|
Search Forums |
Advanced Search |
Go to Page... |
Search this Thread | 117,109 views |
17th September 2017, 12:26 | #121 | |
Senior - BHPian Join Date: Nov 2006 Location: Bengaluru
Posts: 4,375
Thanked: 2,256 Times
| Re: Bullet Train in India - What it means for the country? Quote:
Somewhere I read that the infrastructure needed for India in about 15 years is only 10 or 15% done ! It needs serious grounds up investment not the top line show off kind. Govt plan is for $134 billion for improvement in railways and 20 billion just for safety. Is this really happening ? Last edited by srishiva : 17th September 2017 at 12:43. | |
(2) Thanks |
The following 2 BHPians Thank srishiva for this useful post: | NPX, saurabh2711 |
|
17th September 2017, 12:56 | #122 | |
BHPian Join Date: May 2007 Location: BLR MCT
Posts: 968
Thanked: 902 Times
| Re: Bullet Train in India - What it means for the country? Quote:
It is going to be a good pilot project to assess feasibility for the rest of the country. I just hope the tech is ready to take future upgrades, say 20years down the line. I remember seeing a failed project in Panaji, of a suspended rail network. Nothing to embarrass you more than adopting tech that will be obsolete before the project is done. My pessimism is not pointed at just the ruling party alone. The opposition will have a hand too, in creating the said hurdles. Anyways, it is early days and maybe I can be more optimistic in the near future. I am thrilled at the idea of the bullet trains in India. I am aware of the Chinese and Japanese bidding for it over the past couple of years. I can also see why the Japs go the opportunity(the political mood). Last edited by Mafia : 17th September 2017 at 13:03. | |
(1) Thanks |
The following BHPian Thanks Mafia for this useful post: | saurabh2711 |
17th September 2017, 13:50 | #123 | ||
BHPian Join Date: Aug 2012 Location: Bangalore
Posts: 149
Thanked: 158 Times
| Re: Bullet Train in India - What it means for the country? Why do we not see that infrastructure has to be planned for future requirements? Is our per capita GDP standing still to claim that people will not be able to afford this? Here is an interesting presentation I found made by someone TERI. It talks about market survey,energy efficiency and some projections of revenue. http://iced.cag.gov.in/wp-content/up...TP%2003/SP.pdf I honestly feel that this is a peanuts investment that needed to have happened 10 years ago. Any such large capital expenditure on heavy engineering and infra always pays back many fold. Take for example making our own steam turbines now through BHEL (thermal power units from Russia and the Japanese being reverse engineered) to latest development of companies like Triveni etc who make and overhaul these turbines for GE and export them. We always need exposure to the best technologies. There were plans to set up semi conductor fabs in India in the 90s, if people then weren't so short sighted and had the courage to invest, we could have been competitors to Taiwan and the ancillaries that it resulted in. HTC comes to mind. Someone mentioned village led development previously, I think the letters between Vishveswaraya and the Mahatma make for interesting reading. A model that has failed repeatedly for the last 70 years can't be looked at positively anymore. I have attached a small excerpt, I came across these letters when I visited the MV museum at his birthplace just outside Bangalore. Quote:
Quote:
Last edited by Gannu_1 : 18th September 2017 at 20:05. Reason: Removing unwanted spacing. | ||
(11) Thanks |
The following 11 BHPians Thank Diesel_convert for this useful post: | dailydriver, deep_bang, directinjection, frictionangel, kiku007, Lobogris, rulerofsun, sahibrain, srishiva, sri_tesla, theexperthand |
17th September 2017, 14:55 | #124 |
BANNED | Re: Bullet Train in India - What it means for the country? Isn't it much cheaper to develop aviation than spend billions on bullet trains? Bullet train cost is only a small part of total expense. The real expense will be laying elevated high-speed track, then maintaining it and all the bridges, tunnels and viaducts along the way. In case of aviation , just maintain two airports at either end and you are good to go. By aviation here, I mean air taxis. The propeller planes. No bullet train can beat an aircraft in speed. Even a piston-engined plane. Judging by the costs involved, I'm sure bullet train ticket will be more than a plane ticket, thereby defeating the purpose. A pricier ticket will mean lots of empty seats in bullet train. Somehow, I'm skeptical. In my town, I saw the RTC introduce an AC bus in some route and withdraw it later owing to empty seats. People wait for non-AC buses to save money. Our purchasing power is not high. I lost count how many times RTC did this in my town in any given route. I feel that small regional air taxis would serve better. It's lot cheaper to maintain two airports at either end than full length of track along the way. Is this why big countries like Russia, Canada, US, Australia do not have bullet trains? |
