Re: Hidden costs of owning an EV Quote:
The topic of this post says "Hidden Costs of an EV". So even if an EV is compared to an ICE, shouldn't it be an apple to apple comparison, especially the use case to compare the costs? Obviously, an off-road focused lifestyle vehicle like Thar/Jimny will be expensive than a common man's EV (ZS, Kona, Nexon, etc) which doesn't give the reality in terms of cost of owning both. It's like comparing Nexon EV vs Force Gurkha 4*4 (or) Ioniq 5 vs Fortuner 4*4. How can we arrive at the right value proposition, especially in terms of cost, when both cars have different use cases? | |
![]() | ![]() |
![]() | #45 | |
BANNED Join Date: Apr 2008 Location: Bangalore
Posts: 11,797
Thanked: 27,222 Times
Infractions: 0/3 (13) | Re: Hidden costs of owning an EV Quote:
There is no hard and fast rule/ decree that one can make comparisons only based on the specific Use-Case applicable to any of the vehicles being compared. For example my Jimny (whose use case is mainly leisure loafing, highways and a bit of off-road trail use) costs me 4000Rs a month on fuel to run 500 kms average. And my Mini Cooper S (whose use case is specific but closer to that of my Kona - meaning highways and road trips), costs me another 3500 Rs a month on fuel to run 350kms average. Whereas my Kona would probably cost 800 Rupees to run 500 kms and maybe 550 Rupees to run 350kms. Whichever angle that I look at it from, it is clearly cheaper to own and run my Kona day to day. And this would apply in general, when comparing ICE vs EV especially if the acquisition cost of the EV and the ICE vehicle are the same. The simple common sense thing for most normal users would be to go EV. And this seems to be reflected in the increased adoption that we are seeing around us. It is only going to become more and more evident as the mainstream manufacturers like Maruti and Hyundai come up with their mainstream EVs and as BYD and MG continue to expand their offerings along with the increasing price parity between the EV’s and ICE cars. | |
![]() | ![]() |
The following 2 BHPians Thank shankar.balan for this useful post: | anb, Livnletcarsliv |
![]() |