China: The road to electric is filled with tiny cars

The Rationalist · 9th January 2024, 20:21

To be honest the Kei type of cars won't make it a success in India as cars is an aspirational thing. Besides the government is hell bent on taxing them like luxury goods. The only way for small cars to succeed will be if government decides to give tax cuts to cars below say <3.5 or 3 metres. But with cars going electric, that may not make a difference as taxation is already low on EV's.

An electric autorickshaw costs around ₹4 lakh, so any reasonable EV car would cost upwards of ₹7 lakh which is too close to Tiago EV, a sure shot recipe for failure. I don't think we will ever see very small cars on our roads. The reason why such cars sell in China is because the car buying population is too big when compared to India and the base of the pyramid are the one's buying these small EV's, means those who are the least affordable class. If India ever grows that big, maybe it will happen here.

Nikhil Beke · 22nd March 2024, 08:19

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nikhil Beke

Just read this (factually correct) comment, only to realise my apprehensions to be realistic regards a micro-EV.

Punch.ev may be a fabulous car (and kudos to Tata for putting together a drool-worthy package, prices not withstanding), but it would have this unforseen, unintended consequence of killing this segment of micro- cars (again, after Nano and Reva).

...And I'm pretty sad to be proven right, so soon!

"MG Comet sees no production days since June 2023 as monthly sales also could not pick up"
https://www.thehindubusinessline.com...le67968893.ece

volkman10 · 16th July 2024, 10:28

The Chinese car brands positioning in one chart.

There are 11 major Chinese carmakers and many minor ones. The former group includes a bunch of brands that include low-cost ones up to luxury ones. Then there is the group of the minor OEMs that includes the start-ups.

9th January 2024, 20:21	#31
The Rationalist BANNED Join Date: Apr 2015 Location: Kochi Posts: 924 Thanked: 7,290 Times	Re: China: The road to electric is filled with tiny cars To be honest the Kei type of cars won't make it a success in India as cars is an aspirational thing. Besides the government is hell bent on taxing them like luxury goods. The only way for small cars to succeed will be if government decides to give tax cuts to cars below say <3.5 or 3 metres. But with cars going electric, that may not make a difference as taxation is already low on EV's. An electric autorickshaw costs around ₹4 lakh, so any reasonable EV car would cost upwards of ₹7 lakh which is too close to Tiago EV, a sure shot recipe for failure. I don't think we will ever see very small cars on our roads. The reason why such cars sell in China is because the car buying population is too big when compared to India and the base of the pyramid are the one's buying these small EV's, means those who are the least affordable class. If India ever grows that big, maybe it will happen here.
	(2) Thanks

16th July 2024, 10:28	#33
volkman10 Distinguished - BHPian Join Date: Dec 2010 Location: -- Posts: 24,211 Thanked: 71,698 Times View My Garage	Re: China: The road to electric is filled with tiny cars The Chinese car brands positioning in one chart. There are 11 major Chinese carmakers and many minor ones. The former group includes a bunch of brands that include low-cost ones up to luxury ones. Then there is the group of the minor OEMs that includes the start-ups.
	(3) Thanks