(2) Thanks |
The following 2 BHPians Thank pgsagar for this useful post: | aaggoswami, vinit |
17th September 2017, 19:54 | #125 |
BHPian Join Date: Jul 2015 Location: Coimbatore
Posts: 703
Thanked: 904 Times
| Re: Bullet Train in India - What it means for the country? A country with this big transportation need should have bullet train for faster connectivity. I have seen in China - there is a bullet train running between the cities Shanghai and Nanjing. The distance is about 300 km and it is covered in 1h 20 mins. People living in cities like Suzhou can travel in 30 min to Shanghai and Nanjing due to the train. Many travel almost every day. All this was possible due to the fast bullet train. I saw this way back in 2012 and there were several such cities connected. Getting the technology in India at least in 2022 is a good news and we should welcome with open minds. |
(3) Thanks |
The following 3 BHPians Thank hybridpetrol for this useful post: | Lobogris, saurabh2711, sri_tesla |
17th September 2017, 20:38 | #126 |
BHPian Join Date: Aug 2014 Location: DEL, SFO
Posts: 937
Thanked: 2,918 Times
| Re: Bullet Train in India - What it means for the country? The negativity here surprises me. Any modern infrastructure should be welcomed. This is already at least 10 years late for us. Look at the example of Delhi Metro. Today it carries almost 3 million people daily and has a network of approximately 250 Kms. When we started building it in late 90s, you could have argued that the money can be better spent on roads, trains, education, sanitation and so on. In a massive country like India, we have to work on several projects in tandem. We need India to become a more modern nation and any step in that direction is good news. In any case, all governments end up spending all their revenues on dubious projects. If there were to be no new infrastructure development, you can rest assured that the money would have been spent on some other less useful project. Coming to the cost, at around 15 to 18 billion US$, it is peanuts for India. Yes, peanuts. The Rafale deal costs more than this as one example. India's annual budget expenditure (just for central government) is around 400 billion $. Here we are talking about paying 15 billion over 50 years. That is a payment of just 300 million $ per year. For an economy touching 3 trillion $, this is not even on the radar. In addition, India's GDP and budget would keep on growing. In a decade, the budget would at least double, making it easier to pay back any loan amount. India spends nearly 50 billion $ on defence every single year and that figure keeps growing rapidly. I would actually welcome a network of multiple lines to be developed in tandem. A cost of say 100 billion $ over 10 years is quite manageable for a large nation like India. The overall modernisation and technological advancement coupled with new jobs generated will more than make up for the cost. Coming to people's concerns regarding cattle and so forth, most of the tracks will be elevated. Hence there will be no such issues. We need to look towards the future. This line will be ready in around 5 years. By then our GDP and incomes would have increased by around 50 to 100 % depending on how fast we can grow. We can't apply today's metrics and today's solutions to the future. Otherwise we wouldn't have computers, the internet, airports or expressways until everyone is rich and there is no poverty remaining. |
(13) Thanks |
The following 13 BHPians Thank Lobogris for this useful post: | aaggoswami, deep_bang, directinjection, jvm_1986, karthik_tp, ksameer1234, LordSharan, NiXTriX2004, sagarpadaki, sandeepmohan, saurabh2711, sri_tesla, V.Narayan |
18th September 2017, 09:38 | #127 | |
BHPian Join Date: Jun 2009 Location: Thane
Posts: 191
Thanked: 148 Times
| Re: Bullet Train in India - What it means for the country? Quote:
The bullet train seems to be a great altenative to airplanes and airports. It will also be faster as you do not have to reach the station 3 hours in advance. Right now, the time taken by me to drop my sis at the airport and return to my home in Mumbai is same as the filght time taken by her to reach BLR. | |
(2) Thanks |
The following 2 BHPians Thank rulerofsun for this useful post: | directinjection, sri_tesla |
18th September 2017, 10:01 | #128 | ||
BHPian Join Date: Feb 2007 Location: New Delhi
Posts: 80
Thanked: 59 Times
| Re: Bullet Train in India - What it means for the country? Quote:
