Re: Mercedes-Benz EQB facelift launched at Rs 70.90 lakh Quote:
Originally Posted by sudiptaadhya Isn't it unreasonable to expect car prices to stay flat from 2017 to 2024?
1) You could do that by building tin cans within thinner sheet metal every year but the Germans will do that. The Germans don't care about volumes as much as about quality and technology. The consumers need to pay to fund the R&D - and that bill gets bigger every year
2) We expect our salary to go up 10% every year, right? Since 2017, the INR has lost 30% of its value (vs USD / EUR) and add to it a 20% inflation, and the price of the E200 seems pretty reasonable, no?
3) Lastly, Mercedes and BMW are niche cars, with a niche but steadily expanding customer base, and have a certain aspirational value. There will always be competition, but the equation of BYD / [any other name] vs Mercedes works very differently than Maruti vs Kia - it will never be material enough to force cost cuts
4) Lastly, I would any day prefer to buy a Mercedes where the resale value is great (as the sale price consistently increases every few months) rather than a Maruti or Tesla where the car prices get cut unpredictably |
You bring up good points. My POV is:
The increase in prices seems too much. Typically, if a product is in production for 10 years, some input/manufacturing costs will reduce (tech gets older, components become older and cheaper etc), and on the contrary inflation will drive up some costs. For eg, when you see any device/gadget on sale for many years , prices generally stay flat/or marginally change over time. I believe Mercedes is being opportunistic in raising prices by 60% for the same E class over 7 years.
(1) I personally would not put German "quality" on a pedestal vis a vis "tin cans" from other manufacturers. We have an E class LWB that is a garage queen, because it keeps throwing up issues. We have spent several lakhs in maintenance over 5k km. Our Skoda Superb has chewed through several DSGs and a range of other components in 50k km. I personally find these cars painful, and uncomfortable to own, over the long term.
(3) You hit the nail on the head. The aspirational value of Merc makes it sell at even the current prices. In effect, the brand was underpriced in the 2010s (in hindsight) and the last two CEOs of Mercedes India are simply taking up prices to squeeze the max out of the golden goose.
(4) I hold a different POV here  If I was to go back in time, I would get the Lexus ES300H instead of the E class. To me nothing supersedes peace of mind, especially as I use my cars less & keep them long. If I used my cars a lot, I would be even more concerned about reliability. Merc needs to learn from BMW on this front. And both need to learn from Toyota.
Last edited by L8ButV8 : 8th July 2024 at 23:11.
|