Air travel is for point to point long distance travel. Rail travel connects all the in between points. HSR systems in Europe has shown that both can coexist and carve out their own niches. In Japan, the distances are not so big, so HSR makes even more sense. I think that for a country like India it is not a matter of should we go for HSR, but rather when we should go for HSR. IMO the sooner the better. Quote:
If you have worked with Japanese contractors and Japanese companies, then you will know that they have superb processes that not only take into consideration all the issues we face here in India, but they also have solutions that most Indians seem to either ignore or choose to not implement. If Delhi Metro could achieve what it did with domestic talent, I am expecting that the addition of Japanese technology and supervision could make even more changes. Maybe we will see a rub off effect in the construction industry and get closer to world class standards We also need to consider one more thing, this project is happening because the Japanese government is giving loans at very favourable terms. They can do this because they have extra money lying around for which they dont have many investment opportunities. It is a win win for everyone, the Japanese get to boost their industry, make sure that India does not go to other suppliers of HSR and also get a better rate of return on capital than what they are getting currently. India gets a HSR system virtually for free plus Japanese tech transfer. We cant be using these funds to upgrade existing rail infrastructure or feed the poor. OTOH this project has the chance of making the Ahmedabad-Mumbai industrial corridor even more developed and generate tons of additional jobs because of the multiplier effect that infrastructure has in the economy. At some level doubting the bullet train project is akin to looking the gift horse in the mouth. -- no1lives4ever Last edited by no1lives4ever : 18th September 2017 at 10:06. | ||
(5) Thanks |
The following 5 BHPians Thank no1lives4ever for this useful post: | directinjection, Gannu_1, Lobogris, sri_tesla, V.Narayan |
18th September 2017, 10:23 | #129 | |
BHPian Join Date: Apr 2016 Location: Hyderabad
Posts: 960
Thanked: 5,432 Times
| Re: Bullet Train in India - What it means for the country? Quote:
Bullet train will definitely not ideal for countries like Canada and Australia. Between, Russia has a bullet train between two of its major cities Moscow and St Petersberg started in 2009. Again both these cities have high population and not very far (700 KM). | |
(1) Thanks |
The following BHPian Thanks sri_tesla for this useful post: | Lobogris |
18th September 2017, 10:40 | #130 | |
Team-BHP Support | Re: Bullet Train in India - What it means for the country? For some perspective, here is a 17 year old article on wastefulness of GOLDEN QUADRILATERAL project. Roads to nowhere - The prime minister's dream highway project is a nightmare for taxpayers. http://indiatoday.intoday.in/story/a.../1/243614.html Quote:
Last edited by SmartCat : 18th September 2017 at 10:45. | |
(16) Thanks |
The following 16 BHPians Thank SmartCat for this useful post: | ampere, arvind71181, Eddy, Gannu_1, hybridpetrol, kiku007, ksameer1234, Latheesh, Lobogris, LordSharan, Mafia, n.devdath, praveen789, sri_tesla, Sutripta, V.Narayan |
18th September 2017, 10:45 | #131 |
Senior - BHPian Join Date: Nov 2009 Location: RJ-02,DL,MH-12
Posts: 1,352
Thanked: 2,239 Times
| Re: Bullet Train in India - What it means for the country? If the businesses can have inorganic growth why can't a country look at the inorganic growth options. Bullet train for one should be able to provide us the much needed access to technology and the associated testing ground for its further expansion in India. Calcutta Metro was the first one in India, yet the technology was not global and thus further expansion in other cities didn't happen; flip it and see Delhi Metro which paved way for other cities to opt for Metro and in about two decades of operations, this has become successful transportation solution in many cities. Grade separation, BRT and several other experiments have failed miserably in cities with higher vehicle density. Alternate & dedicated transportation solution are the way to go. We always look for reliable, convenient, and fast mobility solution to reduce stress on existing infrastructure and this will be one. Lets hope this succeeds in India and we get possible replicated solutions for other cities / industrial hubs. I am all in and in favour of having alternate and more reliable transportation solutions. This will be such a massive investment that discontinuing it will not be possible, instead Government will fine tune it for success. Mind you tickets for Concorde flights were costly, yet it had better occupancy compared to Boeing 747 transatlantic connections ! |
(2) Thanks |
The following 2 BHPians Thank i74js for this useful post: | saurabh2711, sri_tesla |
|
18th September 2017, 12:23 | #132 | ||||
BHPian Join Date: Feb 2007 Location: New Delhi
Posts: 80
Thanked: 59 Times
| Re: Bullet Train in India - What it means for the country? We need to also consider that HSR is a proven concept that has benefited many countries. At this point it is a 50 year old technology and there are countless studies to show how it has helped countries. India is a perfect example of a country where HSR makes huge sense. We have high population density, lots of towns with decent population that are not too far apart and a growing economy that can afford air travel. But all I see on this thread are people who are trying to find reasons why it is a bad idea. This is something that seems to affect Indians whenever there is something new and shiny in the country. I remember in 1983 people saw the Maruti 800 and said it was a small car that they would never consider even getting inside, forget owning. Within next 5 years, almost all of them had a Maruti 800. smartcat has posted a nice example of this phenomenon wrt the golden quadrilateral project. This should come up as a reality check for those of us who are looking at the negatives of having a HSR vs doing something else. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
-- no1lives4ever Last edited by no1lives4ever : 18th September 2017 at 12:37. | ||||
(5) Thanks |
The following 5 BHPians Thank no1lives4ever for this useful post: | directinjection, Gannu_1, jvm_1986, sri_tesla, V.Narayan |
18th September 2017, 13:51 | #133 |
BHPian | Re: Bullet Train in India - What it means for the country?
I think they will push for it to coincide with India's 75th Independence anniversary and with the Japanese anything is possible. |
(1) Thanks |
The following BHPian Thanks Whiplash7 for this useful post: | sahibrain |
18th September 2017, 15:23 | #134 |
Senior - BHPian Join Date: Oct 2009 Location: BANG-A-LURE.
Posts: 1,209
Thanked: 4,664 Times
| Re: Bullet Train in India - What it means for the country? China has connected 70% of its cities totaling 22,000 kms with HSR network.Beijing–Shenzhen is the Longest HSR in the World covering 2,203 kms in 8 hours. Imagine travelling from Bangalore to Delhi in 8 hours and pay just 50% of the airfare.I would love to do that. Waseem. |
(6) Thanks |
The following 6 BHPians Thank SILVERWOOD for this useful post: | aroonanand, directinjection, hybridpetrol, n.devdath, no1lives4ever, V.Narayan |
18th September 2017, 17:47 | #135 | |
BHPian Join Date: Jul 2015 Location: Coimbatore
Posts: 703
Thanked: 904 Times
| Re: Bullet Train in India - What it means for the country? Quote:
On the other hand, visionaries ignore such cries and step forward towards their goal to make the country a better place to live. Several years later, now we have the 4-laned highways connecting length and breadth of the country. Instead, if we had used up the money to subsidize something else, our infrastructure would be in much worse state. In the initial years, the metro rail projects were frowned upon, and was seen to silently increase transportation cost, and seen as messing up the roads and catering only to upper middle class & the rich. After we have successfully running metros in a few cities, now there are voices asking for metros in almost every town. And I sincerely believe that, there should be some action to study and bring it to each Indian city, so there will be some help in reducing congestion. At some point of time, when we completely move towards the EVs, we might completely do away with the current concept of 100-150cc bikes and use low speed electric bikes and Metros/buses as the primary mode of transport apart from cars. To reduce congestion further, we may even have laws, such as the ones in Singapore, making ownership of a car pretty expensive affair. All this law enforcement requires, faster & efficient public transport as pre-requisite. So, investments in metro rails, mono rails, BRTs, broader roads with several lanes, expressways, bullet trains, maglevs and any initiative to move people in an efficient way should be supported. It is true that, instead of x, government can do y or z. Everyone has an opinion of what can be done with money, but this investment in bullet trains tries to make our infrastructure better, and it is a long term plan. Let us keep the negative articles from Op-Ed pages archived, so we can discuss and laugh about them after the Bullet train starts carrying people! | |
(8) Thanks |
The following 8 BHPians Thank hybridpetrol for this useful post: | directinjection, jvm_1986, kiku007, ksameer1234, no1lives4ever, SmartCat, sri_tesla, V.Narayan |